ࡱ> z|wxyq` RbjbjqPqP24::3. IIIId>JDKJKKKKK0\dFHHHHHH$=hNllKKlllKKqqqlKKFqlFqqqKJ xېIzqqF0Kqqqqf"$hiq j|jhhhllqhhhKllll//T*   VERlTf[ b_`0}TNz:W \O: HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq" \t "_blank" [eP:_ | S^e:2007-9-2 17:24:49 | pe: 788 [,gehQeSh(WHtQo;N 0RNlċ 02007t^,{20wS ,{566-609u] [  ,gwSvStKN\O/f HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_v 0VERlTf[b_`0}TNz:W 0Ne \O(W,ge-NcQN VERlTf[ v}T v^[dkۏLNRekvc [NcGSVERlf[vTtS z^eg ُ/fNyyOf[OSO VEf[/gVY _VQlf[[/UNVY 0-NVRlf[OoRO0SN'Yf[lf[bHtQoYec ;Nn} T \^n} ] %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%  VERlTf[ b_`0}TNz:W*  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_** RlTf[/fbv|^y[V   HtQo* yr[lTf[t NSN(Wlf[KNꁨRlbc VERlwQ g YTOagyr_   ]eY<\** VEďNe>yO VERNy^NN/fW'`y^ vQ,g_NW,ge^   \O N0 VERlTf[ vcQ NfvN

PT vQtcۏtS/f(Na bav0[4],ge\OяegsHQcQv^RekN VERNll international rule of criminal law/international rule of law in criminal justice/international rule of law in penal field[5]VERNSlWvllr` v}T [6]v^N TNLuNVERNll vNRsQ|:NƉ҉ [vQefW@xN'`0le'`0V['`0'YV?el0gz;NIN0[YeOPgb 0?elW@xll0VEll0VERNll{kR0N6R0bN T‰_W@x;NCg0CgR0NCg N*N͑ۏLNReko~0[7]PN{E^ \Ol[VERNllvcQ0tb_`0;N}TNSz:WNۏLhQbU\_0sQN RNll (uN RNlTf[ vsQ| HtQoYec gǏ|nxv RNll (WgyaIN N/fbR vN*N͋Gl b`(u͋eghRNlWvllr`  RNll,g1\ N/fN*NĉRlf[v}T /fRNlTf[v[@bcv N/fRNlvĉ /fRNlvNyOyf[W(W~SYdkvpr lf[Nlf[iY0ُ/f-NNSlef[/gɉaƋSvyv01\lf[TtS bN]~SN,T0R lNll rule of civil law/civil rule of lawlNWvllr` b VElNll international rule of civil law/international rule of law in civil field WTOWv1u8fy^r` I{NN:N#kpavf[/gۏ0^:W~Nm0QY~1u/fll>yOvlNW@x T7h V[v1u8fy^_N/f VEll international rule of law vlNW@x0FO/f^S_b -NVv RlTf[ kz/fHQLNek  /fgeQsTtSBlNRvN*Nf[y 0[10]HN VERlf[vzz`7h pTTf[ bT>f f -NV RlTf[ ]~YcOYv~TYe]eY<\YecI{ef[vce_NNNNuS0N[v`a0S_6q ,ge@bv VERlTf[ v^ N[hQI{ TN N'Y^Nve[Oag0 N0 VERlf[vwƋb_`NN

yOf[0ltf[TlTf[ NKNb_bN[vB\!k0Nf6q (W weg  RlTf[ /f lTf[ v g:ggb N/fNy NRsQ| 0HN  lTf[ S/fNHNbTُNvaIN(WN\O:N Tf[ b Nfv0MRQNN/fNy~|vN

/f[VERlvNyOf[0lN{|f[0l~Nmf[0l^yf[elO gyrk(uY0\O:NN

e'` }T_>e0RN[ z^T SO|_N1\4l0R nb0S_6q Ne_ĉNN[ʑ eleIN ʑNtʑ|~ʑ0SSʑ0vv'`ʑ elOG [0  SO| /fbNvOP}Y0 bSO| /fbNv NaBlTؚ^0 SO|Re /fbNvgؚt`0 SO| e'`0 NR8h_}T vNRޏT6R~ /fVERlNyONyOs[0ُNNyO?eV{[/fn*NNBl؏/f>yO[/f[s*NNvbQ(Wvx^ybn؏/f>yOvv[/f[sb/ecNyyr[v?e^b__؏/fnNN>yO?elb~Nmt`[/f[syr[vv؏/fu_yr[ĉI{I{0[mDdُNt` TeS N@\PNvQ-NKNN0;`KN [/fNyR[v0NSv0R)RvTO͑ z^vTf[  e(W)nT0W[sS fV[ƖSO~~TVE^l>yO^l Tvyr[Ne_[51uvNN e NO g1u _N NO g[hQ 0[26] 1udkS ]eY<\YecvTf[ 1\/f lQck Tf[01uN[/f R[v T R)Rv @bNY}TNz:WON{ N T1uN[/f lQckv 0 NSv T O͑ z^v Y}TNz:W_N1\ON{яyONVEy^v N T?agNBl RgRVERlNyO:ONHeS^:g6R0dkY hQtScۏNVERNSlSU\ FO/fُySU\v^ N&{Tk*NV[)Rv0yr+R/f'YV)Rv'YVsQl Vrj OYP``;NINrj  VERNSlRfsQl :_Ll rj0[29]S ]eY<\v Tf[a S_eg s[ Tf[sTS_Negm0NvTf[fP?eV{f[ N_Nvnx;`/fb Tf[N?eV{ ~TNv0Tf[Q[?eV{ ?eV{SOsTf[ FO/f^S_b Tf[eYUO NI{N?eV{0bTf[I{N?eV{ Tf[1\bN_(uTf[ 1\bN[V{f[ g~/fTf[,gS[ ?eV{RO~~:g^S0ُ N/f{`a-NvTf[ \ N/fhQ0 ?elTf[_N/fTf[ N/f͑vTf[0sQN?elTf[}T ]eY<\N>yOQY~0R VEQY~ ُ/f{vR_~Tcl N T vo~wQyrr yOQY~ social contract wQ gSSve_yNb YvCg)R bc_V[ObvQbXTv#N0 gNݏS~[ 1\j g^_0Was just desert mS`Z0 N/fWN>yOQY~bb/f>yOy^{6R g~~v>yOeR:YN*NNۏLUSe YNbQeNmvCg)R  RNQeNmR_NV[0lNQeNmR_N*NN0VERNSl6R^vSU\N6q>yOQY~GP[ WNeEQ'`i_ `ZvCg)R!n~ N*NT\OSO| a cooperative system T#cOSlv^g~nxOTs^0[30]T!nNNHNُ/fN*NsQ.vkXzz0]eY<\vT{Hh/f*NNT N*NT\OSO| !nN`ZCg0ُ*N T\OSO| 1\/fc VE>yO ُ_N^S_/fN*N g~~v>yO 0ُ̑vsQ.>f6q/f*NNTVE>yOvc!nN`ZCg NX[(WcS06q (WS S_N>yOTf[ e ]eY<\yO g:NNLuNlcO[hQv#N0Vdk VE>yOc{N[e*NN`Zb_yNb Yv*NNCg)R0NdkяyO TINLR OYuNfMQCg)R0~g Ǐ(u NlQckvfMQ ُyOYug;xNckINɋBl0S g(WjrmSYvRZuv^WNNSQe fMQMb/flQckv0Ndk Te V[؏OYuN[yr[rjvwɋT`Zv1uϑCg FO/fv^^@b gV[ُ7hZP vS [NBl:_LwɋT`Z0[31]NyO @bN V[N>yO TINLR ُ_N1\I{N[EcS !n v /fV[b V[SO| N/f VE>yO 0 Ndk Te V[؏OYuNfMQCgT1uϑCg0ck8^v;/f/U g!nMb gOYu0HN V[\O:N OYu  _N !n NHNNT cgq]eY<\Yecvl l g  !n S/f*NN0Ydk NvQV[ OYu NNHN NYV[ *b b {9e NNHN0(W]eY<\ weg \O:N `ZCgvcS V[NVE>yOv^l g'Yv]+R g[Tf[vsTS ُck/fvsQ.0N(WS RZvSS'`MRc T j g^_ just desert e[vQ VEQY~ ~~o~0R9hnc>yOQY~t [e`ZvCg)R!n~ƖSOcollectivity ƖSONLQY~L#0Vdk VERNSlvN,SR/fX[(Wv[Nb gV gvT NSRrRvCg)R g_ N/fV[bb/fVEl_y^[$RN`Zyr[ĉvݏl0dkY l_6R^؏^T[NcO[Bl_^_vTPvCg)R0[32]ُ̑  N*NT\OSO| SbN ƖSO ُ*N ƖSO HN/f V[ HN/f VEl_y^ [Tf[+T| Nnv(W~~9_OY0(WS :_LlVErjNnfMckIN e ]eY<\YecQ!kc0RvQ >yOQY~ >yOQY~tBl[yr+R/fݏS:_LlvrjL:NZP0R gj_Z0:_LlrjwQ gnfMvS4#'`T'Yĉ!jv_c[ (W28yVErj-N S g:_Llrj0Rdky z^ @bNVERNSl6R^_{:NdkcOSh`Z:g6Ra dual track of access to justice 0[33] Sh 1\ NPN VE`Z Nh V[`ZSO|_NbNh0(WS 'YfNVERNSl6R^ e ]eY<\Yec[>yOQY~ۏLNgTo~>yOQY~9hWNl_ST>yONyOQY~ VE>yO_N`ZjrvCg)R ُ/f&T_NSbfMQCg)RbTN,:N fMQCg)R/f+T(W`ZCg)R-Nv06q Yg`ZCg)R1u[N!n~VE>yO HNfMQvCg)R1\O[NOYu N(WVE>yOKb-N0>yOQY~/f&T&T[NVEl_y^fMQ:_LlrjvCg)R /fN*NX[(WNv0Vdk Yg`ZCg,geg^\N[N VEl_>yOS/fN[Nv TINLO`ZCg HNbcegv1\ N/fhQb'Yfb?elek0?el$R[N;N'YV TINN gj NZbc_?el㉳Q A~_c[[NvCg)R ݏSVERNSl>yOQY~0fMQS(W$RQKNT0[yr[rjv^OncckS_t1uZPQ0[34]^S_b ]eY<\Yec(WgTN;R~N[sNޘÍ[N:_Llrj N/fV[؏/fVE>yO l gfMQCg)R fMQCg)ROYu(W[N !n`ZCg Kb-N?el$R[T;N'YV N*b0{9eTn(uُyCg)R0Ydk  `ZCgvcS vzz/f_N1\ N͑N0(Wb weg ]eY<\v VEQY~ vzQNyOQY~ V[>yONVE>yOwQ gvyO/f;NCgV[v)YX vl1\eNzN0*NN8l܏/fQY~>yOv8h_;NSO N/fV[>yO؏/fVE>yO0,{N N,{NvsQ *NN/f`ZCgv/UN !n ;NSO V[vMRS/f TIN Nh N*b0{9eTn(uُNCg)R0Ydk V[1\ N/fVERZCgv!n;NSO [_N1\l gQ OYu NNHNOYi`fI{ v;NSODf f ُ/fNy[hQ N Tv VEQY~ 0N, @b VEQY~ 1\/f;NCgV[!nbP6R;NCgvQY~0=\{~k TR_ FO1\zQ*NNvQY~;NSO0WMO ]eY<\Yecvo~>f6qf[f_Q VENCgؚe N v~ Ndk Te؏υb'Y'YQ1_NVERlf[ LeƉ;NCg v?elsTS0 sQNN'`0V['`SvQlbc ]eY<\_N gr0R0gr0Rv㉫ǏNN'`VESNV[:NNh NT v`'` gXeQ0N /UNSN[v/fV[RNSlvTf[N?eV{\N*NN:NW@x ُNV[RNSlv T*NN[eNVQNVErj ^bavlNV[b~~ @b:N& & ꁚN̑XY_Neg Tf[[0L:Nf[[T>yOf[[bN{|:Nv`v6q>PT /fL:N1u*NN'`lSbƖSO'`NT O9eS,g'`T*NNNƖSOfLv N T,g(/f&TSQNL:N/f(WNVWKNQbb^8ONVWVLuvOc O_wfLv[(yr_v%`gR9eSTT{Hh/fmgv =\{ƖSOfLvƖTHe^Ǐ*NNL:Nv;`T0N'` gv`vNb NS,gqO >yOc6R1_Sb1Yupe v`'`1\OnmQ4lbv^ b~p'`Tg0~hf |pN{|efvnx N*XNQ0V[0V[>yObVE~~I{ba[SONNV:N/f1u*NNR6RT{t X[(W [N NSMQ0WSN{|v6q,g6R~ُNba[SOvƖSO'`QV{ z^vN\O(u wQ gNċ0Ovؚ^ YBg'` FO/f N{|v6q,g;`O[g~~gSuq_T0[35]*NN/fVERlTf[N?eV{vW@xVLu N;eT9eSN'`N'`Q[Tq_TV[,g'`V[vv`'`*NNv`'`ُ/f]eY<\Tf[v͑}T0 (W]eY<\vTf[-N l gNUOOk VERNSlN?el b fNN PauRN0N[VERNSloSSSv ?el_Q`~ wegk{f:Nm͑0l_1\/f?el FO/f l_ N/f?elvUS~]wQ &TR1\/fv`?el0l^y?elя ckIN1\NNuu0(W]eY<\ weg QNNkNyVERN[$R!j_EQn?elu0bNwS  VESmTl^ /fVERNSlvgeR FO/f bN(Wy"}l yr+R/f(W^Xb)Rf0N^vl $\vQ/fgW[ tS[f w0RfYv ?el 6R~Tr^pb0]eY<\[dk gUOċ$RbTN:NVESmTl^vz:ONN'`TnfM'` /f[tO?el bvyr[~g0[NHN;xVERNlb HN1\/f[TveEQ  ُ/fSNyaIN Nv eEQSR 01948-1993t^ TTVqQ g55!k~TLR bTSl^tSH\cSpe0vQ T7hX[(W$Ny?el‰_vZS_?els[;NIN:N bTvb^'`SlY[Ts^  ُ/fNy?el㉳QvYIZ(uvS ?elt'`;NIN:N l gSlckIN1\ NO gTs^01uNMRE\/eM0WMO RKNQbV }q_T bTSlv@\b1\S` w0Y?e^:N VERNSl‰_v^^VEl_y^v g:ggb[P6R?els[;NINeS%c\O(u ;x?elfMQ N)RN~_gQz0?els[;NIN؏:N TVQzT Nv T ~TNTV{euT Nv T V #N!j__N_6qYyY7h ~ NPNSl!j_0v0R1992-2003t^ VE:_Llrj_{~KNNlv‰_MbncS0FO/fďN:Nbk NNv‰_\*g~N0s gvmT!j_g'Yv:w(WN N:N:_SV[Sl6R^ZPQ!.s0u gN:N mTl^ NǏ/f'YV[]*gSe gHe2Tr^rjvNy `j !j_0dkY QN~TNSlckIN:S+R'Y $NyRϑN[ N_NvN0|_dkobv0'YVv?ela?aQ[TTVvRTg~ b0vQ-N ~9NNRegnsQ͑0gT mTl^,g( N/fV[l^ NƉ:N^\NVERNvcgbL!j_ ُ_Nck/f V[{OHQ t_vvcS f0[36] HN (W]eY<\ weg vQN@b O'Yv 0 N~v 0 ckIN [$RSYUObTNv;`SOċNv^l g9eS1919t^1994t^NuN5*Nyr+RVEgYXTO04*NVERNl^03*NVES{tbcCgvV[lQɋ0FO/f [NtS_\ZWcLNvh  Nrz0 gHeTlQckvelN z^LckIN0=\{ z^T Nv T gelQ_ ge= [NvnxH\NN?elvv0?elQ[[TR0NNTl_V ۏ [l^1hЏL0[PvT"?evTl(uegc[0\Pbk0[gTg~sQl^ /fWN?elSV0?el[N~8^EeaOeޘ ُ7h ckINvlQqQ)Rv1\Oen) lQOSR1\Oenm1Y nxOl^LckINvSR_N1\ppޘpmpN0OY OS~VKN@bNl g[W3vQ[XT(W1915t^'Yĉ!j`\@gN<\NNvfLǑSl_LR ;N/fV:Nb__SW3vQv N3z[0bbNev~l6B\|0(WW3vQzb_eu~rςTv e5% I{0QY _vZ^NNKN@bNO elY /fV:N 0Q\[ag~ 0,{227ag,g1\Q ?el rj+TIN %N͑ݏSVESINTag~ \%N l gcQNUO]wvVErj ُ1\:NwpQ?e^b~_!ncONl_OncdkY OS~V 4# wpQ (WNNN weg ُ_N/fOS~VMQzl^vNye_0N̑e,g[$R R/fVENVQ?ela?a[S0ۏ zrrrVEckINvxQWOS~VfsQ_'k2mv*gegTs^ N/fckIN ,{N!kNbS_e_N^l:N ~_gNRbNvbN ?el~[:_SN$aNZO‰_cynicism ^yrR_N(W1939t^_a0W N)Y؏(WkmpN<\NNv I{NlQ_SV :_CgKNl܀Ǐll the rule of might overshadows the rule of law 0Nbg 1u17VAmN?e^Nh~bvTTV[brgYXTO>Nek~p g~1Y[N1942-1945 a'Y)RvWYbr750N _NhQ elY`Sa'Y)Rv^Q[[$Rbr FO/fQqQN;NIN%_+o'k2m 9eiTvle;NINSck/fqQN;NINvLeN :N2bkVQ?elS9_ g~Q[>e_[$Rv^b~T[V[W^XOkN0 ^J0)RkNTWSeb+Y _!nbr0Ǐ~&O!X[$R ςTN[sN 9eQSS vvvlpQ sSOl gNUOHQO VN_NN9eǏSvz:W /ec qS[N{|j T qS[Ts^j QbgSQ!k9eSz:W [$RNbPone-sided JT8^eR:Y(NS؋Cg)R _Nl gNUOOS~VNXTmG[$R0N 0{6RYXTO,{10Sl_ 0KN Nv`SV[$R R/fVV?ela?av1uʑ>eVl^1unfl[[$R vQN NVl^1uQNl^[$RςT[L{f[$R l gb gl_~S vQN NVTevQl0vVv ܏NYXTO ,gegqQ g11V vQ-N00-N0ςb g&TQCgN/fN*N?el:gg N/fg:gg0(WKQ?_tvc$cKN N YXTONN*N1u[WekeQ[PN{k0ُ_N/f܏Nl^*g1uag~zv;N?elSVςTS/f(We,gb%MRpehTSb V[ςTʉΉ܏N~Q͑͑V_N N ^gςTq_T܏Nɋς[e,guSfkhVSvQb/g_X[(WopzNV؏sQle,gvbTۏ z0Sl[/fTV?e^Nh N/f*NN[SO ُ1\[YXTOTl^v?elS q_T]\Oy^TSl(ϑ0ɋ z^ NĉЏL Sl[n(u1uϑCg0 c?elhQc JT [$R'YY NlQ0l gNUO TvVNXTmG[$R0l_(usSO N/fv _N/fu͑͑0$RQgbL:ONN'` hQ1u~^?elTccc [$R[E N1\/fV?eV{v[e0dkY (W܏N[$R-N KQ?_t>e_wɋՈN)Yvv?elSV/fOYuv^vb_aOONe,gZTv[[f0_NOQ\Q$ON f)RNS_bTe,g|NXvT\O0sQNq\ NIYe[$R KQ?_t(W_[lwTэ FOSwSW͑eg0`Zbr[$R1\/fُy*NN?ela?avSOs =\{JTe*g}TN_N NwSfL0?el_N(WvQNV[vyr+R[$R-N`Snc͑0WMO @b N TvS/f[NS[$R bN j NmS qS[N{|j 0*`e,gNb(`[$R/f܀)RvckIN /f܀)Rvb Y01955t^1992t^ ckINb:NQb?elvmyT0MRWSl^vy{Y0zTЏL T7hEQn?elSpe01uN gsQ'YVv?elϑSǏSlckIN v^b_]=eQgV #grjvN[YXTO~9w:0e'}0v^cMR~bk]\O01uN'YV%`Nc6Rl^ 1uT'Ybag~zl^vR_NGW&TQ VE>yOǏz8^lbvĞё:gG0e6q1u[tOz [tOtSZPQ*`_vT N_vQ[[tOfwT'Y~9]~%N͑JRQ l^{N1uT'Y# Ol^weQ~9lmo0h[[N}T]\Ovb^_N/fl^?elSvxQWO0dkY ^X\~NTў^XT~~0enfeaSqQTVNSN[ Nvl^X?e^b NNl^T\O [tOSS~_N*gǑSNUOce ُ1\fl^v}TЏ[hQSQN[tOWN~T ZPQv?elQ[0bSevN[YXTON g3N~b _NN]\ON4*Ng NۏLN1fgv[0W]g l g\ONUOg0bJTNNMRWSl^gbJT:N݄,g Q[ NǏ/fvQN[SO0ZSObQHrirbJTvXd hQeMRWSl^bJTv{_^'`0NMRWSl^qQNh[[T NɋR^vR1uVcQ [hQ/fWN~NmQ T7h/fRދ N~sSO/fjf~vvN_N NeSzN̑vcw$NWYɋSO|$N*Nl^(uv[SOl_N Nv TMRWSl^ NɋR^vl[SNnbc bSel^1\ NL0gTS[v؏/fbSel^NMRWSl^ N T bSe?e^b75 000Nr(WHh ,gSN'Y g\O:N FO/f`QR}YvS01uNTR0{tT"?e l^ߏ1996t^11gMb_YEQRЏL0 gv/f S_evbSeck/f[tObXTKNN ُ1\O[tOvQV{fR YBgMRfBl(u{kR [tOb~T'Y ^g_NwɋV܀)R jr bSeb~1uNbSel gTkN9eQ9e0Oۏ z'} __x0NNK{uR=\ YpeOSFU_ReR Ypeؚ[TYNh~~yS MRofenfm0iR NvNhT gO}T _N(WTT?e^ NeGlb0c:yNhNeg?e^vcCg'Y\ NN SV[N,cCgY $Rv[[f NSV[cCgN,\ $Rv[V0P@\(W7g5eSb4x ;N-^c:y Ɩ-NwQSOe,gĉ[ ՋV(W;N N[BlYOSNhN_N_{VT{wQSO0Vvz:WASR}VvQ[Vvz:Wv^ Nnpf ?e^z:W_Nؘ_ N[ (W z^Nrj[IN N0RvvT (W{Nh[[ NN6qb Nek OfR YBg0 0Wlĉ~ 0,{NzmShQ?el _N/fNgbv&qpYg[_1\dkۏLeObkv Wl'YO_\?elgkIN T{k0egꁠRb'YvcN;N-^yegeZPQNb/g'`v?el$ReTLZSzsSۏL cSb>e_ vhQ0pS^TVcQgTOHh ՋV͑_N0*cZcQ NLR R BlR+RhQ0~g pS^cmG114hy&TQ VRmG113hy&TQ hQ:W"k|Tbbc~10R ُ/fYN'YO NUvRN:WbN!kNbT+ovSS'`e z~Nb|_\?elNeNYOSvR/}NSb~ʑ>e0 N`7h 0Wlĉ~ 0؏/fTVYOSN N\ &TR NO/fN)Yُ7h0[37]>f6q ]eY<\[VERNSlvSS'`[ƉNbVYpef[*b6q N T0ُck/fNyOT:Nvh0N,ZTSvQN,2vGP[_NT Nv T0$Ny6R^,gX[(W]'Y]+R @b:yv~gN gsQVErjRZvTf[N?eV{W@xv`V[SlwQ gc~'`T8^ĉ'` :gg0~gTNXTnx[ Vdk1\OX[(WZTN2vHegNg_vS VESl:ON8^ĉ'` ZTvvv1\ NSg_ b^Nj g^_retribution and just desert 1\^/fVERZf:NS_vTf[N?eV{W@x0dkY V[>yOb gTyI{~v?elTN>yOQZ:g6R vhNRv[s_YyY7h N[hQcgSlN[VESlQNN[hQcgyrkgbL:g6RT;S[$R vcgbL:g6R(W NN~80t^NMb_Y _N;N/f yr '`(v vQN#N:g6Rv0RgяMbS0[38]Vdk (W]eY<\ weg 9hncVESlvSU\sr b^NlQck^S_/fVERZvs[vv ُN\Ov llR~6k b Rlr` z:W N T0 V0ll0VEllNVERNllvLu[NsQT l gNUONy}TOkmR ll fRNTf[N N/fTy ll 0s(WSYNN*N T [ Ty ll N T c  T ,gS/fN*NNzfv(u VdkNOR PYg[YeQwSeQُyNOvN 1\OfR YBg0vMR  ll 0 VEll 0 RNll 0 lNll 0 L?ell I{I{ yO^ lly^ W Tv?el[N_NY gS0[42]Ile.(R@b nfMll 0 hQtll I{/f VEll vN(u v^N/f(W hQtCgRf6q/fyrc VERNll vaIN =\{[N VERN[$R B\bN0vQ[ TTVyfN[WS(WċNVERNlbe ]OVERNllvaINQseu VERNlbvz/fȏTnfMNCgNlluniversal human rights and rule of law v͑Nek 0[49]ُ̑v nfM ll N/f+Rv yrcVERNll0dkY sQNVQllNVEllvsQ| \O^X [WSS_g|i_0ghQb ll(WS_NNLub4NqS:g N$a`0W  bN_{NdkSR:Nwpl gNS]l_ _Nl gN N^Sl_Ob0NUO(WVQ \IYllvV[ (WVY_N_{ \͑ll0 T7h @b g(WVYZWcllvV[ _N_{(WVQuLll 0[50]la  (WVY_N_{ \͑ll v1\/f VEll NNǸof[ v1\/f VERNll 0ll;`/f(WN6Rvppp-N_eu VEll_N_6qO(WVEqNvVQllNVEN6RbVQN6RNVEll QY$N _v -NPu [WS NǏ/feNvNN0Tyahf  VERNll ‰_|TKN2kQ0\O:NNyO0VElQqQl_y^NVERNy^vLu[NsQT VEvzz/f g>yO ؏/f e>yO ُSQN[ >yO vt0Onc >yONCQ ~_6q/f VEe>yO vS Onc >yONCQ ~_6q/f VE g>yO VE>yO N TNV[>yO0vQ[ VElv NCQ N NCQ KNN_NwQ gv Tv'`( Ngbvwckwpv^ N(WNlf[ꁫ (WN?elf[N>yOf[vW,gRgk0Vdk [ُN}Tv㉳Qbz y N_l_N[Ty?elN>yOf[vt0 bTZW[0dk  VE>yO vzz^S_/f*NNHN$\ir _6qNzf0ُck/f[ VEll CN VERNll ۏLm^`vp@b(W01\ell>yO 6qlTf[T>yOQY~/fvQ;NTf[N?elf[ bShYeag/fvQƖ-NNh NbX[(W)YXKN+R0l_,g1\/f?el VEl1\/fVE?el0?elTf[wp N T l_t__6qQg Nb0,ge N/f[dkۏLhQbU\_vT0We FO/f SN{cQvNgb&qpO/f VE>yO ^ N^S_SU\bNy zSO>yO YgT{Hh/f[v [52]HNc Negv1\/fُy zSO>yO N ;NCgV[ vzz/fNy`7hvsQ|lQl*NNNCg SN teSOzSO>yO  VE>yO T @\zSO>yO  V[>yO ^z`7hvsQ|S_6q Yg[,{N*NvT{Hh/fmgvvMRُS/fYpeNvT{Hh iRYO1\QNNeQ\OmeQ ]eY<\Yecv YTOagf[ ONSR0vMRvYwQ g['`Tb/g'` fRsQl [6q _Ɖb oƉ ^6q e6qlf[v NLu;NIN R;`/fN;NCgV[ w4Y'}v00R ;NIN S f[>m NOb 0,ge NOؚ>N e6qlf[ 'Ye f NOؚU NLu;NIN 0,gesQlv/UN/fvzz`7ho~Mb&{Tefۏ zTyf[;0 N VE>yO vcvsQvlf[1\/f VElQqQy^ v [?e!j_ 0ُ^S_/fVE[lf[[0VElf[[0VERlf[[vlf[;wp0vQ[ ُck/fef[LuvtppTNpKNN N^f[NeQ NYpS^dY [53] `yrv@b VE[?ey^ t /fNy NeTv 0 vNeEQv 0 qQX['`v  VE[?e!j_ international constitutional model [54](Wb weg ُ_Ne^1\/fNyYSubv agag!j_ T WWWW!j_ v'YBgp S NǏ[?ef[[QN [l b [?e W[yO v^e~Nv WWWW'` y^0bN4ngN|T$U VEll FO/f @b gv VEll qNv_Nck[nNُyy^vBgp'`(0  VElQqQy^ /f VE[?ey^ vs[_h _N/f VEll v?elW@xTh_0 VERNy^ vzz^S_/fNy`7h'`(vy^vMReg w [gY/fNy agag'` y^ N ُyagag'`y^,g_NmqNe^TTVSvQ[tO gvQyr+Ry^OYUSrzbTTzT{|VE'`bVESRNyr+Rl^ VERNlbRNhSNyVERNy^ Nُyy^NTTVb[tONST gsQ;NCgV[\X[(WN[~[ TVvRNVElRfNhSNy O~y^0 N{|y^v^e~NOS:g6Rv^ۏL g:gSU\ vS vNzN0QzubSP/ff:Nf>fvyr_0ckV:NYdk f[Lu@b VERl _N1\ gN NycToۏv NLuRlVERNl 0etQv VERlT O~v RNVEl0[55]N[6qvƉ҉[ƉVERNll ~_6q/f`‰v06q 0WtNS1\dk gT 0Wte>yO ُ/fN{|v[}TTgwYdk  8Cg3z[ [56]_N1\_N N=gv?elMRc0>f f @wefvۏS N{|?elޘÍ06q (W ;NCgV[~lvNLu N{|S`7hޘÍbT/f(WTTVSvQ[tOvs gy^-N[sN agag'` 9eopT WWWW'` Si N/f9ei T؏/f9eimG'YVt;e S QbTVT{ُN bN_{m^[Ɖ;NCg0V['`0'YV?elv,g'`Tyr_0 mQ0;NCg0V['`0NCgNVERNllvLu[NsQT (WVERlvNyOvtHQqe] gNfnxl0 gN>yO TeN>yON7h ~SR~0-N~Tؚ~6k SSĉ_QNN NSlbÍ09hncQY~  ;NCge6q NY/flQavЏ(u @bN1\8l܏ Nlv^N;NCge6qS NǏ/fN*NƖSOvu}T @bN1\S1uN]egNh]CgRSNly FOa_tS NSly 0[67];NCg Nl _N NRrR0CgRRz N/f;NCgRz RzvTCgN^\N;NCg /f;NCgv[a0;NCgwQ g^y#Wv~N'` N/f*N/ey4xxbQwegv*`ir0;NCg NI{NCgR CgRS/f;NCgv[a0_[_e Tf (W,{Ny`Q NvS_f>f0 N@wevcy egf>f0bSevfTNQNNNQSb=\ ;`t_Nz6qꁨRbrNmpyj ُ[^2mvhQSOfT/f*N N\vQa0V*NVEmTl^ [$RvQNN/fVQfTVERNlbcSvV*NHhN _N/f[VQfT0[70]fT_{[vQVQrjbbVERN#N QzTeSmGVERN[$R ُ/fVEllvg'Yz4x _N/fVERNllgff RNllvIN;N(WNONCgRf[ 0HN VERNllbT[N<\eY.y^Xe:N NVElvNUOvQNR/evk VERlvV gyr_(WN[ Te [nN derives its origin from v^N Ne 8TS draw upon  NCgl human rights law T V[Rl national criminal law 0NCgl;NSb gsQVEag~TlQ~ ؏Sb'k2mNCglbThe European Court of Human Rights I{VE~~v$ROl [N(WYeb:NRlvSU\!.s]'Y0Ǐg'YP^0WybkOrN{| \%N0MckSu}TNSO[teI{ NCglVdkbU\b:_SN@b;RaObvN

fk0bUcV0^b:_'Y0`^:_lx0z:W}V b_^N,b g?elOP S[la:_'YcEN [$R:gg lQhlN[ z^NncĉRY:N?elYOSNl|T~g @bN VERNllvNyOv[gTQ ;NCg/f T;Nvc Nsir  VESO|_N1\bNT;Nv OPN  0 ;NCgُNNT;NNlsQ|-N8TS egvi_ (uNh:ybNy:N V[ vbairvY'`( l g_ b NT0ُ_N N/fTv/gbi_egLu[勽bairNvQN T{|bair sS vQNV[vsQ|0[NVEsQ| [hQSN [NVEl ُ/fN*NYJSl g_Tg}Y NNǑ(uv/g 0 \1\l_vvv bNg}Y\ ;NCg ُN/g\O:NegeNvWYuT>e0RSSechvg N 0 (WsNVESO|-N N*NV[/fN*NY T(WVQSO|-N*NNN7hwQ g NyO N[ NX[(WqQ TSO _N NX[(W[N NNUOb__vR)R;NINv/ec  g'YYpeNvg'Y)Rv N{|vg'Yx^yug'YYpeNvg'Yx^y0ُNSO|-N NX[(W[l;N0[YpeV[bhQN{| _a_NS)Rv v]\ 0[88]k^nu ُ,T NSNNASRl'N0er gvP VERlf[[T[R[_N:N ُyy)R'`(WV[SvQlbwɋN`ZVErj:_Ll vN/z:W Nf2eW^\0W{SR;`(W V[bV[/ecvrj bMRbkek yg^\N{SRI{N[^fMQNVjr mg^\N{SRI{NbNV[lQlvNCgnKN^Y nfM{SRRgmGT\OQG0V[SvQlbHN NꁻlvQjV[bV['`rj HN N r^mNVQ?e HNS[NV r^mQ?e V[;NINvwg)Rv/eMNR @b[sVE>yOqQ T)Rv؏S/fh`0dkY VEl[V[lbv[Eq_T_NASR gP`N`VElN, Nb:NzHhOnc VEag~v[e_N~8^bcbǏJS0VE#NvRlYyY7hb~Ǐ[ezl0eRybQOYu0P6R{OncV0%NyO v Te _N(Wkw0W0Wt0ُ&{Tl0N{|`a-Nv YfN b؏wQSOegT*N=ُ/fck8^v`a0ޘ:gOVEyrQNTRN[$Rb:NS0ޘ:gNNTQOVERNlbb:NS0@wevcy l gNHN NS00WtSOS_eg\0ckN:NYdk  hQtSNVERl [91]1\bNVERlv8h_KNN0]eY<\e1\:NhQNLuwI}YN 0VERlxQ 0 [92]FO/fASRf>f 0Wlĉ~ 0N]eY<\vgR`vݍu܏0 :Nw bNb؏>P,T N TX0gя ef[[e gsQVERlr^яgW\OۏLNċ[93] v^N_Q~ VERlf[~8^Ɖ;NCg:NVERlvLeN =\{NN8^8^ NmeQx;NCgv,g(TSQX'`0=\{VERlvnxS+Tcb;NCgvV } FO/f[_N0(WgyaIN N؏:_S;NCg0,geċvW\OfRsQlVERlv:g6R'`Q[ \sQl[SO'`W0ُ/f Nx^v V:Nck/f(WُNB\b N VERlN;NCgKNSuNNg:N gvqQ/c0,ge[ُNW\OYUO[INVEl_y^ZPQ:N[lvV^ [ gsQ^g;NINf[/gxvzv~8^'`m:1Yh:yWa FO/f^S_cQ[VERlN;NCgKNv|nxsQ|vVT{ N'YO__bqQƋ 09hncNvRg VERlN;NCgvsQ|e/ftpp _N[N0(WُN N ef[SOsQYyz:W>PToۏPN‰v (NaR[v NSmg`‰v0,ge[,{Nyz:WY gO͑ _Nf,ge\OvN

PT0FO/f \O:Nl_N bN NSN N >P,T N TX NDt+RTx0]eY<\1\:NVERNlb N/fN*NV[[SO FO[/fN*NNsX[[SOv{|yO^l Tvyr[Nm0ُyz:WwQ g R['` T '` V _N NfmG*YY^0g^t\NebbVERl vnxq_TV[;NCg FO/fN_NZWc:Nl g;NCg [VErjv21\ NSۏLl g;NCg VERNlb,g1\ NR^dNNYOSKNY ^bXTVv;NCgl gS0RNUOP6R eEQ{SR vvvck/f:NN R T )R(uV[;NCg  nfM{SRTP6R^\NAMQ :_SNV[;NCgl g;NCg1\l glb l glb1\l gwɋ ;NCgv^^;`/fLeN ;NCgs^I{ S/fN*Nl_i_ ؏ N/fN*N[i_ VESO|yr__N NO{f"kΏ [hQNv  N/f b'`v [OeujObv/fNV;NCg @bNR[SOVERl/ecV[;NCg 0Wlĉ~ 0v Re NY N؏ QmNbNrjvybkĉ0 Te_NcؚNSN{|jvwɋi /UNv$NyRe1\/fb?Qz_RT'`+RgkƉrjS 0Wlĉ~ 0,{10ag ,g_Nfnxĉ[] N NNUOe_P6RbgkƉ:NvQNvv X[(WvsX[bSU\-NvVElR ;NCgwQ gSQX'` ;NCg‰_^S_ NeOۏ I{I{0S_6q g`‰0gmgvS_^\^e.^j,NQNN Nbeb N?a荊s[v`lJSek: \(WNVERlvsQvWQ ;NCg6R^v^eSNvqSi b (WSNv\eg ;NCgv͑'` NOŏJR1_ ,[96]Nu (W6Rq_TVERlO(uv8h_Q[eb V[v\O(u؏/fck(WnmsvVESlSO|v8h_ } ُNN[1\_N:NVEllthe international rule of law /f'YR@bv‰p߂ T 0[97]N[N;NCgi_ gsQvVERlvlW,g(Y\/f gN`uvvQ;NCg‰_/f:NYbk'`v0ُN(NavPN‰>mNX[(W_'Yv N T RNoۏ>mv]'YRΑN0 >f f  zh N;NCg0NCgTVERNllKN  Ɖ҉ N T vc!j_ b c!j_  [6q b ^6q  e b Ne  z:WNO N T01\f[/gĉ f:yQwxvrz'`0 N0'YV?el0TTV0[tONVERNll 'YV;N[NLu ُS/fN*N͑s[0 S%c'YV\O(u _NQNN/fNR'YVvqQ T`l09hncelTl_`~ VElTf[[6q_NO gevSs 'YVvQzNzN TeJR1_N[N.^ROcnfMTs^va?aTR0'YVvQzSvQ(WTV_nfMq_TRvzN P6RN[NS[\VۏLbNvq_TR  'YVv?elaƋb_`Qz[N ,{ NNLu T N~v vi_Tf v^[NN:Y'YVObvzN ُ~NُNV[MQS[tO4#b'YVvcS[vAMQCg0,{ NNLuvV~_N~Ng:Nݏlv\V(WTTV'YOMQSVE>yOvvSQv[('`AMQ 0[98]TTV(WVESO|-NE\8h_0WMO0FO/f  _>f6q VESO|*g gHe0W;bk02b-Nbk[͑'YINRvݏS0[tOS0R'YVRgkv6R~0 TTV'YO_Nl g gHe0WN[tOS%c\O(u 0[99]1\'YV?elNl_XWvsQ| ef[؏cQ؏ l_ُNyr gv%N'`~8^mS'YVNv(u 1uN[[N%NPTNb^ck_v[c 0[100] 'YVU"k:gRLN VEl_y^>f6qxKbx0Vdk 'YVa_)Y6q0W>PTN^ck_[c N/f{kgvl_Ny^0ڋ6q Nu Ns^I{'`+R0SO(0D(0vI{ l g+Rva` 0leV[N6q>f6qYdk FO N/fNl;NCg Ns^I{ 06qNQY~>yO b6R:_0Ob1_ leV[bT?el1\/ftRDn 6qNNleV[l g]+R06qN-Nv:_g~ TaN>yOQY~ leV[-Nv:_bT[N weg_ Tas^I{v VEQY~ 0@b 'YV?el @b 'YVYN @b 'YV\O(u /fNSsQ0\VKN@bNQr 1\/fV:NlN'YV6R~\VKN@bNQ 1\/fV:N gN'YV~[\VKN@bN:_'Y 1\/fV:N\V~bTv Nba'YV\VTvKN@bNv[s^Y 1\/fV:N܏yN'YVNe'YVKN@bNQz Ne 1\/fV:N/f:_ tRDn2kXkX0O@bhTw V/f SVE'` v;NR ,{ NNLu/f S8Cg'` v;NR RKNaƋb_`N[YeONQz pNQzO_8^ YBgT`p0@bN ~TYOyHQuveSSs 'YV?elMb/fVEpNQzv;N nn0 (W VE>yO b V[>yO b VElQqQy^ b VEl_y^ -N TTVSvQ[tONhNy Ts^N[hQ v W'` b LN'` 0 agag'` y^ =\{ُyy^sQNNNLuW,gX[(W)Rv FO/f [ NNhhQy^(W[KNY \ gY W'` y^ OYVERNlby^0N8~~8fy^0NLuwm my^I{I{ (W[KN N\efؚv ~N[?ey^ 0[101]{:N ُ1\/f ;NCgs^I{ T hQSONSR [0Wt >yO g SS v!.sN0 NNYdk 1\/fُy# N{|Ts^N[hQ v W'` y^ ckb4N]'Yv 9ei b Si SR0[102]gNNuuv1\/f\O:NJS*NYN~MRvSSW  N'YVNSR T Nhy&TQCg v[?e:g6R N6qSN^sN VEll v%` 1uN'YVQ[NLuvTs^N[hQNR0Ile.(R[TTV0[tON 'YV?el vS~ m;R0[103](WN weg TTVُNNLu~~v~gS fNNybNRϑs^a 0TTV[z 0e/fnfMllvRR~g _N/fbT:_Cg?elRϑvYOS~g0'YV/fTTVv;N ^RFU [N[ [tO8^NtNOV v^:N][INNOXTDyO  NNSbV[0_NSbhQt^l>yO  )R(uNSN`avel[sAQVElV^VE>yOTeNS@b_v[?e~g NvlW 0[104]Nu󁤋:N  ]~\O:Nĉ'`T[$R{NireQ 0ĉ~ 0-Nv0(WV[NVE{KNۏLCgvQ!ktR SN:yQVEl_CgR\egvN*NQT:gg  bSN`a bN]~0Rُ7hN*N6k(WbNv`~TL:N N[sN!kϑvޘÍ]~b:NS  OObNb[empyj0bNj0SN{|jTOeujvybkĉlSbZQakfT:_Cgvs[]wQ 0[105]'YfVE؏cQN 0Wlĉ~ 0v i}T aIN 0Wlĉ~ 0_Ǐvwck͑aINv^ N(WNvQeg6kv[E:ggb4NYV r`YUO QNN[hQ(WN(WhQNLu[g%N͑vrj@bNuv&OtN?el‰pvi}T 0[106]FO/f [tO,{14222002 014872003 T14972003 SQcdNVERNlbv{Cg ُ1\Nuُ7hN*NW,g{|f f #NLu Ts^N[hQ NirvN'YV (W[_NLu Ts^N[hQNir &,.V X   2 4 βββΆjjQjQjjQjQQQQ0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh3h3B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph)h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^Jph6jh3h3B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h3h35B* CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph3&@ x p  ( 6 b | BDjpnt4<z*2v~(0>F2!:!""$ $&&((****++`8h8>>`ChC^FfF*J2J`NhN@QHQTTVV0Z8ZFbNbVi^ihpRZRZ0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphR115>E~K^b`i v ( J0l6h ĸn $dP1$a$gd3 $dP1$a$gd3Z@HX`ȔДޖ`hҢڢdl`h 6>~LT4<V^bjpxD3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphGDLBJLT:Pdldl4<*2<DFNJRX` ", 6@ $ R\жждU3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphGnFR2&R.^""#8*R/?L^P^avdTijpfsjsnsft $dP1$a$gd3 $dP1$a$gd3 N Tyrk)RvQ[ vQz:Wؘ_ N[ NYU=\#0'YVN>PT:N 0TTV[z 01\/f NLuy^[z [tO1\NhNLu gؚ~lCg 0 N(u9hnc hQSONSR 1\/f9hnc YpeQ[ vw>yOSR 'YVa_kzSNh\pe0N*N'Y ;NCg Q[pe~v*N\ ;NCg (W ll 0 VEll T VERNll vjmno-N _6qOmGSeMROvpr0[108] VEl1\/fVEQY~ ُ/ff[Lu =\{hT_0FO/f ُyƋfYv/f['`vbb/g'`v0 VElvSSNsr1\/fYdk NNOُ7h0 l_1\/f?el VEl1\/fVE?el Nё V[a?aQ[VEl0bcKN VEllSQNV[a?a TaS~_g N TaSNbLb }0*` VEl NPl PPlNT T0T T Nb_g,{ NN0:_SN_0RNR e ll 0 ll /f[1_vS1r0VE>yO:_Yg =\{Ype؏/f1_01_eSb NǏ:_ _N NǏ:_0(WVE N wckv\Ov`__/fVElRvb NcSbqƉeyw0VEllNSVERNll St0؏/fQY~'YTt0 >yO1uQY~ u ُ/fb__+TIN ;NCg^\NNl ُ/f[(+TIN0dkY ؏ gNy+TIN \pe gNYpe  N TaSb_g 0ُB\+TIN~[0W_ƉN00Wte6q^\NhQN{| t^[L Ype gNSR 0T|'}[ BlR0NUO>yO OVN:_R\OqN;`/f\pe0ll>yOvlR/fYpeNa_vSOs0lRNeǏ b N Tav\peNN_{ gN0lRV6q/f hQSONlv1u[z FOZR8^/f[\peb N Ta0Vdk lR&T[\peb N TauHe 1\b:NlRꁫ'`(vՋёw0VEll gnfM'` d^TVReQT T0nfM'`/f>yOlRvW,g^\'`0>yOl gnfMlR _N1\ NbvQ:N>yO0@bNSN VEe>yO [109] b VE>yO/fN*N ey^v>yO anarchical society 0[110] l_/f?elvh Nё Yg VEe>yO  VEl _N1\ NS/fl0[111]\O:N0Wtuir ُ/f N{| g'Yv`T0 N{| S g\>yO S g@\.^>m v^e 'Y>yO 0f'Yv`gR(WNN{|z6q:N ُ/ft@bS_6qv 0ckV:NVEe>yO @bNVERN[$RMbO/f bvckIN 01\yrl^  'YVa_ Q[NR0 N'YV vFg{kZQ NOmGyrl^v[$Rx0V NSO NrR1\SNc`aY:N0 N/fTTVSb[tO ؏/fVERNlb N[[LORN[$RCg0]RefW_N/fN7h N'YVvz:W NSN0VERNlb ؏/f RNT T>yO 'YV?elkrX[ f NǏ'YVv?el$cST 돳[ 0 kQ0RN?eV{0VERN?eV{NVERNllvLu[NsQT HtQoYeccQ  RN?eV{/fN[>yO[rjS fvƖ-NSOs  /fN*N>yOlQqQ?eV{ [RN?eV{vxvz N@\P(WlĉvƉWQ ^S_ۏLlĉv[ 0[112] O@bhTw  Rl N,/fc RN[SOl VERlR/fxQWv lTN [SOl0 z^l0~~l0Sl[l0_^l0L?e[lI{[hQNSO gp T[ N&{0ُS fNVERlv Rlr` 0bN؏wS RN?eV{Yf[yۏL ~Txvz 0FO/fbN_NASRN VERlyf[hQeNgeyrv teSORlf[ 0u薛lv hQSORlf[ 0Pi iv RNNSOS ubr[v lQlNSOS I{t_N_0vMR VERlf[S/f(WVElf[0RNɋlf[TRlf[KNSb N[ l?Qb ĉ l?Q0VERlf[\ef>fv ?eV{f[ aƋ0k Nw cgqVERlvSU\SSNsr  ?eV{` _N/fS_RKN%`0?elNTf[l gnx['` ?eV{l[O/f/ey4xx0bSNُ7hVERNe?eV{0\O:N[NVErjv beub/g SmGv,{N*Ncb1\/f egxvzT6R?eV{ /fTTVT[tOT/fVERNlbT/fVEmTl^T؏/fT;NCgV[ weg VERN?eV{@bb4Nv܏kV[RN?eV{%N\_Yl g~Nv?eV{lt;NSOTy?eV{(WS0WSU\bP ?eV{KN_N(WvNeEQbKQQ0Vdk (W^Ty?eV{v Tt'` v Te N{|fWyr_1\/f |?eV{ Pi i 0 \O:NNyVE >yO?eV{]wQ 1\/fُy |?eV{ _NEQnN*YYv?elSpe0@bN]eY<\MbhaSS\O:N?eV{ VEwɋ^S_PN[[N0QV{Tؚ~gbL0Vdk #N:g6R1\ N/fUSNv0VETV[rjgYXTO0VETV[ONYXTO0V[wɋ0V[nm:g6R0V[lNTP0[QeNm:g6RI{T gRHe0YUO bS_:g6Rv^^fN0:g6RKN_Nv^^T:Nb /fv_vp_0_Nl gNupvUSNeHh0 N\OUO b ;`Sb[sckINveHh v^NS gS1\[sT0ُ7h #N:g6R1\ NI{ TNrjc6R!j_ /fNy>yO?eV{]wQ0Wav/f YUOċ0OQz{|W YUO bS_:g6R v^eVEcWS0#N:g6R`_[He _{ZP0RSO0lQs^0wz=\wt0uSckINab\md NckINa0zrrrVEl6RT[N)Rv aV[s?elQ ُy?el㉳QWΘ_c[ gj_ZSR0yr+R/f \O:NNySR ݏS:_Ll_{mSwɋ N/fVEwɋ؏/fVQwɋ0 gj NZ/f#N:g6Rvg'YLeN0 gj NZ e NTl _N NS_ fNTs^vg~vhN0WSbVE'`l_:g6R0[NQ[HhN~gvaIN ncĉRk z^ĉRfR͑0 N{US0W[Ty N Tl_6R^-NvĉRۏLjRTbQ0Vdk R N*N-]evVE g:gSO| NS{f_0N[ N  VEckS_ z^ international due process vSU\wQ gR'` ُ̑l g[T{| ckS_ z^ ĉۏLyf[vl_kRg _Nl gЏ(unx[N,l_SRvel0 CNR KNk Necessity is the mother of all inventions VEĉR(W  -NRoS0N, [b6RE\/eM0WMO FO/f[_Nb4N%N͑cb0;`KN VESl!j_VR)R[0TS@b }6qv^ N:ON;'` FO/f NfY0W/feg(NavQ N/fOag'`Q0[115]VdkSNe :ONNvNf_fR(u1 VERɋYtv/f'Yĉ!jvrj 1uN[NTN N\Ov` Nte*NrjNQV{Tؚ~c%c[KNvT|;NOV c%c#N SRۏLnx Vdk(Wte*NrjNwQSO\Ov`KNnxzvcsQ|1\e8^SuV2 1uNncN,/f(WOP܏0W:S @bNncv6eƖ0ċ0OT_ASRVS_0WN,_Nl gYtncv_Y0(WYt{k$OHhNe$\vQYdk yr+R/f1uNeEN܏0yf[N[Y:1Y c8\TNTRASRV3 SelTbRthe chain of custody _N/f0ُ;N/frj0WOP܏0SY:ON0NNNX.SON0Dnw:I{V } bv4 nc~8^eǏX0ُ N/fcrj,gvnc /fcޏcyr[JTNrjL:NKNsQ|vnc0dkY eEN ncvS`'`1\] ~g(W^[e1\[fmG(u0ev؏[fNuN*NNHMRT NN5 NN,/f[N [$RSQ!k_S|^yRuv^[aYb Y ُ1\ON N?a\O6 VERNl^ďN:Nbk/fyrvTNTv0#6eƖncvh[[Tg[NT*N[ ge/f(WYt^NT Nl|N~̀ofT Nv T0NN(Wnx[vl_6R^KNYpMRL ~8^/f4Newa0gb/g N[0NN_Nl gyf[SvY _N N N_ NOV?aT N T?e^v.^R7 ?aaOSRVERNgTwɋv?e^v^ NY N?aa@wS N`lQ_vQNT\O(u YgNNcOv.^RwQ g Devyr_ b/fǏ`bb/g_v 1\f N?aalQ_N8 VERɋ1ueg N Tl| O~vl[cc0(W,gVvRNSl[-N NNvSl~_NT Nv T0ُN]__6qO[NNYUOtl_0N[0Qz'`(0S_NTeTNSuq_T0@b gُNRO[nc,T[T N$RQNuq_T0dkY NN؏{(WvNKN0(WNce0eTNKNKQ gx9 VERɋO(uYy0Vdk TX OыTeNыv(ϑNncċ0Oo`o`vsQ [ceTed\OHhNvR_NOSuq_T0[116] NCgON>yOOb/fRNl_v$N*NW,gNyOOb:N ُQNN/fllV[v-NVc_vf[ N(W\peRf*g_S 0RNll:_OJTCgv0|Q~[N)Rv0RNɋ-Nv NCg Ncur0JTbjrvNCg NSb[NvNCg0HtQo0H^tNSI{IN 0HN VERNllbTbN w0R e(W~&O!X0yr+R/fNN[$R-N JTvckS_Cg)R1\]c Ne z0MRWSl^0bSel^0VEmTl^0VERNlb JTCgvevS0R͑Ɖ ĉReg~0HN vQNyO-Nv1_ NN NNh;NAm>yO0VEJTN,/f>yO:_ N؏/fg:_ Nhv^c6R;NAm>yO0b[RNZ 1_V6qyr+RO HN:_bT{:N N,'`O1\YN ~Nyr+RO Nt N0\ ONOb TI{͑0,{N VQJT.Uc[f VEJT.Ucp0efSU\ ^'Y MRWSl^I{1\/fxQWO0VEl^l gf[ bUcOVVET\O ُ1\ObUc NR0&TSeb0RJT Q[VE[$Rv}TЏ0NbUc z^/f&T%NeS͋ $\vQ(W[$RRg JT\O:NV[ؚ[bleĖ _{Ocwxv l Nl^op[b0_`a l^O~NNyr+RvO_0,{V JT gCg _^ $Nv?elz:WN,/fNv0VERN[$R _N/f[V[?elv[$R0j TNjr/fgOeav?el0Yg_^NJT?elz:W N T _`abYUO gHeۏL0QrvJT N,_NO~b0RN*N_^ gS 0VQJTv_^N,NJTv?elz:Wem LNS_/f,{NMOv VEJTv_^dNLN>PTY ؏YQNN*N?el>PT0[Nُy>PT l^ NS N20,{N VEl^ hfN[ 0 hlNSO 0h[[^\Nl^:gg NXTrz0:gg Nrzh[[ScOg0wɋ$NoR͑bُ1\I{N l^/f lQhl N[0ُy6R^^VE[` ؏S~SlDn ^\eHYKN>N0_`a ُ7hNy6R^!j_O/fN OJTNCg :N-N_0,{mQ l^l grzLR:gg LR_NO`VET\O0l^OBlefLR FO/fjrv}TЏ[Ecc(WLRVKb-N l^S0 ;NCg T SlCg vYNNSzzݍya O_l^NEQR~SjrNCg0jrCgvƖNl^NLRVv TP[OS[ T[gƉ[ N0,{N VEl^N,/fl|YOSvNir0?elNeSvYOSQ[NR0YOSvNir NS/fgzvb>PTf>fvNNl^/fOY [EЏLcNfNbYOS 0ُ7h :_Ovl|1\T:_Obvl|YOS JTCgvgY Th[[Sb*Ns^Kb0YOSNegl g\PbkǏ gR/f Nl|SbςTl| YOS Teg1\/f$Nl|YOS0YOSv~g/fJTCgvegY FO NSl gbkX NSOl^b:N JTv)YX 0,{kQ S[VbS[lelaݏ0S[vlaYur (W[_br N f/f` NSO0VQS[NvNh`l gVES[N:_'YTcEN0~NJTǏYvNCgO g[fo`[N OO T[NR_؏ckIN v[$RHeg'YSbbcb0Ydk [[NvsQgqTOb1\O6q:_S0heNN,OS0Ryr+ROb0;`KN (WVERNll-N YgY TI{ w_ONOb ]~{/f[ZuN0JTNbjrvsQgqN0gwYdk jRsQ|0b^N20lQckNHesI{I{tu {͑eϑ01\HesNlQck Yg N/fHesONlQck weg\ TI{͑01\b^N2 l^[Neg_N/f Te w͑ ~_g gj NZeS0T[R_؏ckIN T ZT*gegbr 0L:NV6q͑ FO/fc JT_NQNN/f cL:NN҉rۏLR{|[{ v0S_6q N N/fWN [6q v?eV{R_~0PVERN?eV{ }T勂Ydk [(W/fNyeHYT`T0 :NNHN/fNyeHYT`TbT wǏ VERNlQ vSSNsr Nf0V[ glQ0lQ g{ g͑0 gu g[ RNlQ/fgTNSQ0RNlQ4xp N*X V[1\O'N1Ywxvy^0lQV%N[ [[ lQVuo %NSPi iIN 0g}YvlQ/fllSvlQ llvRNlQg[[ _Ng%N[0RN?eV{/flQKN ~ RNl_/flQKN v @b~>Nv _0NUO >yO gRvlQ/fuo %NS0N{|:NNVESuX[ gHQ QN X[(Wl TMb/f T\Ol 0VEX[(Wl/fVEy^vX[(WMRc VET\Ol/fVEy^vSU\O0VERl^\NVEX[(Wl /fVElv^~l06q gHQSU\vl*g_gHQ[U0ASRf>f VEX[(Wl NkVET\Olf[U0eNe VENzޏ~ N~ VEbkp T7hdkw|_O0VElQvRlr`ASRf>fS N%N0qS[Ts^j0Oeuj0bNj0qS[N{|j0mpyj0wRj0P``;NINj 5?eV{KN N vQYOrjgN6eeQVE[$RlQ0Oeuj\el[[IN bNjTqS[N{|j-N_NS[wR P``;NIN؏/fg gNvrj0f SVck(WNdk01`Zvisؚ rjvR:g1\:_paS)RNIN 0gT1\/fOS'`l^NlbegS N T0TR_vQ;N rjS_4Y _6q]~Sv NQ_0vMR ;N/fTTVSvQ[tONVERNlbvOS0 0Wlĉ~ 0]~~NMRYv \͑TsQgq iR Nv1\/fS`YUOpN^0S_6q g'Yv؏/f R N N'Y+Y  w w-NNbN'T0VI{VERl:NUOirV NSO aƋb_`[\ N㉳Q [YeQz NObk NLu NO*Ys^ VERNll\\SqS0b܀VvS gV]0V:NNHN NOꁨRSO 1\PMRςTN7hVvVSOg[fSO OPOPg:_'YςTvVSOg N[fSO OPOPgeSO0NNBN?aJU0@bN:_Cg؏/fwt0@bN SU\Mb/flxSt 0 :_'YSN㉳QNR 01_\؏/flb V[1_ pY0:_ZTV 1_Y`_KN VE>yOOeele)Y0:_Cg/f ~  bvckIN /f v b VERNlQ\ NX[(W ]N0ef0N'`0;NINNVERNll[vLu[NsQT'`  VEll 0 VERNll ^\N0WtNv?elefNir0?elefSy N_iryvW,gefS6R~0teSO 0WtNvefvzzYNUOy6kbTُfWyr_0 sSOVE>yO/f V[v>yO FO/fV[_N/fNv~T ;NCgvNh_N/fN{|0@bN؏/fN'`Q[NR0sQNN'` /T``[N gNy8h_Ss lWŖ~̑_g{m `O_{wSNLu N g$NyeNelNy/fЏ(ul_ SNy/fЏ(ufkR0,{Ny/fN{|yr gv ,{Ny/fΑ}Qyr gv 0[118]NT'k2mT;NNcN 8h_ z QN^S_/fT;Nv/UNNN0[119]>f6q ]\fkR/fN{|v}Q'`0(Wefv S| 6k ُy}Q'`؏vS_f>f0W T gN gp\OTle 0[120]a`/f l_{ NNbN bN NSl_b_g0}Q'`S\O N'`lmp0@gNN NY@gNN ƖSObevfR#NSNꁨRAMQ0N{|vSSl_NfNُNp0brQNN1Ngo unpunished 0yOv Te _N(Wkw0W0Wt ُ/fƋ00Wt^\NleV[ ُMb/fN[0le|^yNV[a_^y#Wek ُ/fvMRv8h_Oag0dk TleV[_N1\_NeP8Y'YvQ|^yNa_vs^I{:gG06q le|^yPNagl S_[[ s^fWe [Y OŖS_[rz Mn%`e UV f0YOyIN 'YV/fg'YvlAm ~‰ NefS 0Wt@b gvfPQNNegꁃ[NvUVNf0 'YVvQzNzN TeJR1_N[N.^ROcTs^v?agTR 0[122]Vdk sQN 'YV?el 0 'YVYN 0 'YV\O(u /fNSՖ0\VKN@bNQr 1\/fV:NlN'YV6R~\VKN@bNQ 1\/fV:N gN'YV~[\VKN@bN:_'Y 1\/fV:N\V~bTv Nba'YV\VTvKN@bNv[s^Y 1\/fV:N܏yN'YVNe'YVKN@bNQz Ne 1\/fV:N/f:_ tRDn2kXkX0VE]_e@b N(W0?el0ye0le0eԈ0eS0[Ye0'`+R]_/f;N]_ vQ-N$\N?elT[Ye]_:Np0N{|v~p)Y~pdY _N;N[nNdk0 gN;N _ (WWcwYeNLu^z8lENTs^ e~xQh gN;N _ (W[OYeNLu^z8lENT Ne~xQh HN  w;N SOYUON b^V;NINvQ OepQNLu W0W~~SSKNN 0 w;N N N^ :NNHNO͑e_b[YeǏNO NOǏ|^y QzN[O_8^ YBgN`p0 N{|;N/f|^yRir0;NIN/fefb Nefv|NS0;NINvQz/fg'Yv|^y NT0]_'`[;NINY7hS |^zN[;NINpTgz0VERN[$RQNN/f[yr[v;NIN0;NIN/fNy?eleS _N/fTf[``0;NIN^S_ yN{| NNCg0gzv;NINqS[N{| Nhjv`0qS[N{|jI{/f[gz;NINvvc[b j T(W NeRS jr(W Ne~S jy_Ng~pTz0~&O!X[$Rv/f~|;NINTyeTf[0ُ/fN!kg{_^v[$R0 ``[ $RNV*N $N*N~R N*N20t^vy0ُ؏܏܏ NY0h[[؏wɋN6*NrjVSO l^$RQ3*N gj VSObXT~~b0R(WvQN`S:Sl^ cSRN te 0$Ny>Nc/fSeMRO0@bN_VNSS`^g}Y0(W'k2m  ~|;NIN /fǏW ulb &T['Y`\@g _NgbrjQNN1\/f~|``r 0NN[$Rv^\e{~ǏNN vYo\NN _Y1928t^ JTvc _N/fN QV;NIN :N~"} Ջ\QV;NINe,gvjv`SSNQSb=\0MRWSl^/f[s|m ~GYv-N.YƖCg;NINT'Y^X\~Nle;NINvVE[$R JT;N/f^Xe0bSe[$R/f[leN6R;NINv[$R JT/fmp~N'`vfT QNNNQSb=\ ^2mvvQNfTNwv~ 0ckV:NYdk JTvj T_N/f mpyj 0 qS[N{|j I{0l^؏yr+RۏLN ZSO[$R }qRNYeU ُ/fꁌNb[$RNegv,{N!k _N/fbSel^v^8^lt!.sKNN0[123]ďN:Nbk VERNlbczNV*NHhN @b gQzeN N/fye;NINbgCg;NINvv`g0[$R y^QR0a(WllQ SbQv؏/fgz;NIN0V*NVESl^y"}l0N^vl0^Xb)Rf0gW[ SbQvh'Y T\_0gW[^8^l^/f[l\^yr;NINvNySbQ fRf0VZVEll mB\SV0R^/fNHN wVb~MbwSWcwYeO[;NIN0*`;`~~ 'YuQ NSblegT;`/f N^OQOV 0YgV gN)YOmGVERN[$R [$RvwpTJTvc N[ONdk:N~"}0 VERNll N/fNyd[Ov ;NIN /f[Ype;NINvS[T _N/f[NRgzv8Cg;NIN0N6R;NIN0le;NIN0ye;NIN0P``;NINv~_gTSbQ0 vQ[ N{|Y~(W:NTuX[ #cNb0TvɋBlO g N TvB\!k0 Ts^NSU\  Ts^ (WHQ  SU\ (WT0l g Ts^ KNv  SU\ KNk qDTs^qQY/fgW,gvT Vdk OeuN4xOWTs^1\/fg'Yv NT06q VE>yO gOeu0e[IN0g~xQvTgW,gvT؏(WN0bNj/fg O~v NT _N/fgW,gv NT0SckIN(WKb bNy2006t^Hr yr+R/f,{NR,{Nz vW@x N͑eO bv /fNyWN b_ N xvz ۏLv b_ N vNy`0 b_ N vwQSORgSbfNvQ[Tz0fN\wQ gwƋb_`vmT'`0 ,ge1/6z:W| ,g fShN 0T>yOvRNll 0 NwS -NVNllQ['Yf[QHr>y2006t^Hr ,{116-124u1/5z:WfSh(W 0-NVRNlBg_ 02007t^,{2g1/4z:Wf(WSN'Yf[lf[b ZSX[W NlQ_ZPǏ;NS2006t^5g19e NHS 1330  1640 SN'Yf[lf[bf[/g;mR-N_ (Wdkyr+Ra"lf[TxvzeTZSX TNvRTybċ0 dk!k(W,gQzlQ_Sh \OZPNQY͑ckTf0 ** \O|SN'Yf[lf[bZSXxvzu0T\n]N'Yf[lf[boRYec -NVlf[Ol_efNROtN0-NV'k2mf[O'k2mlxvzOtN0 * HtQo 0pTTf[vRlf[ 0^ l_QHr>y1999t^Hr0 ** M.Cherif.Bassiouni, Crimes Against Humanity in International Criminal Law, Kluwer Law International 1999, pp.90-92. [1] y2004t^Hr ,{600-609u0 [2] S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/ldq/" \t "_blank" R'Y VERlvlt nnS[ O~VElvQQ }uy_0bS^s^0syh;N 0VERlċ 0,{1wS -NVNllQ['Yf[QHr>y2006t^Hr ,{64-78u yr+R/f,{73uSvQN N0:N VERl(WN NQ*Neb [ O~VEltb_bN:_pQQ (Wgy z^ N [Uv^SU\NVElvt V[;NCgSRT Nr^mQ?e SRS&TRGd(W;NCgv^b N V[S&TNa[_vQVldNV[#NY S&Tvz*NNvRN#N^\0W0^\NNnfM{CgvQzV[CgZNXvRNAMQCg/f~[v؏/fv[v0vT{Hh/f['`v0 [3] _fwiYecZW[0W:N ʑf[vQNUS~vel [/felTwtv~N /fwQ gnfMaINv,gSOv /fTf[v9h,g  ʑf[ N/fNOB\!kvf[  /f+T gmB\vTf[St  Rlʑf[NRlTf[v^^'`( N Tv$Nyf[ uSN Rlʑf[1\/fRlTf[ 0S _fwi 0Rlf[ 0,{2Hr l_QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{3u0 _fwiYec؏:N N/f RlTf[ ؏/f tRlf[ \O:N ^INvRlf[ v~bR $N/f RlĉvTf[W@x 0S _fwi 0Rlf[ 0,{2Hr l_QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{1u0ُ7h (W _fwiYec weg Rlʑf[0tRlf[NRlTf[ (WwƋb_` Nv^ef>fLuR Ne;Ra:SRv_0>f f ُyNHtQoYecf>fQz0{wbǏ _fwiYecv~'YReW 1\Y TwbǏHtQoYecv~'YReWN7h0=\{$NMOW TRlf[[(WeltNwƋb_`v NQg Nb FO/fSN[v/f $Nk TR_0HtQoYec VR_  ĉRlf[ /f(WTf[`TvhQe^g _fwiYec_!` Rlʑf[ tS_N0RYEQn`vIQ0bcKN $N] NX[(W elt N wƋb_` vN:0FOُv^ N&T[[wƋb_`ۏL_:SRvyf[aIN f N&T[Ny2000t^ Hr ,{81-85u0dkfNfnxcQ \͑W,gNCgSR /fVERlvW,gSR (WVQf[LuS/f,{N!k0SSĞp NCgvVEObNVERl }ؚ프f0uy_;N 0S_NVERlvtN[ 0 TgNlQHr>y2001t^Hr ,{99-113u0y2004t^Hr ُ/fbVVERlf[-NASRUvOy KNN0 [5] N N Nyeыl NNhNLuĉbCgZ(ul0 [6] S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ VERNllN{|Ts^NckINvwck ^g }HtQo;N 0RNlċ 0,{17wS -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y2006t^Hr ,{516-549u yr+R/f ;Nn} gsQR0 [7] S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ VERNllTNLuv^~O } 0T>yOvRNll 0 NwS -NVNllQ['Yf[QHr>y2006t^Hr ,{116-124u yr+R/f MR ,{2u0 [8] HtQo ^ }!S 0RNlltʑN[݋ 0 l_QHr>y2004t^Hr0 [9] S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ QzN b  NLuRl`RN-NVRl9e6R } 0lf[N[ 01991t^,{1g0r^t^NT -NVv?elNf[/gen_f ~ glQ_^ T HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_@b llVvRleS^S_/fS_N-NVv b vgRe v^NhQbU\_SHtQo N?elRl0R^lRl  NCQ>yO^g-NvRlO9e }HtQo 0S_N-NVRleƉLu 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y1999t^Hr ,{522-571u勇egRSh(W 0RNlċ 0,{1wS N 0 [10] SHtQo lf[TtSSvQRl` } -NVlbQ S^e2004t^12g29e0 [11] sQNُN HtQoяt^W0N vQegNh/f lf[\O:NNywƋb_`v[  $\NR lf[:NƉ҉ }HtQo 0S_N-NVRleXG 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y2002t^Hr ,{175-198u0勇ee(W2000t^1\(WvQ;Nv 0RNlċ 0,{7wS NSh0 [12] SHtQo lf[TtSSvQRl` } -NVlbQ S^e2004t^12g29e0 [13] SPi i 0RNNSOSNsQ|Rl 0 SN'Yf[QHr>y1997t^Hr ,{447-466u0 RlX[;msQ|-N  sQ|Rl~ NegeSh(W 0l6RN>yOSU\ 01996t^,{2g vQgяSS QRNNSOS } 0lf[ 02004t^,{3g0 [14] SHtQo MR }HtQo 0RlTf[ 0O2Hr -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y2000Hr0 [15] sQN[ RlTf[ vtc[Th HtQo,gN g~N_0N  'YRl ]Sb g3yf[  NlʑRlf[0RtRlf[vlS [sRltvSO|z4x ck/f Q@b(W  ,gfNv|Ӛ 1\/f jRsQ|vW,gSt 1\/f tRlf[ 0SHtQo MR } 0RlTf[ 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y1991t^Hr0eǏ5t^ NS=\{fNS0RN}Yċ ] ]~ASR NnaN t0SHtQo MR }HtQo 0RlTf[ 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y1996t^QHr0Ndk Te N؏(WSNY  RlvN'`W@xُ*N  e/fN5XX S/fNGb [vwpck/f 0RlTf[ 0v~p _N/f 0RlTf[ 0v,{N [cvN'` ;N N/f&Otf[aIN NvN'` /fcTf[aIN NvN'` sSNa_1u:N-N_vt'`N~v 0SHtQo ^ }HtQo 0RlvN'`W@x 0 -NVeckQHr>y1996t^Hr0eǏNt^ NScQ 0RlTf[ 0NfNSO|ǏN^Bg (WQ[ NSbRlvTtcNf[tc$N*Neb9YBg(WNw $N%O$O  b[ 0RlTf[ 0NfN}6qv^ Nna ɉ_[_ g Z T ؏ N{/f%Ny1998t^Hr0QǏNt^ NۏNekf  ُ̑vRlvltf[ [E N/fclʑRlf[ُ̑vltvRlf[ R/fcRlTf[ =\{lʑRlf[q_T^l FO/f  bf`NRlTf[vxvz Mb/fbv_@b(W Mb/fbv|^y[V  (WRlTf[W bۏLN:Ng10t^v v^[sNTf[el0RTf[Ny1999t^Hr0eCSt^ OY NScQ[/fb _eVevN,gh_'`W\O =\{X[(W \O'` I{ NKNY ؏/f wQ g̑ zxaIN 0SHtQo MR }HtQo 0RlTf[ 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y2000t^O2Hr02004t^ N[ ,g؏/fN*NlʑRlf[NtRlf[mBg(WNwvwƋSO|0ck/f(Wُ*NaIN N 0RlTf[ 0\ N/fwckaIN NvRlTf[ 0SHtQo MR }HtQo 0RlTf[ 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y2004t^O3Hr0 [16] SHtQo lWNSiRlf[vNywƋ[ } 0lf[[W 02006t^,{3g0 [17] sN2mYec:Nel/f gRv]wQ (WRlf[xvz-N yOf[0N{|f[0~Nmf[u^yf[,gۏLxvz &TR  vQNN4lQ[/f^8^Suv Rlf[(W ^RlWv!.s _N N^\N Rlf[bg 0SsN2m Rleltvr^W,g } 0lf[xvz 02005t^,{3g0ُy㉇ gf:yR^0,g^lmN VERl KN N0KNMRTKNTvtu _ gOPybvqSi0{RNNdk:Nt @b g YVtu :Nb@b(u v^ N[YVtu,gۏLǏ^x0=\{Ydk 1uNVEl,g1\/fVE?elfe.NёVElTf[vW,gz:W \O:NVElv͑R/eKNN VERlfR:_p0WS fNVE?elv%`gRoS0Vdk _n VERNSlv?eV{NTf[  ^m YVtu weg(W@bMQ  uSNel_N N{cmQ0 [18] SHtQo lf[TtSSvQRl` } -NVlbQ S^e2004t^12g29e0 [19] S[]4b~.M.lKQ 0[r%ml_'YxQ 0 NgSCQI{ы l_QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{869u0 [20] S[]4b~.M.lKQ 0[r%ml_'YxQ 0 NgSCQI{ы l_QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{869u0 [21] ُ/f{vыl NNhNLuĉTCgZ(ul0 [22] sQNtSO|v['`SvQ _z HtQof~cQ g RlTf[ُ7hvSO|/fN*NxvztuTc:y[NvNT|v_NeQ܀v^NSS gbHevel FO/f2bknNSO|vb__ Nv[y'`N['` V _euNQ[ Nv[‰'`Nyf['` 0HtQo 0RlTf[ 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y1991t^Hr ,{15uN؏ۏNekcQ  _N b__ Nv[y'`N['`TQ[ Nv[‰'`Nyf['`KNX[(Wgy)Y6qv[z v^bNg5eZSX[ 0RlTf[ 0vybċSNg5e pTTf[vRlf[ } 0-NVlf[ 01993t^,{4g 0HtQo ^ }HtQo 0RlvN'`W@x 0 -NVeckQHr>y1996t^Hr0 [23] ShTIQCg Rlf[ve~N-NVs[ } 0?el[W 02006t^,{2g0(WN weg  (We [v`(WMR [SO|v`(WT  (W`vW@x N Mb_ NSO|^gv  (WEQRU\:yKNT ㉳QvTyeHh_Nkfnxv`Q N NN[f:NTtvSO|v`MbSz)RۏL 0ڋTe0 [24] SsN2m Rleltvr^W,g } 0lf[xvz 02005t^,{3g0 [25] Please see M.Cherif.Bassiouni, Crimes Against Humanity in International Criminal Law, Kluwer Law International, 1999, pp.90-92. [26] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 737-740. [27] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 21-29. [28] Please see M.Cherif.Bassiouni, Crimes Against Humanity in International Criminal Law, Kluwer Law International, 1999, pp.89-122. [29] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 674-676. [30] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 676-677. [31] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 690-691. [32] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 693-694. [33] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 698-704. [34] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 729-731. [35] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 686-687. [36] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 545-581. [37] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 393-494. [38] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 680-682. [39] S[]N_t.t(5rX VEll The international rule of law }~_t+Y.Y;N 0ll 0The Rule of Law l_QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{94-127u-Ne T,{291-338ue 0 [40]  (WV[TVE>yO-N llacb N T>yOv N T O~0?agTBl NS[BlOSCgRBl ㉳QQzTNzNSmdfRvKbk0[ NFO/fc?e^~bTgbLl_Ny^ N?e^,g_N gNl_ĉR [,g N oƉl_b:N]v ͑e6R[l_ 0 1958t^ V_^OSORzNN*N Nl_^zvNLuTs^yr+RYXTO Special Committee on World Peace through Law ~~ N[g`HNeg!P[V[vl6R0dkT sS(W1963t^ŖxQvN!kO N ǏNN*NNLul6RvN,SR[ Q[^zN*NNl_:N-N_vNLuTs^ 0S[]4b~.M.lKQ 0[r%ml_'YxQ 0 NgSCQI{ы l_QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{990-991u0 [41] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{107u0 [42] OY sY.gKQ^yȓKQN~  ̑9h;NINYeag :N Yg gllv݋  bNs(W1\P(WSS N7h0P(WNLu NvQNV[7h bbwُ*N͑N  ُ7hvll_[OnfMcS \O/fbN@b ^gvN)Y QY b\]TN+Yfc^z N*NNllTTV(Wl_ĉ[KN NۏLvQ[Y?eV{;mR:NW@xvV[@b~bvVE>yO ُ/fNy llb 0S[]'YkS.J."+Y _20N~80t^Nv'Y }fe.NёI{ 0wtN:_Cg  VElNfkRvO(u 0 လpI{ы fkIl'Yf[QHr>y2004t^Hr ,{2uT,{15-16u0 [43] S[eY]Ile.(R TTV0VEllNP``;NIN UO_Oы } 0l6RN>yOSU\ 02003t^,{6g0 [44] gltf[e0WcQhQbĉR0vĉR NNSrzSl:gsQNSvQ# /fVEB\bvll N }0Sѐ8lAm 0llVz 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y2002t^Hr ,{196uSN N0_N gVElf[NcQ VQllNVEll(WĉRKNl0l_vCgZ'`T gO'`0l;Nv6R^STl_SI{eb X[(W]'Y]_0S_6q ُv^ N/fS_NYNLu'`vVE~~N6q/fNN l gYrvN MRWSl^0bSel^0VERNlb0N8~~Nz㉳Q:g6R0V[lb[Y{I{/fO0S1gofe hQtSNllV[vSSoۏ } 0f[`NNc"} 02006t^,{1g0؏ gf[:N  VEll /fc~_gVEl;NSOvll  /fVElaIN Nvll =\{yYN6qZWc ُyll/f^z(WVElW,gSRW@x Nvll _Nb VEll/fN*N NeSU\T[UvǏ z 0Sls^ VERllQ~-N Ob;NCg ag>kcg } 0u>yOyf[ 02005t^,{6g0f gf[\0WcQ =\{X[(W@wV FOVEllvЏL؏/f gzS_v vQW,gSR1\/f(Wte*NVE>yOO6R:_Cg ON{|v \%NN1u 0Vdk  V[CgR T NVE>yO TINЏ\OvVE~~ꁫ_NS0RP6R Ndk Te  dNvQNV[v)Rv Y N{|v)Rv_Nb:N~_g;NCgV[LRv͑V } 'YVL:Nq_T͑'Y  f^S0Rllvc6R 0SsT hQtS̀of NvVERNlbNVEll 0stl_ċ 02004t^Qc[S0؏ g:N  ll1uVQpTVEYN1648t^v 0ZeyrO)RNT~ 0 /f ll@\WSv_z  TTVeN!kO(u VEll /f(W1970t^v 0sQNTVOTTV[z^zS}YsQ|ST\OKNVElSRKN[ 0-N sS TTV[z(WOۏVEll N:N͑  v^N:N  VEll/fVE>yO SbvQ{tv:ggcSlQckvl_ltvr` [ R:_N[V[;NCgvP6R T [NCgvO ĉNVE;NSOL:N  OVET\OۏNekĉS06R^STl_S 0S4TT[0 _ONS [VEllvNN` } 0lSyb^f[bf[b 0>yOyf[Hr 2005t^,{2g0yO/fN*NzSO>yO  VE>yORW,g N/fN*Ns^bv>yO  V[llNVEllSN gqQ TvvhcSlQs^vl_lt FO/f$Nv[se_tSX[(W]'Y]_VQllO͑NP6RlQqQCgRvn(u VEllRO͑NP6R*N+RbXTn(uOR  :_'YVb'YVƖV㉳QhQtlQqQvRT#N  /fNyNlv` :_ qQ T{t R /fNyllv` 0Sos^ Ջl_hQtSNVEllvsQ| } 0lQh 02006t^,{3g0 [45] S|gn RROۏNLuRNllefvۏekNSU\ } 0,{17J\VERlf['YOe.sGl 0 -NVNllQ['Yf[QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{19-22u-Ne T,{23-28ue 0vQ-N  NLuRNllef ыb penal law civilization all over the world NLuRlef /  penal law civilization of the world NLuRlef /  penal civilization Rlef dkY  RNll ыb the criminal law Rl  RNllef ыb civilization in penal field RNef 0 [46] Available at <  HYPERLINK "http://www.un.org/icty/glance/index.htm" http://www.un.org/icty/glance/index.htm>, last visited on 2004-12-28. [47] Available at < HYPERLINK "http://www.ictr.org/Englih/geninfo/index.htm" http://www.ictr.org/Englih/geninfo/index.htm>, last visited on 2004-12-28. [48] Available at < HYPERLINK "http://www.un.org/law/icc/general/overview.htm" http://www.un.org/law/icc/general/overview.htm> last visited on 2004-12-25. [49] From Bruce Broomhall, Inernational Justice and the International Criminal Court: Between Sovereignty and the Rule of Law, Oxford press, 2003, p.1.(U.N.Press Release L/2890<20 July 1998>, at 4.) [50] Available at < HYPERLINK "http://language.chinadaily.com.cn/audio/normal/2004/09/0921.rm" http://language.chinadaily.com.cn/audio/normal/2004/09/0921.rm>, last visited on 2004-12-10. [51] S[]N_t.t(5rX VEll The international rule of law }N~_t+Y.Y;N 0ll 0The Rule of Law l_QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{94-127u-Ne T,{291-338ue 0 [52]  SxQ6ql(W:_6ql/fl gVLuvN{|qQ TĉRv Te S/fZW[vRCgTV[;NCg  e6qlf[S[V[;NCg Ee9TNLu;NIN N6q O͑lvNy2004t^Hr ,{349-350u0e6qlf[QNN1\/f teSOzSO>yO v/UN?elTf[W@x0 [53] Please see  Comparative visions of global public order , Harvard International Law Journal, 2 (2005), 387-388. 2005t^3g5e6e 0T[OVElBg_ 0>NRNN!k hQtlQqQy^‰_k N[W f NN~vR;NINe T͋TyEteTp`   Vl 0 VE~Nml 0 VEsQ|   NN~QNNe NLulQqQy^ world public order vRVof0[N_Nl g:NbN hQt~l?eCg global governance regime v?el҉T9eivP6R0l;N\ob:gGcOfYc[0N>yOf[҉^‰[ V[lNTV[lbv[e  T^[e  v荊N[Nv^\0W{V0z6e6R^0V[lQlTyl0"?e:ggT/eN6R^NSyNUSNLu  ǏT T0T%ONThQ~~  q_TNlQy[SOvL:N 荊vQ TIN Nv{Lu0ُNN/fVEĉ6Rv_Y0S_6q X[(WVElQl0TTV0N8~~  ُ/fN*NRh0N>yOf[vyO0V[lbvV}TN0VT T0"NTNvyN}TN0V~Nm[SOvQ萡{t?eCgNCg?eCg0sX?eCg0~Nml?eCgbNNTs^vT\ONX[(W?eCgbNuSNc0RhQt}lf0*zz0;So01ZPN?eCg0 NX[(W N*N hQtl_y^0k NGY*` (W N T0WW  VEl_?eCg international legal regime T7hi_S _NOX[(W N Tv`a0(WlVTV (WXTT'k2m0 T7h N N Tvf[/gWƉ҉‰[ k*NWONTꁄvNLuc[Q[IN]wQ0@bN8flf[[yN8~~:N [l VElf[[Ry V?eCg 0Ndk Te 0R N8f:N-N_v[?e;NIN trade-centered constitutionalism 'k2mf[NVf[1\O g N Tv`l0,g!k[W1\/fkQs(W N TV[Tf[y O~-Nv gsQhQtlQqQy^vev N T`el0 [54] Please see Erika De Wet,  The international constitutional order , International & Comparative Law Quarterly, 55 (2006), 51-76. [55] S _fwi 0Rlf[ 0 l_QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{29u0,gev>PT/fNLuRl0 [56] es[;NINf[>mNh0vQ8h_z/fe6qVE>yOYNe?e^r` 1\8Cg bzrrr ^z8CgSO|N~bNLu3z[8Cg~|b,gf5 @bN8Cg_p 8Cgp1_gNLug N3z[0@bNN{|_N1\HQTvQNWl0V0V l NvTs^ v^(W 8Cg p1_Tzz:eNvQNNLu'Yb0/U g QY~3z[ e 8Cg3z[ 0Sw$l  8Cg3z[ SvQ } 0NS-N^'Yf[xvzuf[b 02005t^,{2g0Wav/f *g1\ QY~3z[ b VE:g6R ۏLmeQU\_0 [57] OY gf[1\ZW[0W:N 0TTVSbQV g~~rjlQ~ 02000t^ T 0TTVSP%lQ~ 02003t^ -Nv Ob;NCgag>k /f VERllQ~vRe>Nc /fVERlSU\-NvRKNN /f nxOc6RVErjN \͑TV;NCgv^L N`v͑ce  gRNcRVERlWvllۏ z 0Sls^ VERllQ~-N Ob;NCg ag>kcg } 0u>yOyf[ 02005t^,{6g0؏(WSNY TV;NCgs^I{/fVERlvW,gSR  VERl/f~b;NCgs^I{v͑]wQTKbk  VERN#NSR NN^z(WTV;NCgs^I{SRvW@x N N g)RN~bTV;NCgs^I{SR  \͑W,gNCgSRv^ NasT@w&T[V[;NCgSR f NasTُNCgSRؚN;NCgSR 0Sls^ 0VERlf[ 0 fkIl'Yf[QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{97-108u0ُyz:W(WbVf[LuwQ g^lNh'` {|y2005t^Hr ,{4u0 [59] Sls^ 0VERlf[ 0 fkIl'Yf[QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{106-108u0 [60] Sls^ 0VERlf[ 0 fkIl'Yf[QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{70-74u0:N  VERlvz4xNRe ;NSOs(W^zc6Rm0SbQVrjT[eVERlVERNl^ ve:g6R N*Neb0:NNHNNN_[ dNgTNagt1uKNY MR$Nagt1u;N/fQV[>yOv,g v^^ VE)Rv vteSO ~S N Ne0 [61] S 0belIlS͋xQ 0 YYef[NxvzQHr>y2004t^Hr ,{1821u0 [62] S 0geS_Nؚ~틞xQ 0 FURpSfN2003t^Hr ,{1466u0 [63] S _pg;N 0[r%msNؚ~IlS͋xQ 0 [r%m'Yf[QHr>y1984t^Hr0 [64] S 0geS_Nؚ~틞xQ 0 FURpSfN2003t^Hr ,{1466u0 [65] S4b~.M.lKQ 0[r%ml_'YxQ 0 NgSCQI{ы l_QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{1054-1055u0W:N  sovereignty 1\/f ;NCg ~lCg  N TTsV0V0vQNT6RI{ N TVSO NSl;NNN6RI{ N TV[ X[(W N TƋ0lKQCN z[V[ l N}6q w4xNʑ]_ _Nl ;NCg1\I{N~lCg vOag0 [66] S%m;N 0VEl 0 SN'Yf[QHr>y0ؚI{YeQHr>y2005t^Hr ,{31u0 [67] [l]bSh 0>yOQY~ 0 FURpSfN2005t^Hr ,{31u0 [68] S[l]bSh 0>yOQY~ 0 FURpSfN2005t^Hr ,{33-35u0 [69] [l]bSh 0>yOQY~ 0 FURpSfN2005t^Hr ,{69u0 [70] ُNp (WTTV[tOcNvς9N\[\`R-Ngf>f @bN-NVvS[z:W_Ngf\OS gNe[dkۏLteTRg h[[@bwɋvT[R^ybQ.Ucv[ag6q/f?e^ؚ[SvQ/ecvluQ~Tȏ_.T^tT?̑^._ 0(WvQN N*N`R-Nl;NRg0LNr^T-N^qQTV 1uN/f V[LcN`R V[S NS cN] vrj @bN h[[v;Nwɋ|R\*gl0R?e^Qrjeb ُ_NmGVE~~TYW Tf[yr+R/fZ^A l]e v%NSybċ0Ygh[[~~[_V[ۏL Grbv`RcN V[cN`Rvl[!j_,gNSh[[KN bvckIN wɋ?eV{ \'YS(u0gwYdk NMRWSl^TbSel^vk ُeu/fNy9h,g'`vP0 [71] []"̑+Y.]eY<\ 0VERlv nnNQm 0 syhы l_QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{1u0 [72] Please see Antonio Cassese, International Criminal Law, Oxford press, 2003, p.18. [73] S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/" \t "_blank" uwm\0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ 'k2m:SEVEl[(WVEl-N^d{kRv\O(u }uy_;N 0Rlċ 0,{8wS l_QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{128-146u0 [74] []"̑+Y.]eY<\ 0VERlv nnNQm 0 syhы l_QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{14u0 [75] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{2u0 [76] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{9-13u0 [77] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{22u0 [78] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{33u0 [79] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{162ul*0 [80] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{316u0 [81] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{327u0 [82] Robert Cryer ,  International criminal law vs state sovereignty: another round? , European Journal of International Law,5 (2005), 980. W/Oyr.g^t\/fNIl'Yf[lf[bYec0 [83] Robert Cryer ,  International criminal law vs state sovereignty: another round? , European Journal of International Law,5 (2005), 981. [84] Ian. Ward, Justice, Humanity and the New World Order, Ashgate, 2003, p.18. O[.l_/f~aSeyr'Yf[l_Yec0 [85] Please see Bruce Broomhall, International Justice and the International Criminal Court: between Sovereignty and the Rule of Law, Oxford University press, 2003, p.56.^e.^j/fyr)R\ASKQ'Yf[Yec; also see Robert Cryer ,  International criminal law vs state sovereignty: another round? , European Journal of International Law, 5 (2005), p.981. [86] Please see Georg Schwarzenberger, Power Politics: A Study of World Society, 3rd ed. 1964, p.12. [87] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{109u0 [88] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{156-158u0 [89] Please see Antonio Cassese, International Criminal Law, Oxford press, 2003, pp.277-322. [90] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, p.385. [91] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp.673-740. [92] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp. 445-448. [93] Please see Robert Cryer,  International criminal law vs state sovereignty: another round? , European Journal of International Law,5 (2005), 979-1000. [94] Lattimer, Mark and Philippe Sands ed., Justice for Crimes Against Humanity, Hart, 2003, p.181. [95] Please see M.Cherif.Bassiouni, Crimes Against Humanity in International Criminal Law, Kluwer Law International, 1999, pp.89-122. [96] Please see Bruce Broomhall, International Justice and the International Criminal Court: between Sovereignty and the Rule of Law, Oxford University press, 2003, p.2. [97] Please see Bruce Broomhall, International Justice and the International Criminal Court: between Sovereignty and the Rule of Law, Oxford University press, 2003, p.185. [98] S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{212u0 [99] Sfe.Nё fkRvO(ulNV?eV{ }fe.NёI{ 0wtN:_Cg  VElNfkRvO(u 0 လpI{ы fkIl'Yf[QHr>y2004t^Hr ,{50u0 [100] SefW)R. +Yf S_ĉN~'YVv8nbĉR }fe.NёI{ 0wtN:_Cg  VElNfkRvO(u 0 လpI{ы fkIl'Yf[QHr>y2004t^Hr ,{68u0 [101] Please see  Comparative visions of global public order , Harvard International Law Journal, 2 (2005), 387-388; also see Erika De Wet,  The international constitutional order , International & Comparative Law Quarterly, 55 (2006), 51-76\O/fwpQ?Yeyr9N'Yf[VE[lYec WS^S'Yf[yrXYec0f[/gN/fvQ2005t^2g25e(W?Yeyr9N'Yf[v1\Lo;NQ[ . [102] Peter Hilpold,  Reforming the United Nations: new proposals in a long-lasting endeavor , Netherlands International Law Review, 3 (2005), 398-431. \O/fe^KQ'Yf[VEl0'k2mlNklYec0 [103] S[eY]Ile.(R TTV0VEllNP``;NIN UO_Oы } 0l6RN>yOSU\ 02003t^,{6g0 [104] Leila Nadya Sadat, the International Criminal Court and the Transformation of International Law: Justice for the New Millennium, Trannational, 2002, p.103. \O/fNSv'Yf[Yec0 [105] Leila Nadya Sadat, the International Criminal Court and the Transformation of International Law: Justice for the New Millennium, Trannational, 2002, p.11. [106] Please see Pace and Thieroff,  Participation of Non-Governmental Organisations , in R.S.Lee ed., The International Criminal Court: The Making of the Rome Statute , Kluwer Law International, 2002, p.396. [107] Naha Jain,  A separate law for peacekeepers: the clash between the security council and the International Criminal Court  , European Journal of International Law, 2 (2005), 239-254 . \O/fVzpS^'Yf[lf[bYec0 [108] -NV/f N'YV KNN egKN Nf0FO/fc VEll  f[ N^NSv0 Nlq\0dkY b[ VEll 'YR 'YV^ gW,gKmT?eV{QY0 [109]  YgVESO|ck(Wb:NN*NVE>yO HN[؏(WRug v^N qQ TSOYJS؏/fNy?a gTzz݋  (WVE>yO-N  V[v;NCg l gNUOkvaIN0V[v l;N N/fNlvl;N0V[ NI{NlO v^N YpeV[vĉR\Ne(WOHQ0WMO NNvNyOSU\ v^;xNlQqQSOvSU\ 0[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{61u0 VESO|8^8^ w\O/f e?e^v   (W8^aIN N 6R^_NNele)Y:Nyr_ 0[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{62u0 l_Ny^/fVESO|vt`T[v;NN

y2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы,{67u0 [110] ُN(u1uwm_.^\(W1977t^|~0W 0ey^v>yO 0 T&OkN'Yf[QHr>y1977t^Hr 0efW)R. +Yf:N ey^ NI{NmqN c6Rbĉ6R؏/fX[(Wv S/fُyv[ g^vRvzz gY'Y \e[Rg0SefW)R. +Yf S_ĉN~'YVv8nbĉR }fe.NёI{ 0wtN:_Cg  VElNfkRvO(u 0 လpI{ы fkIl'Yf[QHr>y2004t^Hr ,{69u0Ndk[^ ef[؏ gNyl gfL NI{Ney^0VQvfL N\ NI{NV[ey^0\O:N ُ̑@bv y^ N/fN*N+TIN0 [111] @bNJ.eYeN(W19N~1\ VEl NS/fl_ V:N NX[(WN*N:NTV6R[l_ bOvQ gNl_v;NCg G.QWSTH.id9h"}_N VEl N/fl_ V:NVESO|-Nl g?e^ _Nl gl_@bOVv?e^SO6R  l gzl:gg l g[el_vL?e:gg _Nl g㉳QNzTcۏl_SU\vSl:gg 0S[]fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr _CN9hI{ы ,{4u0 [112] SHtQo [%NvNmRN?eV{xvz } 0lf[Bg_ 02006t^,{2g0 [113] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp.704-737. [114] Please see Antonio Cassese, International Criminal Law, Oxford press, 2003, pp.365-387. [115] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp.583-659. [116] Please see M.Cherif Bassiouni, Introduction to International Criminal Law, Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2003, pp.633-636. [117] Please see  Civilization and History , in C.E.M.Joad, etc., ed., English through Reading THF Macmillan Press Limited, 1980, pp.1-2. [118] [a]lWN~̑ 0T;N 0 __OI{ы UNlQHr>y2005t^Hr ,{104u0lWN~̑/fN6Rዡ'Y^ @bW 0T;N 0 'k2mfTQNNNKbNQ0^XW0y 2005t^Hr ,{87-90u0 [120] ُ/f{vыl0:kSeYecvыl/f gp\OTleX S:kSe 0kO[req\ 0 l_QHr>y2004t^Hr ,{229u ُSvSe/f Inter arma silent leges 0dkY:_v/flf[NbNvQp N[0:kSeYecvSNy-Ne(ul/f gp gX l_eX S:kSe 0lX 0 l_QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{5u0dkY:_v/ft'`N#NbNTЏRv`0 gf[؏cON틄veHr,g In time of war, the law is silent  v^ыb bNN_Y l_1\l؞ SY[{O[ы] 0el| 0 l_QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{5u0 [121] []fe.NёI{ 0wtN:_Cg  VElNfkRvO(u 0 လpI{ы fkIl'Yf[QHr>y2004t^Hr ,{37u0 [122] []fe.Nё 0VEl?elNNy2005t^Hr ,{212u0 [123] Available at http//:169.94.11.53/English/factsheets/1.htm, last visited on 2006-4-29. egn: 0RNlċ 02007t^,{20wS \J T   ##F/P/ 1@1h4r477|??_`bbLbVbbbd d~ffmnfshsjslsnsps v vvvvvv`wwwyy6jEh3h3B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph2ftu vvvwyX| : \dĕl֙H| $dP1$a$gd3yyyNzPzVzXzX|^|Ălntv &,.:@   (\ddlĕ̕ lt֙ޙ̳̳̳̳̳0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh3h3B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphFHP|ԝܝޞ&z,0<BHNV\"b (h&.nª,4tȫ2:ެ2:̯ԯ@HN3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphG|ԝޞ &,22̯@N²$Z$ $dP1$a$gd3NV²ʲ(*$,JL¿ZbXZ$,JLbd2P^rJR(ддддддКддККК3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph6jh3h3B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph<J(<644 4h $dP1$a$gd3(0<D6>4<4<& L028:<>4<hpжКККК6jh3h3B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph<T\x $,D(h,26X`HP JDH>FNRжжжжжжНжжжжжжж0h3h3B*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph>T $XH>f2R$f $dP1$a$gd3Rfnn2:DBR\$.V.fp4 VBL    &0z<FBLHR\fεεεεεεεεεεεεεεεεεεεεεε0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJphGB  &z<BH\T~ $1$a$gd3 $dP1$a$gd3f&J(jT^~螗 h3h&y-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h3h36B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0h3h3>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h3h3B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0182P. A!"#$%S EDd,  c :ANormalFax01C"jP src="/webcount/count.asp?newsid=37584"b!X󆡑NBD4nX󆡑NBPNG  IHDRfsRGB@}0PLTE{bIDATE!0Eq^uM&VUp\ &C|)"3.8̴(6 jPtsʄ&)NU- \^w& ^eyƾ_c|_^9IENDB`Dd V  3 C"J ((N@N cke $1$a$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ ؞k=W[SOBi@B nfh*S*Y(ph345 "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& !"& ""& #"& $"& %"& &"& '"& ("& )"& *"& +"& ,"& -"& ."& /"& 0"& 1"& 2"& 3"& 4"& 5"&!  n%V*/38=EB!GKdP^U1Z2_chmYrv{xmE5nȪ߸*qc23 6/p    Q t A;%7?8uf-^nQ A!"#L$%Z&'(3)*u+,]-.*/012P34v<1>GOgn~  ! f!b+j-07?@ABD\IJ6JMrNPPSbX]qag#l)ntttvXx }5PJ_ʮ#C˰ Y>Z|%߸[*`NS\bioux@q q0PP}z!In;.fOdS E]cb>x!WCc0)) L25r s;r s;r Y r Y r vr s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r zr c2r s;r ƒer SWar .Lr !r dr s;r I@;r zr mXr ]r H r I@;r ]r r Nr 7r s;r }R*r I@;r 2r ?)r s;r iPr }R*r {?r s;r iPr w~r 2r vr hr w~r I@;r Ir r s;r 7r c2r ]nr w~r 9ir s;r Y r SWar Gr Nr 3sr xr s;r &r c2r Gr ƒer }R*r vr s;r r ?)r s;r vr s;r vr $r $r /Cr dr s;r Y r Y r vr dr vr r vr Y r vr Cr vr }R*r vr vr vr s;r !r r s;r vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr Y r !r vr $r vr zr $r vr vr vr Y r Y r Y r r Mr vr vr $r .r s;r s;r ?)r s;r s;r s;r s;r ?)r vr s;r s;r s;r &r vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr Y r vr vr ?)r vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr vr Y r Y r vr vr Y r ?)r Y r vr Y r vr Y r Y r vr .r $r ?)r s;r vr vr vr vr vr Y r vr $r vr vr vr r v<1>GOgn~  ! f!b+j-07?@ABD\IJ6JMrNPPSbX]qag#l)ntttvXx }5PJ_ʮ#C˰ Y>Z|%߸[*`NS\bioux@q q0PP}z!In;.fOdS E]cb>x!WCc0)) L25I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0v<1>GOgn~  ! f!b+j-07?@ABD\IJ6JMrNPPSbX]qag#l)ntttvXx }5PJ_ʮ#C˰ Y>Z|%߸[*`NS\bioux@q q0PP}z!In;.fOdS E]cb>x!WCc0)) L25I00@xI00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I0@xhI002 ZD\yN(Rf 1nft|JNѰ `*./dh)Q\Bw{}3XXXXXXXXXXXXXX_ftnref1_ftnref2_ftnref3_ftnref4_ftnref5_ftnref6_ftnref7_ftnref8_ftnref9 _ftnref10 _ftnref11 _ftnref12 _ftnref13 _ftnref14 _ftnref15 _ftnref16 _ftnref17 _ftnref18 _ftnref19 _ftnref20 _ftnref21 _ftnref22 _ftnref23 _ftnref24 _ftnref25 _ftnref26 _ftnref27 _ftnref28 _ftnref29 _ftnref30 _ftnref31 _ftnref32 _ftnref33 _ftnref34 _ftnref35 _ftnref36 _ftnref37 _ftnref38 _ftnref39 _ftnref40 _ftnref41 _ftnref42 _ftnref43 _ftnref44 _ftnref45 _ftnref46 _ftnref47 _ftnref48 _ftnref49 _ftnref50 _ftnref51 _ftnref52 _ftnref53 _ftnref54 _ftnref55 _ftnref56 _ftnref57 _ftnref58 _ftnref59 _ftnref60 _ftnref61 _ftnref62 _ftnref63 _ftnref64 _ftnref65 _ftnref66 _ftnref67 _ftnref68 _ftnref69 _ftnref70 _ftnref71 _ftnref72 _ftnref73 _ftnref74 _ftnref75 _ftnref76 _ftnref77 _ftnref78 _ftnref79 _ftnref80 _ftnref81 _ftnref82 _ftnref83 _ftnref84 _ftnref85 _ftnref86 _ftnref87 _ftnref88 _ftnref89 _ftnref90 _ftnref91 _ftnref92 _ftnref93 _ftnref94 _ftnref95 _ftnref96 _ftnref97 _ftnref98 _ftnref99 _ftnref100 _ftnref101 _ftnref102 _ftnref103 _ftnref104 _ftnref105 _ftnref106 _ftnref107 _ftnref108 _ftnref109 _ftnref110 _ftnref111 _ftnref112 _ftnref113 _ftnref114 _ftnref115 _ftnref116 _ftnref117 _ftnref118 _ftnref119 _ftnref120 _ftnref121 _ftnref122 _ftnref123 _ftnref124 _ftnref125 _ftnref126 _ftnref127_ftn1_ftn2_ftn3_ftn4_ftn5_ftn6_ftn7_ftn8_ftn9_ftn10_ftn11_ftn12_ftn13_ftn14_ftn15_ftn16_ftn17_ftn18_ftn19_ftn20_ftn21_ftn22_ftn23_ftn24_ftn25_ftn26_ftn27_ftn28_ftn29_ftn30_ftn31_ftn32_ftn33_ftn34_ftn35_ftn36_ftn37_ftn38_ftn39_ftn40_ftn41_ftn42_ftn43_ftn44_ftn45_ftn46_ftn47_ftn48_ftn49_ftn50_ftn51_ftn52_ftn53_ftn54_ftn55_ftn56_ftn57_ftn58_ftn59_ftn60_ftn61_ftn62_ftn63_ftn64_ftn65_ftn66_ftn67_ftn68_ftn69_ftn70_ftn71_ftn72_ftn73_ftn74_ftn75_ftn76_ftn77_ftn78_ftn79_ftn80_ftn81_ftn82_ftn83_ftn84_ftn85_ftn86_ftn87_ftn88_ftn89_ftn90_ftn91_ftn92_ftn93_ftn94_ftn95_ftn96_ftn97_ftn98_ftn99_ftn100_ftn101_ftn102_ftn103_ftn104_ftn105_ftn106_ftn107_ftn108_ftn109_ftn110_ftn111_ftn112_ftn113_ftn114_ftn115_ftn116_ftn117_ftn118_ftn119_ftn120_ftn121_ftn122_ftn123_ftn124_ftn125_ftn126_ftn127DA7j=   jTg0a/!0#$R&@')#-0>@)CCC)D}DDD,FdFFG0HWIKiMMOOQR0SSTTTU&VwWYYY+\\^``nb"d^d!eee&fffOgg2iijl#mmnWnMp%q^ssuvvy]yy}~ փ0̏ڣ>ު#C˰ Y>Z|%߸[*`NS\bioux@q q0PP}z!In;.fOdS E]cb>x!WCc0)) L5  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~E"D:mA     nXk4e3!4#$V&D')'-0>@-CCD-DDDD0FhFFG4H[IKmMMOOQR4SSTTTU*V{WYYY/\\^``rb&dbd%eef*fffSgg6iij"l'mm n[nQp)qbssu vvybyy}~ ۃ 5яߣ C#$Dΰ\A])_ž.dRW`fmsy| Duu4TT~%#Mr?2jShWIagfB|&\ Hh5..!%Q5|%< |%< |%| |% |%| |% |%|  |% |%|! |%  |%|" |%" |%|# |%<# |%|   < u9[kN=5       ? x<^nR=5 ;*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagschsdate>*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PersonName x$2006201429457DayFalse IsLunarDate IsROCDateMonth ProductIDYearHtQoPi isN2mhTIQCg                   KNRVknw  :?DEIJTUZ[01=@DGNOfimnpqwx}~lmqr"239ADstxy|}456:>BJKSTUVhijmqrz{  !)*-.~ !(,.015 5 5B 5;',bHkR(x]|x]C89cMx]A~n8|;WAn{)lD{)lnx],aQ51w #]{)lF{)l7Xj~iXG'x]8>x]{)l)f x]dD2 7oBZF x]w Lz2<;h {)lJt 50 {)l x]Q [a YsNx] x]?SYV5x]8F{)l9x]t{)lCgx]Kx]w]x]\$Z~{x]Or{)l-~b Ad0x]+ux]@+M%T`B,x]2>{)lf{)l];{)lFx]Hd {)lNMGCXaw]e3x]{)l'!DoJ>"*:t-"D1w #x]#{)l.**#{)lH$5]%/A`6:ys%wmdE%QZ'x]zB){)lh)x])QaTP;*x]fB*dk]#O+E0K+H'ml ,x]x-{)l%*-.O+S Xh-x]Zt .@B:|z/BtEz/{)l50x]j0{)l}P 1x]K#19d)A1x]g1{)l1>2x]#2x]3[2x]E436Zi3 d 3mw73}P 11O3p@~FP6LY/A`6x]D6wDq6x]lv7h- 7e37q{#A8`G v+8{)lu8p@(U8x]0E8id{W;-}9 P7,9{)l4:x]*:x]4+: T@B:x]9TF:x]|s:Rhw:x]6;/Oa;x]Lz2x]]V>,>,>x]E{Y?{)l?h$@\S*D5\.@.r"@G'p@x]p@hCV@x]e,AibwA{)lb Ax]VV9Bx]m`@BSFGT`Bx]7oBx]qCkCx]\S*Dx]}D+alDx]w2Dx]cEx]BtEx]}Ex](F{)lM&2Fx]|4F^*haG SFGx]FGx]A1fH,E7Ii+K^XYI{)lYI%*-K-66JAu{vQAJ)A1WAJR(2{Jx]lOJx]U.K{)lE0Kx]oVK%Vd>Kx]#DVLx]CLIL4LMx]+Mx]}XNx]z2/Oax]ibx]~cx]wmdx] }{d{)l9dx]`kex]wf~c@TgZF ^*hx] Ph{)lS Til ,a ij\(Oj{)lnkkC(gkF?k [rJk:~k{)lOkw2DHkx]{)l%*-,cOl{)l'wlx]+alx]H'mx]imx]z mx]n{)lDox]z8o2{J-o;8&pKpx]7r4:*Jr(U8.rx]Xrx]2t'wl[Otx]1?u|MZux]`G vx]^v`kefwM&2Fmwx]]wpbxlOJxCg~fysNmy{)lAyp@u' {1Xq{x]Au{x]Z~{x]6{x]+{?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~      !"$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefhijklmnpqrstuv{Root Entry FMې}Data 1Table#WordDocument24SummaryInformation(gDocumentSummaryInformation8oCompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q