ࡱ> q` RbjbjqPqP2::k>\x0x0x0x0<04 b_0111118dT<^^^^^^^$T`hbN^Q@11@@^11_ T T T@11^ T@^ T T T10 Vېx0Q, T^2_0b_ T cS c T Tt c^$>LT>6 T>,>!>>>^^S>>>b_@@@@ D4D 4X VESl z^-Nvl^KNS6R^ \O: HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf" \t "_blank" uwm\ | S^e:2007-8-15 13:31:25 | pe: 592 VESl z^-Nvl^KNS6R^ The Amicus Curiae in International Judicial Proceedings  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/" \t "_blank"  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/" \t "_blank" uwm\  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/glz/" \t "_blank"  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/glz/" \t "_blank" ؚz_ _ l^KNS6R^@wVESl:ggяASYOt^egv'YϑXRbm^9ei (WVESlW_NvS_vSU\0 gsQ&TcSl^KNSXd WTONz㉳Q:gggяv[_wNbXTeopvN ]~b:N gsQWTO$RvppKNN0 l^KNSbNamicus curiae friends of the court lami de la cour 8^cHhNS_NNNYvN[lbX[ guvN[bl_ǏcNfNbbJTbSR^[ve_Ua0WclblavN0l^KNSXdamicus curiae briefs [1]/fNNz8^l gvc)R[sQ|bl_T|vyNTVSOTl^cNvl_‰pbN[Oo`vbJT ُNbJT[S_NecNveN'YYwQ geEQ\O(u0[2] l^KNSS/ecS_NNev‰pbe/ecNevR‰p Te_N/ecSNevR‰p0 l^KNS6R^YNWll SU\NVnfl Ty i0RVl[3]-Nv^_NA~c $\vQ(WV[lTsXlvSU\-NNuN͑vq_T0[4] яASQt^eg1uNSnflT'k2mNCglbvq_T lVlNlb_NNvcS*NNNl^KNSNSRɋ0[5]1udkSl^KNSvMR]b:NVQl-NNykbqv6R^0 VESl:ggvi_ 8^ g^INTrINKNR0^INvSl:gg;N/fcsLVESO|-NNVE~~0VE6R^I{b__0Nl_vel㉳QVENzv z^N~~ eSbSlel _NSbNel0rINvVESl:ggNcNSlve_㉳QVE~~v z^N:gg0,ge(WrINvVQSl z^0vMRVESl:ggSN'YRR:NN NmQ{|N,'`Sl:gg8f0FUNTbDObSl:gg:SW~NmNSOSvSl:ggVENCgSl:ggVERNSl:ggNSVE~~L?el^0[6] @wVESlɋNNS z^vcؚTɋVESl:ggHhNvXR VQlv z^i_[VEɋvq_T_NevX'Y ُ1\BlVEl[O(uevcяVQlv z^ĉReg[tVEHhN01uN gsQV[$\vQ/fVlvl^KNS6R^[VESl z^vq_T *NNT^?e^~~I{vRRI{V } l^KNS6R^_NnNVQl^8O0RVEl яt^eg N\VESl:gg@bЏ(u0[7] ,gea(WǏ g b0W[l^KNSSN NmQ{|VESl:gg-Nvl_ z^vĉ[T[vh RgTSl:gg[l^KNSv N T`^ ;`~(WSlKNS6R^ NX[(WvqQ TĉR v^ċNl^KNS@bS%cv\O(u0 N0VESl:gg[l^KNSv`^ N TvVESl:gg(WvQɋbT z^-N[l^KNShsNT_v`^0 Ne\[mQ{|Sl:ggۏLNRg0 N 0nfM'`VESl:gg 10VElb V[TVE~~SN\O:NVElbɋ z^bT z^vl^KNS0 0VElbĉ~ 0,{66ag,{2>kĉ[ fN[v^^Nyr+RNvcKNelwlbb(Wlb N_^e b @b:N[NTO~`bKN gCg(WlbQ^KNNUOV[0bO~`bKNVEVSO XflbNb@b[KNgPQQYcSsQNKNfNbH bQYN,gHhlQ_[e,TSS4YH0 [agʑv~g1\/fl^KNS/fcSv01uN(WlbcOTaev^l gS_Ne @bNmHhvV[TVE~~NN[aIN N1\/fl^KNS0yr[vVE?e^~~SN\O:NBlcQTav;NSO _NSN\O:NOo`cOSNT z^0[8] N^?e^~~ lbgRf(W1950t^N*NHhNvT z^-NAQvQSN FON1971t^KNTRNb~01996t^T Y g@b~gR0FOlb[^?e^~~v_>e/f^ck_v0*NNsSONlbvHhN~g gvcvsQ| _N N\O:Nl^KNS0[9] (WɋLeb VElbSStV[Nz SNɋv,{ Ne_NNPNV[0 0ĉ~ 0,{34ag,{2>kĉ[vlbSNBlbcS VElQqQVSOcOsQNck(W[tHhNv`b vʑNPN?e^VEVSO0*NNNS^?e^~~GWcd(WY0[10] 20VEwm mll^ 9hnc 0VEwm mll^ĉR 0,{84agT,{133agvĉ[ (Wwm mll^Twm^NzR^vɋ z^-N NUO N/fHhNS_NevV[T?e^VE~~(WfNb[t z^~~NMR GWSNl^KNSvDkĉ[v [Bl N͋ N^%Nfvq_T0(W2000t^VHh-N 17NcNvl^KNSXd}TЏYb 11N&{T z^3uYHhvXdGW Nɋ:ggN*g&{TDR z^v gsQĉ[:N1ub~ vQ-NSb*NN0^?e^~~0lQS0ON[TTONSLN~~cNvXdSY6NXdVcNeQĉ[gPb~0[17] (WWTONz㉳Q z^-N bXTV_NwQ g\O:Nl^KNSvCg)R0  N 0:SW~NmNSOSSl:gg 'k2mqQ TSOlb 'kqQSOlb^zNNyryrvNhlQO)Rvvl^~[[18]6R^0(WCostaɋEnelُN gsQqQ TSOlvOHQ'`v͑HhN-N l^~[]al^KNSN7hShNvQ[HhNva0(WlbvQ-N 'kvYXTO0tNOTbXTV_N~8^R:Nl^KNS0[19]dkY }6qlb 0ĉ~ 0I{eNv^l gfnxO(ul^KNSv(u [20] FOvQ,{40agfnxĉ[6qNTlN[vQ[NcNlbvHhN g)RvsQ|v SNNeQɋ0 NǏ lb(WQ-N/f\ُNNeQvNR:Nl^KNSv0,{40ag؏ĉ[ 3uNeQlbHhNvbJT^S_@\PN/ecS_NNNe0ُObvl^KNSS%c\O(uvzzkvQNVESl:ggegf:Nrz0 f~cCg\O:Nl^KNSSN z^v gNN^?e^~~'`(vOSO0LNOSOI{0S_*NNb~~:NHhNv~g\q_TvQl_0~Nm0WMObLR1ue _NAQ\O:Nl^KNSSN0l^KNS_N'k2mlQqQ)RvƖV(uNTlbJTwck(W[tvHhN@bmSvQHhN,gv^lq_T0[21] V 0:SW'`NCgSl:gg 10'k2mNCglb (W20N~70t^N ^?e^~~TlbcQv1\ gsQHhNcOfNbċvBlb~0(W1981t^vYoung, James T WebsterɋVNHh-N l^[N^?e^~~]OTvcQv\O:Nl^KNSvBl ~NNccS0sSBl]OTvHQ\vQfNbbJTcN'k2mNCgYXTO 'k2mNCgYXTOYg:NS_ SN\勥bJTllb0(WHh[t-N lb NFOAQ]OTvSRS4Yɋ z^ N(WvQ$RQ-NQN]OTvfNbbJTvQ[0HhNT lbO9eN z^ĉR fnxAQV[TvQ[~~T*NNTl^cNfNbċ0[22]ُNĉRTeg 0'k2mNCglQ~ 0,{11S[fNO9eTv 0lQ~ 0@bc~0 0lQ~ 0e,{36ag,{2>kĉ[ :NNlQckSlvvv lbbSɋS_NeKNYvNUO~Vb3uɋNKNYvNUO gsQNXTcNfNbabSR^[ V :N'k2mNCglbl^KNSv[cONag~9hnc0ncdk lb^AQ@b gNvQ[tvHhNv~g gsQvNXT Sb^?e^~~\O:Nl^KNS0 [-N V[0[23]^?e^~~06qNTlNSN(WfNb z^nx[NT T'k2mNCglbcQ\O:Nl^KNSvft1uvBl0 l^KNSSR N^cNfNbċ FO*N+RHhN_NAQۏLS4YbJT0[Nl^KNScNvfNbċ S_Ne gCgNNT{ Y0[24]NNl^KNSBlcNfNbċlb@bb~0lbb~vt1u;NSbN/flb[l^KNS@bmSv(WdkMR] gNfnxv$RON/fS_NebvQNl^KNScNvċ][l^KNS@bcۏLNEQRv N/fl^KNSlbnx[:NHhNvS_NeV/fl^KNS@bcOvOo`NS_NVesQ bNlQckSlesQ0dkY lb TacNfNbċ l^KNS*g(WP[veQcQv_NOb~0[25] NpeW[ N w bl^KNSSNv~[pe}6q N\ FOYgNlbYtvte*NHhNϑvk l^KNSSNvHhN؏ N0R;`SOHhNv10[26]PNDn:ON ^?e^~~k>PTN[lbhQSO^[tvHhN_NsS͑vHhNcNl^KNSfNbċ HhN@bmSv;N glQck[$RCg0Oo`Th1u0*NNyTNabUc0N_!nvsQv^NS_GI{0 lb(WNNHhNvQ-Nfnxbf:y0WcSNl^KNSċv‰p geh:y Ta Te_N NONh:yS[v`b_0[27] 202mNCglb 2mNCglb/f(ul^KNS6R^gYvVESl:gg [28]}6qvsQvl_eNl gfnx1\l^KNSZPQĉ[ [-Nl^KNS(WT⋌T[$RLebS%c\O(uv^ NX[(W;x0lb[l^KNSXd^8^"kΏ NN(WN[ z^ NAQl^KNSۏeQSl z^ NAQwQ g N T‰pvl^KNScNċ0] g100YNl^KNSXdcNlb [29]lbN*gb~l^KNScQvcNXdvBl0 (WɋHhN-Nl^AQl^KNScNXd]b:N`O0l^KNSXd~'YYpe/fsQN_c[TPSTPvpe ؏ gNNmSu}TCg0NS;NIN_GT1uCgI{l_vHhN0[30] [NcNvl^KNSXd lbO(W$RQ_YecS FO NOcQXdvwQSO‰p0 NǏYgN~kl^KNSvbJTTlbv$RQ 1\OSsl^KNS[E Nvq_T/f_'Yv0 (WT z^-N *NN0^?e^~~0lVSO0ag~v^bXTVGWScNl^KNSXd0[-N gv^?e^~~TNN'Yf[:ggY!k(W N TvHhN-NTlbcNXd0lbg\cSl^KNSbJTv‰p0 N 0VERNSl:gg MRWSTbSe$N*NVERNl^[l^KNS`^yg0$Nl^v 0 z^NncĉR 0,{74agGWĉ[ R[l^QNnx[HhNvQ SNbAQNUOV[0~~b*NNQ^v^1\l^nx[vNUOۏLH 0ĉ[:Nl^KNSv'YϑSNcONl_Onc0(WSl z^-N $Nl^vl^KNS[_NASR0N[0 10MRWSVERNl^ MRWSVER^(WvQЏLvǏ z-N6e0RNNN^?e^~~TV[?e^Nl^KNSNcNvXd l^KNS;N(uN 0ĉR 0,{10agĉ[vy[t z^Џ(uY (WR[T NɋHhN-NmS͑vVEleЏ(uA~ (WmSlQck z^ YJTNLbe(WelgbL.Ucv`Q N ge_NЏ(ul^KNSЏ(u\ 0[31](WccTadicmZ(WMONSle<\Nv N*NOO%:_xY0wRP_N @gVrvHhN-N l^KNS NeQs01995t^l^Q Tah[[Bll  ў[ NMOle<\N^Xeؚ~[XTcNMRWSR^[tvBl l ў?e^Nl^KNSvNSNN gsQvl_ z^ (WvQfNbTS4YvbJT-Nh:yv^ NS[[ NMO[XTy[t0ُyV[\O:Nl^KNSvZPlnNV[[ckS_ z^vg_ NS_vQ\O:Nl^KNSQ^e vQ0WMO[E NNS_Nev T0[32]1994t^>NLvlQ_,TO N _V?e^0TadicvbNNl^KNSvNSN WSTvNl^KNSNSN FOvQb~NُN0 N Tv~~(WTadicHhv N T6kcQN6Nl^KNS3u [33]vQ-N2Nl^b~ b~t1u/f3uNvcN/fe(ub͑ Yv0 (WlQ_͑enxcɋv z^-N 0 z^NncĉR 0,{61agAQ*NN\O:Nl^KNSSR01udk[$Rl^_NN[v;NRCg l[SN9hncncnUS _fYvOo` N/f@\PNh[[@bcOvbJT0dkY [$R^T Nɋ^l[_NSNcNl^KNSbJT0[34] l^KNS(Wyr[`Q N؏S/fS[NNhbcev~0(Ws|m ~GY(Milosevic)NHh-N :NNFd1JTb~:NvQc[bN [te*Nɋ z^vۏU\ b;x O[$RvlQck'` MRWSRNl^r^_^Nl^KNSvNv^NcNbPgeve_SNɋ0[35] 20bSeVERNl^ bSeVER^v_Yĉ[NMRWSl^v T0[$RR^T NɋR^QNnx[HhNvQ ]~bAQV[0^?e^~~b*NNQ^v^1\l^nx[vۏLH0bSel^(W[-N ^8^la\l^KNSNS_Ne:S+R_0 30VERNlb VERNlb 0 z^TncĉR 0fnxĉ[(WR[T Nɋ-NSNЏ(ul^KNS0 0ĉR 0,{103agĉ[ (W z^ۏLvNUO6k Yg[$R^:N SNbcCgV[0~~b*NNNfNbbS4Yvb__ [[$R^:NS_vShċ0 9hnc 0ĉR 0,{149ag ,{103agvĉ[_NSR NSN(uN NɋR^v z^-N0 mQ 0VE~~L?el^ VE~~L?el^_e1\Ǒ~Nl^KNS6R^ O*NNTTVSO(Wɋ z^-N`S gNN-^KN0W0L?el^vĉ~-NN,Sb\l^KNSckĉSvag>k0r^L?el^(WSl[-NcSǏl^KNSSRSl z^v3u SbTTVL?el^0NLuLL?el^T2mV[~~L?el^I{0 N0 l^KNSvStTЏ\OvQ*N sQNVESl:gg-Nl^KNSvStTЏ\OvĉR 1uN gsQvl_Fhg^8^!j| vMR\eV[T~Nv!j_0yr+ReVv^ NN0ُy`^NVESl:gg/f&T[*NNT^?e^~~_>esQ|[R0(W[*NN_>e z^'Y0mSOb*NNCg)Rb[$R*NNjLv:gg-N l^KNSv^(ukA~0Y:SW'`NCgSl:gg0VE~~L?el^TVERNSl:gg[l^KNShsQNygv"kΏ`^ SR Ncb*NNvSl:ggYVElbTWTONz㉳Q:g6RI{1\[*NNT^?e^~~\O:Nl^KNShsQ%NPT0 vQN/flbcCgvQSR0l^KNScNXdbċ8^~ǏVESl:ggvcCgbybQ0Sl:gg[l^KNSwQ g_'Yv1uϑCg0e(W/f&TAQl^KNSvSN [38] ؏/f[SNvb__TċvVvP[ GW gQ[Cg0ُO_l^(WُN6R^vЏ\O NccNvS_v;NRCg Nebl^SNb~peϑǏ'Yv3u SNeb_NSNOYucSvQ@batQvl^KNSXdvS'`0 N/f&TcCgbcS l^vQSpYJS/fQNSllQckvQT _N1\/fYUOcknxTSeYtHhNv0 SllQck,gv Nnx['`T!j|'`:Nl^cONYvVeYO0WT`zz0 N l^KNSvStĉR :SWNCgl^TVERNl^I{]~ǏN gsQv z^ĉR0FO$\vQ*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jhhB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3hh5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph)hhB*CJKHOJQJ^Jph6jhhB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3hh5B* CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph3" z F L  ,Pb@04d!b# $dP1$a$gd $1$a$gd $dP1$a$gd` b 8 : @ B D F J < B hnZ`>. "$"X#`#####͚ʹʹʹʹʹʹʹ͚͚͚ʹʹʹ͚ʹʹ͚͚ʹʹʹʹʹ͚͚3hh5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph0hh>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jhhB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphG<===ACEEBFZ[\t]]^`b`6cPcdf`ilnppDu $dP1$a$gd $dP1$a$gdjGrGGX\\t]]bb*c2c6cNcd:dfff ghhhhfii jjllllnnnno oppppssuuuuuuuддддддддЛ6jEhhB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(3hh5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJphU-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0hh>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph2 ^wQ g[3uvc SbvQ\O:Ng~~bXTvXfSvQ3uvl_0WMO03u;mRvvh03u;mRv'`(TDёegn4 ^yr+Rʑ3u(W,g Nɋ-N)RvsQ|v,g(5 ^cQ(WN[~bJT-NSsvyr+Rl_NSgb,gfNbXd[av勥bJTvl_ʑ6 ^,g@w:N[S_MRbN*NNNnav㉳QKNvv v^&{TfNTvQ[ gsQOS[@bĉ[vWTObXTVCg)RTINRKN|^y cQ:NUO ^g Nɋ:gg TacCg3uN(WS_MRɋ-NcNfNbXd؏^cQُ[vMRvNz㉳QwQ g`7hvygaIN NXdNS_NeT,{ Ne]T Nɋ:ggcNvPge NO͑ Y07 ^SbN*Nb23ueN,gNz@b gS_Neb,{ Ne/f&T gvcbcT|vXf ^cf/f&T6e0Rb\6e0RNS_Neb,{ NevDёvDRegQY勈cCg3ubvQfNbXd0 ُNDR z^eu[l^KNSvStĉRwQ ggyaINv:yHe^0ĉR-N:_N)R[sQ| ُOcN3uvcS'`S0RNg'YvP6R0 Te z^vBl_Ngؚ3u^S_fvQ‰pNS_NeT,{ NecNv‰p NO͑ Y ُ/fvS_Vv V:N3u8^el w0RS_NeI{cNvHhwSPge0 MRWSR^(W1997t^_NǏNN*N 0 gsQcNl^KNSXdvOo` 009hnc勇eN 3u^S_fvQ(WHhN-Nv)RvvQQYvvQQYcNvOo`bRgv'`(vQyrpvQ:NXd gRN.^Rnx[HhNbvsQvt1u3uNNHhNS_Ne/f&T gT|b gesQ|I{vXf0[41] ~'YYpelb[Nl^KNScNvbJTTXd Nĉ[wQSO^ FOWTO Nɋ:ggvDR z^/f*NOY [ĉ[ l^KNScNXdSbDU_(WQ N_Ǐ20uSbpS?z0  N l^KNSvSNb__TBl 8^(W[-N l^KNS\OTVESl:ggcNfNbvbJTbXd ge~AQ_NSNSNl^vS4Y z^ FOg:N\0Y NSRWTONz㉳Q:g6R Nɋ:ggv[t z^ _\SR'k2mNCglbv^[FOMRWSl^[Nl^KNSSN^[k_>eVElbT z^v_^~8^AQV[NVE~~vSN0 l^KNS8^Bl1\l_cNXdbċ FO(WNNHhN-N _NSNib'Y0RN[0VElb0VEwm mll^0'k2mNCglb0MRWSR^0bSeR^0^Xb)Rfyr+RlbTVERNlb gsQl^KNSvĉRl gP6R_{cNl_0:NMQb^ z^Tib'YNzV l^KNS^ɉ0W\Q[c6R(W_vVQ Te^9hnccCgQ[/f&TcQv^vaT^0 VESl:gg8^AQS_Ne[l^KNScNvbJTbXd\OQV^Tċ NSOsOo`vhQbNs^a0 (Wl^KNSvz:Web l^KNS/f&T^S_(WvQXdbċ-Nb(WSNɋ-NZP0RlQck0-NzTrz N TSl:ggvBl'Yv_^0N,eg a(WVQl-Nvl^KNSN7h 'Y[v^ Ng_VESl-Nvl^KNS[hQ-Nz0(W'k2mNCglb0bSeR^TWTONz㉳Q:g6RvNNHhN-N N\l^KNSvz:Wv^^-NzTlQck 'Y[[dk_wf0 NǏ }6ql^KNS NOvQ-Nz'` FO gNVESl:ggSBl[NvL:N^N l^KNS v0WMOv&{T0MRWSl^vl^KNSWladimiroff HQu1uN(W2002t^[bLuvN!k-Nc0R s|m ~GY1ccvS'`g\0ُNL:Nl^:N gݏl^KNSvlQck'` gHQKNZu SmNvQl^KNSvDf:yNl^KNS[$RQv>fWq_T0'k2mNCglbW Tv"}Soering HhN[45]1\/fNO lb(W$RQvctǏ z-NfnxSN\O:Nl^KNSv'YfVEvbJT v^SNbJT-Nr^~0[46] dkY l^KNSvygq_TSN(W'k2m02mNCglb@bZPQv N\tEQR0‰pcknxv$RQ-N>fsQeg0  N R:_ z^lQck gvVENzv㉳Q0l^KNS6R^SO N\O:NVESl:ggS_NeFONVESl:ggck(W[tvHhNwQ g)R[sQ|v*NNT[SOSNVEɋ N f}Y0WObvQ)Rv0[47] Te 1uNVESl:ggvQ q_Tv NN/fS_Nev)Rv NO\O:NCgZvl_ nn q_TlQOvCg)RTINR0SlckINBlZP:N^S_NNv?e^0?e^~~$\vQ/f^?e^~~T*NNNhlQOۏLSN &TRlb$RQvTl'`_NSV X[(W0l^KNSTl^cOvOo`__/fS_Ne@b N?abcO NNv0[N؏SN[evTb/g'`v cOSN bvvQ[㉳Qel0l^KNS(WNNHhN-N Y(WWTONz㉳Q z^0'k2mNCglb0bSel^vNNHhN-N (WN[ z^ NS%cNُy\O(u0N'k2mT2mNCglbTVERNl^[Nl^KNSvA~^(uSN wQ l^KNS[NXRlbvf^TTl'` cknx0Se0W㉳QVENz cؚlbvZOS%cNygv\O(u0[48] V OۏVElvSU\0l^KNSVEl@bb,g1\/fVElvN*NmwQaINvSU\ l^KNSXd[NVElvSU\_NZPQN!.s01uV[TYVSl:ggcNl^KNSXd:N/fNyl_nxO HN V[cN~V[Sl:ggvXd1\fwQ gl_NPT͑ov`Q(Wl^KNS/f^?e^~~T*NNv`Q N_NNMQ0N/fl^KNSvTl'`TNh'`v0^?e^~~l^KNSHQ__egSV[ ُ[ gvSU\-NV[b_vQSO[SU\-NV[v)Rv N)R vQ!k/fvQSNhyr[v)RvƖVbDRNv)Rv0 N/f1ul^KNSvSN@bS&^egvɋ z^b^v0[Nl^KNS'YϑXdvYtSO^[l^vɋ z^ _NS~VESl:ggTS_Ne&^egYb0[51] ~ @wVElvSU\ VENz] NNNPNV[vNz VE~~T*NNb:NVENzv;NSOvRTVenib'Y ُySU\RBlVEl[fY0WЏ(uяyOTNCgI{ROo` N0\O:NNzeT,{ NevbXTV[(WOo`0wƋ0b/gTR N_NX[(W@wf>fv]ݍT Ns^a'`0sSOvVT'kqQSOُ7hvwƋTb/g:_VTVE~~ (WWTONz㉳Q:g6R-N_Nc(u^?e^~~cNv l^KNS afN f N(uSU\-NV[N0[52]l^KNScNvXdTafN gRl[cc g(uvl_TN[ebvOo` gRNl[YtHhNvۏ^TlQck z^ v^:NVESl6R^v~N'`ZPQ!.s ُySN\Ocؚlbv0WMO _NOOۏVElvSU\0@bNl^KNS6R^vOp'YN:p VESlW_ۏl^KNS1\b:N'YR@b0FO1uN(WYpeVESl:gg-N l^KNSvl_9hnck!j| ُN6R^vSl['YY/fPR[vsQl_ĉ[vʑ /fʑ ^ĉ[v~g@bN nx[l^KNSvl_'`( \vQ[MO:NN*Ne N TNS_NN _N N TNNTN[ FOwQ gYvVEl_Ny 1999t^Hr ,{57u0See Philippe Sands et AL, Manual of International Courts and Tribunals, Butterworths, London, Edinburgh, Dublin, 1999, p57. [12] SpQe]XbWidyQ N_l8 ,{228u0 [13] S z*mfW 0WTOSlTf[vR;NINKN~ 0 SN'Yf[QHr>y 2006t^Hr ,{169 170u0 [14] Nɋ:gg gsQV  ybkۏSyr[~{|N~NTHhvbJT HhSWT/DS58/AB/R,1998t^10g2e0Appellate Body Report on United States---Import Prohibition on Certain Shrimp and Shrimp Products, WT/DS58/AB/R,2October 1998 0 [15] SzYOW 0WTOHhOSċg 0 -NVNl'Yf[QHr>y 2001t^3gHr ,{415u0 [16] S z*mfW 0WTOSlTf[vR;NINKN~ 0 N_l13 ,{172u0 [17] HhSWT/DS135/AB/R,2001t^3g12e0 [18] 'kqQSOlbl^~[l:Navocats gnraux :NAdvocates General vL;N/f[hQlQckTrz0W[cN0RlbvɋHhN\OQTcQa OSRlb[svQSlL0l^~[[HhNv[tT$RQS%c@w͑v\O(u0 [19] SZ\ N_l4 ,{629u0 [20] S)Rnf Qh_`I{ N_l11 ,{138 139u0 [21] SZ\ N_l4 ,{630u0 [22] T N_ ,{631u0 [23] OY (WLabo Machado ɋ.PortugalNHh-N k)RelbcSNl^KNSNcOċ V:NHhNVermeulen ɋBelgiqueNHh g{|yOSU\ 0 2003t^,{6g ,{139u0 egn: 0klxvz 02007t^,{3g Duuuuvwxyz||}>Fށ6΃<j$XxF $dP1$a$gduuuufvhvnvpvvvvvvwjwlwrwtwwwxxxxyyzzzz|||||}}~~~~~~~~~>DFLށ6>΃փ<Dʹʹʹ͚ʹʹ͚ʹ͚ʹʹʹʹʹʹʹʹʹ3hh6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0hh>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jhhB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph<jr҆$,X`xFNz BJ>F^f *2&V^BJ*2HииО3hh6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph/hh5B*CJKHOJQJ\^Jph-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0hh>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph>Fz B>^*VB*HRR $dP1$a$gdHP̑Α6<"RZȓRZʔдддКЃ| hh&y-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3hh6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph6jhhB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-hhB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0hh>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph Rʔ $1$a$gd $dP1$a$gd0182P. A!"#$%S EDd,  c :ANormalFax01C"jP src="/webcount/count.asp?newsid=37542"b!X󆡑NBDTnX󆡑NBPNG  IHDRfsRGB@}0PLTE{bIDATE!0Eq^uM&VUp\ &C|)"3.8̴(6 jPtsʄ&)NU- \^w& ^eyƾ_c|_^9IENDB`Dd V  3 C"J ((N@N cke $1$a$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ ؞k=W[SOBi@B nfh*S*Y(ph"W`" p5\k> "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "&1 '^"&:+/5N:k>^4N : u 1t  J}T] :M!M!!^"""K###$%%%c'(7*:+K,N,....9///0;10223344 555666'7H77788.89/9w999999:!:N:j::;;N;;k<<<<<f======>W>j>m>r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r Y r dr r dr ?)r Y r s;r vr s;r s;r .r Y r s;r $r s;r s;r }R*r I@;r $r s;r s;r s;r !r r s;r s;r .r vr $r ?)r vr s;r ?)r ?)r Y r s;r r s;r 7r $r s;r Y r s;r r s;r r s;r r s;r s;r 7r !r $r s;r vr {?r r r vr s;r r ?)r vr }R*r s;r Y r &r &r .r $r !r s;r /Cr s;r vr s;r s;r s;r vr r Y r r Y r vr vr r vr vr Y r s;r vr Y r vr s;r s;r Y r s;r s;r s;r s;r r s;r vr s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r vr s;r s;r Y r s;r vr vr r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r vr r u 1t  J}T] :M!M!!^"""K###$%%%c'(7*:+K,N,....9///0;10223344 555666'7H77788.89/9w999999:!:N:j::;;N;;k<<<<<f======>W>j>m>I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0000000000000000000000u 1t  J}T] :M!M!!^"""K###$%%%c'(7*:+K,N,....9///0;10223344 555666'7H77788.89/9w999999:!:N:j::;;N;;k<<<<<f======>W>j>m>I0.@I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0.I0@hI00j>` #jGuH$')+LMOb#<DuFR%(*KNP&HL)-0efg....%/)/;/p/q/r///2132333h3l3< ===D=H=k>XXXXXXXXXXXXXl_ftnref1_ftnref2_ftnref3_ftnref4_ftnref5_ftnref6_ftnref7_ftnref8_ftnref9 _ftnref10 _ftnref11 _ftnref12 _ftnref13 _ftnref14 _ftnref15 _ftnref16 _ftnref17 _ftnref18 _ftnref19 _ftnref20 _ftnref21 _ftnref22 _ftnref23 _ftnref24 _ftnref25 _ftnref26 _ftnref27 _ftnref28 _ftnref29 _ftnref30 _ftnref31 _ftnref32 _ftnref33 _ftnref34 _ftnref35 _ftnref36 _ftnref37 _ftnref38 _ftnref39 _ftnref40 _ftnref41 _ftnref42 _ftnref43 _ftnref44 _ftnref45 _ftnref46 _ftnref47 _ftnref48 _ftnref49 _ftnref50 _ftnref51 _ftnref52 _ftnref53 _ftnref54_ftn1_ftn2_ftn3_ftn4_ftn5_ftn6_ftn7_ftn8_ftn9_ftn10_ftn11_ftn12_ftn13_ftn14_ftn15_ftn16_ftn17_ftn18_ftn19_ftn20_ftn21_ftn22_ftn23_ftn24_ftn25_ftn26_ftn27_ftn28_ftn29_ftn30_ftn31_ftn32_ftn33_ftn34_ftn35_ftn36_ftn37_ftn38_ftn39_ftn40_ftn41_ftn42_ftn43_ftn44_ftn45_ftn46_ftn47_ftn48_ftn49_ftn50_ftn51_ftn52_ftn53_ftn54.4V-o C  _QxOv`KyE'TY"T%%^'8(l((2**t+F,z-.9///0;10223344 555666'7H77788.89/9w999999:!:N:j::;;N;;k<<<<<f======>m>  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijk/7Y0r G  cU|SzdO}I+X]"X%%b'<(p((6**x+J,~-.:///0>13223344555667+7L7778"828939{999999:%:R:n::;!;R;;o<<<<<j=====>>m>d&\ e&V_f&U_b&\ c&  2;r=m> !2;{=m>;*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagschsdate<*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagschmetcnv h$011215198919982000200135788aDayFalseHasSpace IsLunarDate IsROCDateMonthNegative NumberType SourceValueTCSCUnitNameYear        ILPTjmu*-  "%9<?FJK47VZ-1'+48ot      Z ]       " # A B C D    C G t u v x { |     1 5 = ? N P  _c  HJQUx}OU\]vz`eBDIJz{KORW/4bgpqy}8C  =@DE9:<=LMEI', !),=>RSTYZ[no. 0 F H q s L!M!!!!!Y"^"|""""""""""J#K###"$#$c$d$$$$$$$$%% %%T%X%Y%\%%%%%%%%%%%%% '''' '!'''('^'d'''-(4(6(8(<(l(q((((())2*8***9+:+t+y+F,K,M,N,P-S-e-f-j-k-z-~-...........&/)/*/8/////////////0+0/010205080;0?0C0D0L000000011111)1-1/1013161:1?1C1J1k1o1q1s1v1y1|142:2A2\2`2b2c2f2i2j2m2p2t2u2}2~222222222222i3l3m333333333333333333333334 44|4}444444444444444444 5555*5+53575;5=5@55555555555555566 6 6 6666626C6D6F6G6H6K6Y6K>M>N>Q>T>V>W>Y>Z>a>e>g>h>i>m>ux ?BtwQ U } n o K O L M +,/2'*;@eh;{<~<<<<<U=X=========== >>m>::::::::::::::z:::z:z::zz::::::::::::::::::::;m>4;m>o%c2+f+B2 efy!V_Ar4:PSn ef-"!V_]I^I ef` ef3hx" ef$=4mV!V_,./!V_%x`!V_l efn zmQ" C|Y= I$kJ7-1j_A!V_1v!V_% efc!V_e!V_&4"SM. ef!V_' -FKK!V_6 efg efI efwi&@D25T!V_z efRKz]wF efbF!V_?q8 efb0!?q84" ef" efrh$ efLef% efr`&!V_f&!V_SQ)!V_vp)N]2a1*!V_;X\* ef:*!V_2+f+ ef. +lb,!V_@Z, ef<^,cq,V,!V_ - ef0.!V_.cqKL?/2]?0!V_wf1PSnhb1-RN]2 ef 2!V__2 ef@D2 efX7P3!V_k_4 ef{50 85J5!V_5!V_eW5!V_r6Lef%}G6!V_Q7Itw7!V_0 8 ef&q8 ef949B2IH9!V_r4: ef;"TT;_2Y;o<+<!V_o< efN= ef>gj >!V_25>3XJ>!V_@!V_{@ ef0A!V_?ZB!V_l+B:gmOCk_4A$D:BR[xE efwF efoEGrh$|H!V_JglI@Z,C!L!V_Z!L4L!V_"&Mx"+O!V_ P efwU3Q efzmQ efp aR P:BR ef-R efdSSM.QV!V_lV!V_M9V!V_9V!V_~)W!V_>~XN=_[X ef3X efC|Y efMv(Z!V_Z!V_/[wU3Q=R\7k<|7J\!V_2] efI^ ef!V_cq,ss`!V_e`!V_OT` efIs`!V_mIa!V_zxa!V_a!V_ `d!V_doxj>|j>j>Lk>PP PPP$PXUnknownG:Ax Times New Roman5Symbol3& :Cx Arial;([SOSimSun 1hI&I&P 5qP 5q!-!),.:;?]}    & 6"0000 0 0 00000 =@\]^([{  0 0 00000;[L>L>3HX?2 AdministratoradminOh+'0`   ( 4@HPXAdministrator Normal.dotadmin2Microsoft Office Word@@H6ې@H6ېP 5՜.+,D՜.+, X`lt| qL>  8@ _PID_HLINKSA|N97$http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/97!http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/97http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/97http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/83http://law.hit.edu.cn/glz/83http://law.hit.edu.cn/glz/97http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/97http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/83 http://law.hit.edu.cn/glz/83 http://law.hit.edu.cn/glz/97http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/97http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/_http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQSTUVWXY[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry F@ VېData R1TableZ cWordDocument2SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q