ࡱ> q` RRbjbjqPqP2::)J4444444( NNNNThN f(O$LPLPLPLPLP"nR:Sh f f f f f f f$ghEjN0fu4ULPLPUU0f44LPLPfhWhWhWU 4LP4LP fhWU fhWhW44hWLPO >ڐNVhWbTf0fhWjS,hW T$0TrSSS0f0fRWSSSfUUUU   0   0H$l$444444 >yONSl[$RNRv*NHhxvz \O: HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm" \t "_blank" RNgf | S^e:2007-12-14 9:32:28 | pe: 1926 >yONSl[$RNRv*NHhxvz HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn1" \o "" [`$]  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/" \t "_blank" RNgf T\n]N'Yf[ lf[b ў_l T\n 150001 Research on the Interaction of the Public Opinionand Judicial Judgment Liu Li-ming (School of Law , Harbin Institute of Technology , Harbin,15001) XdSl;mRN>yOX[(WNR0,geǑS*NHhxvzl Џ(u|~St [ُN>yOǏ zvQ(W:g6RۏLcRg _QbVSlЏ\O|~vN,!jW---ёW[TX!jW0lWegbVvl_6R^FhgNSi-N O~eSKNX[(Wwv @bN^S_BlNyfwQTt'`Ts['`vSlckIN sSOSFUWckIN0>yONSlKNvNR/fo'`v OOSlT@wf[U0WObNlCg)RveTbaoۏ TecR@wl_ĉR,gSuSi v^1udkOۏOSFUWSlckINv[s0 sQ.͋Sl[$R>yOSllQck Abstract There are interactions between judgment and public opinion. In this thesis, the structure of public opinion lies in legal affairs (pyramid model) and the intrinsic mechanism of the social process that social consensus affects judicial judgment were analyzed in detail by using individual case method in case sociology and theory of system control and minus feedback to search for the justice that should be after in the changing era in our country, named consulting justice. The interaction is so good to push the public makes law more powerful to protect civil right by the consultation and interplay with judicial department and political department. They are also reforming the law itself so that the consulting justice can be realized. KeywordsJudicial Judgment; Public Opinion; Justice N0vcQTgxvzvS[e N vcQ Sl[$R/f[s>yOckINvNy;Nb__ SlckIN_N/f>yOckINg͑vh_KNN0t`-NvSlyOV }0V:NNN NS/fq~Џ(ul_b/gvl_N NN_N/f>yON el)u_NNvX[(W sSNNv O~TeS ۏLSl;mR0Sl;mR;`/f(WN[vezz NۏLv Ty>yOV }elN-NcdQS _6q(Wl_Џ\OǏ z-Nɉ NɉvSOsQeg0vQ-N >yO[Sl[$Rv]'YSRTq_T1\/f_zQvNO0 [>yOSR[Sl[$Rvq_TZPQxvzASR_ VQs gvvsQxvz'YSNZSOvcwNSlrzSSllQckvsQ|N~|vlʑlf[bef[v҉^egcُ*N N_>yO 1\/f[ZSOċvzzYUO[SlNuq_T_N NY0HN NwQSOHhOQS Nl>yOf[vxvzƉ҉ Sb4xN_\Sl[$R;mRbaS0~|S0^y#WSTN:NOKN1y>yOu;mSv{ \vQ~eQ>yOu;mKN-N \O:NN*N>yOǏ zegxvz f(Wُ*N>yOǏ z-Nl_age@bSOsvl_eST>yOُ$Ny N Tv>yOaƋb_`/fYUO Te\O(uN g@wYy>yO҉rvl[ c:yُ*N>yOǏ zvЏL:g6R \ASR_0 (N)xvzFhgTel 1.xvzFhg [NSl[$Rv>yOSR VQYf['Y/fNeZSONSlvsQ|҉^ۏLxvzv0VYs gvvsQxvzYpeV~ebS[Nɋ~gvq_TۏL gtRg _N g[xvz l͑N[l[v_tT`avRg FO/fl gRg>yOُNV }[Slvq_T,nxRvl g\ OZN:SR_eg01uNbVvV`TSlsr VQvvsQxvz/fNevcwTSlrzv҉^Sc Ypef[:N~bSlrz Ǐ^g6R^egĉevcw0NN N T z^vbebST>yOI{ Tweg0SY VQvsQxvzvxvzel_Nv[USN0 ,ge͑(WЏ(u|~vN,St[ N T{|Wv>yO\O(uNSl[$Rv>yOǏ zZPcTRg v^;`~QُNǏ zvN,!jW f>yONSlX[(Wo'`NR ۏ cBlbVlWeg^S_BlvSlckIN0ՋV(uTlevlQqQWtSlsN'`tck/fSlTKNvvN[݋0l0teTObVvl_ĉ4xeze egwQ gTt'` egcяwckvSlckIN0 >yOclQO[vQsQ_vNir0NN0saT‰_vO_0`^Tav;`T wQ gN[vN'`0:_p z^Tc~'` v^[ gsQN`vSU\Nuq_T0,ge@bxvzvSl[$R /fcSl:gsQNNeQ0RQN*Nl_NNvhQǏ z0bVsN>yO-Nl_NN-Nv>yO /fYCQSv HTsQ O~ZSO0wƋLu0Q~lQOgbv Ng!j_ NgbN NzvFhg0 NKN^zNOo` NevvN ONSvt`!jW0ُy!j_v>yOOnc/fS_N>yOFd1NNCQSvb_` ۏeQNYCQS>yO0N{|cSN Ype;NIN vs^I{v8nbĉR  [݋;NSO _N_6qQsYCQ'`0ُy Ng!j_v>yO,g(/f>yOvRS0>yO_(Svhs b_bNSl[$RǏ z-NvYCQ[݋0 [1] 2.xvzel ,gxvzǑSv;Nel/fHhN>yOf[-Nv*NHhxvzl (WN[egQ1997t^ 2007t^ (WVQ gq_TvZSO NbSvxQWHhOۏL6eƖtetv^Џ(u|~el\O!jWRg0 HQ/fVQ gq_TvZSOv b0,geR+R(WBg_0Q~e0b~05uƉZSO0Q~[WI{Q*NZSOb__-N bN NTu;mhT R0ejmeQ0WSehT+g0-N.Y5uƉSeS0)Ym>y:SsQ)Y6 ُ5*N_ gq_TvNh'`ZSO\O:N bHhOv}SO vQ-Ne g O~ZSO_N gQ~ZSO e g;NAmZSO _N gkYSQrzXvZSO0vQ!k/f[HhOv b gTnx[2[ZSOf~NbSbċvHhO:Nxvz*NHh0(W Q@b gHhO-NۏNek b>yONHhNv[tsQ|[Rv VQg gq_Tv8*N*NHh0gT/fDevhQbdƖ [Nُ8*N*NHh NNTQ N'YϑdƖvsQDe0 N0*NHhN~Nċ 1uN,gxvzQ[Tel Nvyrk'` @bN g_(WُNR\@b bv8*N*NHh\O{vN~ S gbHhNvegS 0SU\Ǐ zSYt~gU\sQeg v^bHhNYtǏ z-Nyy>yONSTeb[vS fc:yQeg Mbf}YvtckevxvzTRg0 1.lWS _ёgRTNNHh 1997t^Sѐ]^lQ[R@\@\ _ёgRT~fd{k0d$OTNN0 0'Ylb 0sHQbSNُNHhN w[Blb'}e%NgY lQ_b Q NYo`04*NgT ѐ]^-N~Nllb$RY _ёg{kR0(u _ёg]v݋ N/f=h(WNKb̑0 2.l]NvY~bHh 2001t^ ĞgzW1V\"NWYu~N`N _f[ v^ۏLNlQ0ĞgSNT vQY&Ob~\vQWNNN _f[0 _Bcwɋ 1uNHhNvyrk'`_wYZSOvsQl f_SNl_LuvopN0N[lb$R[W1VeHe WNR_&O@b g0 _f[cw Nɋ N[~cNS$R0 3.Y[_RHh 2003t^R Y[_RV*g:d&^"fOO"6e[ (WQebzkSb{k0 0WSe^b 0!kb2NُNmo` T'YQzl}T _wN:_pST0Q~ Nv|TX NebcRN[HhNvOgT[vsQNXTvYt SNebOOlQONUS~v*NHhvcw NGS:N[6R^v(u0f[N^[ 06e[cRl 0ۏLݏ[[g0NMOf[ShXf chQVN'Y8^YO1\Y[_RHhS6e[c6R^[erQ/TRyr+Rg z^0)n[[;NcS_VRb8^RO ǏN 0QeR{tRl 0 ^bk 06e[cRl 00;NrTNgNEea$O[jYQ0 4.Ng`!`Hh 2003t^ NgBhVLzb 1uNRHhNXTv N\O:N NgBhvsY?QNg`!`r{k(W[-N0V]ZSOǑNdkNT(Wb>ySR N*gSQ?zN B(WQ~SQez zsS_wN^lsQl NN(WQ~ NSv~~~_`!`0NllblQ_[tdkHh mHhvlfNmZs_L[jcwlQɋ0 5.ĞYHh 2003t^  ĞYHh ~Q~ OdT (WhQV_wN^lsQl0dkHh_wNlQ[萄v͑Ɖv^bzNNHh~ v^MRTN!k[ĞY{kVۏLNt[0vQ7uSYOfkNmZ:_xYj.Uc0Vt^TlblQ^[t~gYejʑ>e0ĞYHhf2NbVs gvSlt[6R^vmqN v^_wN gsQ蕄vla02005t^2ghQVN'Y8^YOǏN 0sQNSlt[{tvQ[ 00 6.RmHh RmVccr g~~0[ў>yO'`(~~jI{j N[$RY{kR0Nv_^NVQgw TvRlTRNɋlN[[RmNHhۏL :NO[Ǐ zX[(WRkj .Uc0dkHh_w>yO Nvg'YN0f[N~~(WNN O~ZSOTQ NdecQ]va0)YR~Nmxvz@b1\Y['YHSNNS_{|N^O0 NMO_^chQVN'Y8^YOʑRl,{176agI{I{0_4lSNllblQ_[t $RYY['YHS gg_R3t^ g4t^gbL TeN~10NCQZё0f[1\dkHhcNNchQVN'Y8^YO[g 0^lё:ggT^lёNR;mRSRl 0v^fN0 8.T\n[ldNHh 2003t^ NINCgNςyeNuNgb0ς Nf z6q[lfTMRQQ \R_NKNY d{k 12 TOd$O0lbNςrNNjN[$RYvQ gg_R2t^0R3t^0ُN$RQ~g_w'YT0:NϑR*Y{ $RQ NlQck Bl͑e[t0f[~~de勋NN0T^RZSO6e0R gsQ蕄v S?zw 02004t^3g Hhg0 Yg]\O~gyN[ϑR&{Tl_ĉ[ lQOS fvvQNGW NX[(W02004t^ў_lwP%[XTBh=l0 gQS:N[lHh_wN-N.YؚB\[f-N{_g Bh/f=h(WQl NN0 bNi0WN~N,gxvz@b bv8*NzQS fN>yONSl[$RsQ|vl_*NHh0^ NُN*NHh-N bNkN_NUOePfnZi0W w0RNSl[$RL:ǸT@b+T@wv>yOV } vQ\O(u(WgNyr[vl_>yO`X N/fYdkKN'Y YdkKN_Y NNbNe`7h0O N{ǏR06q ^fv/f gN*NHh1uNSe OdvyyP6R NSxvz[*NHhvNS'`v:ON NSSlNXT_tǏ z|~vN[ O_Y[xvzeg_͑vSlNNRsQ|-NvgN~υNweg0ُ>f6q~bNvxvz]\O&^egNV FOsSOYdk YpeHhO-N؏/fTbNcONYvvsQOo`0 N0>yOq_TSlL:NvNNRg Nb\[8*N*NHhR+RR_{| [ N T{|Wvl_NN-NTyV }vNN\O(u;uQAm zV Џ(u|~velۏL=\Rg0 HQ g_N~N NُyRgelvtW@x0 cgq|~v`` >yO1\/fN*N_>e YBgv]|~ /fN*N~~|~ NvR'`0vv'`;mRSSN[ُ*N~~|~ۏLTNNĉ_vc0[2] T7h Nl_NNvSu~ǏSl[$R0RgTl_TgQs ُNǏ z_NSN w\ON*N^\N>yO?el|~vN*NP[|~ ,geyKN:N SlЏ\O|~ 0ՋV^zN*N>yOq_TSl[$RL:NvN,|~!jW0 Oo`S(WNUON*N|~-N/fNynfMsa Oo`Svhsb__/f_s'`v S1\/f|~vQNeQKN NS|~v N T }0 N TsQ|vvN\O(u0c6R|~R:N_s|~T핯s|~ (W_s|~-N c6R|~vQϑ Nq_T|~vc6R\O(u sS|~QzNeQzKNeSS(W핯s|~-N |~vQTeQKNX[(WSS sS|~vQ[c6R\O(u gvcq_T [3]0|~``]~^l^(u0RT*NxvzW 6q vQ(WVQl>yOf[xvzWv^(utS^8^\ ,ge\Ջ\vQЏ(uN>yONSl[$RNRvxvz-N0 SlЏ\O|~/fN*N핯s|~ l_NNvSuSƉ:N|~veQ gTvl_Tg HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn2" \o "" [a$]SƉ:N|~vQ0Qُ*N|~veQTQKN sSl_NNTl_TgKN X[(W@wSvS N(W|~Q萄v }KN_NX[(W@wvN\O(u sSOo`vS0 N SlЏ\O|~vR`~gRg 10S_NlvQz _f[~bHh (Wl_NN-NmSS_NlvQzveP (WHhN[tǏ z-N8^8^O_S:_pv>yO0l] _f[~bHh1\/fNO0 YV1@b:y S_l_NNSuT (WۏeQSl[t z^v Te _N_wNZ NN ZSObS [t 0We f[ V1 SlЏ\O|~~gV _f[Hh Fig.1 Structure of the justice operate systemcase of Zhang Xueying SOvsQl0ZSObSTlbv[t_S0We 0WeSǏeg_SZSOvmeQbS $NqQ T[Sl:gsQv[t]\ONuSRTq_T0[tv~gS_Y_Sf[(Wt Nvc [4]0[t~gTf[/gc\SOo` O~|~veQsS NN*N T{|l_NN v^q_TvQ[t~g0ُ/fN*N핯s|~ (WZSObS0>yOT[tǏ z N*NV }sv\O(u/fNNv0 ُNNNǏ zS[t~g[Nf[/gcv_S/fUSTv [tv~gTf[/g\O:Nte*NSlЏ\O|~vQOS vcS0ReQOSNz [ NN*N T{|l_NNvYtw0RN[vc6R\O(u0 dk{|HhNv&qp(WNS_wQ g0WW'`Te'` _N1\/f Nnx['` @bNWNdk{|HhN@bNuv>yO,g1\ g]_ l]S_0WTlf[f[v[z1\/fُy]_vSOs0l_TS_KNsQ| lf[[NSl[N gN*NW,gvqQƋ 1\/fSl[$R^S_܏yS_$Re0V:NS_wQ g Nnx['`Tv['` ُwnNS_v0We'`Te'`0 l[_N/f>yO[-NvN `Fd1NRYLuV }vr^pb/f NSv ُ/fN*N_xQWvHhO [SOsQNl[ꁫS_‰Nl_ }{QvQz SOsQNl[ꁫv0WWP6R'` SOsQNl[Slv]'YSRTq_T0 1uNHhNmSvS/f$N*N>yO0WMOvS_vNv)RvQz @bNte*NN/fV~sN>yOS_NlvQzTteTۏL v^l gmS0RNUOCgR f[vc_NNN/f(Wl_tvB\b N0CgR蕡l g(Wُ*NHhN-N>fs _Nl g~ZSOSlbeRNUOvSR0 6q Sl[$R-N \O:NSlvl[~8^MQOS0RS_vq_T begNY萋SR begꁎNQ_vS_hQ0V:Nl[_{\O:NN*N gowvgblegLR ge_NO cgq]vONTNkV lؚo`y{ƖDё]b:Nl%ONy{ƖDёv;N nS0Y['YHSv_^0R N)Y [$Rv N^/fY['YHS ^/f-NVPSvё{tSO6R0 NN ZSObS Q~ f[c CgR [t 6R^OU V2SlЏ\O|~~gVY['YHSHh Fig.2 Structure of the justice operate systemcase of Sun Dawu YV2-N@b:y l_NNSuT ZSObS_SQ~Tf[vsQl Q~Tf[[HhN,gT6R^vcb:NZSObSv[a NNN\O(u HTs NzKNR0>yOv%`b_bTf[vTYp|TT_SCgR蕄v͑Ɖ CgR[Sl[$RǏ zeQOo` g~Q[t~g0[tv~g\O:Nte*Nl_NNЏ\O|~vQOS vcS0ReQOSNz [ NN*N T{|l_NNvYtw0RN[vc6R\O(u0f[[CgRcQsQNO9evsQl_6R^v^ _N\q_T@wCgR蕄vvsQQV{ vQgTv~g_N\\O:N|~vQOSKNNǏS[ NN*N T{|l_NNvYtw0RN[vc6R\O(u0 dk{|HhNv&qp(WN}YNrl T` NTl N/f v`l SOsNl)RvN No6R^vQz @bN te*Nl_NN-NHTsNPvr` Ty{|Wv‰pؚ^vN [CgR蕌TSl:gsQNu]'YSR ُ_N/fHhNgT~gTNNlavN*N͑SV0(WُwHhN-N eSOsN}YNN v`l vQz _NSOsN*NNN6R^vQz (WُNHhNSlЏ\O|~!jW-N CgRSNvQ-N v^w0RQ['`\O(u0v^NCgR(Wdk{|HhN-Nv^*gvcp0RSMR S/f(WTSc[0 30+[6B\vQz[lHhTRmHh [ldNHhTRmHh^\N+[6B\QzvxQWHhO0[l5YTQ(ufQY]wQ gN&{SvaIN0 Rmf:NgƖVcNTN'YNh0$N*NHhN_w:_pvST /fV:NvMRnfMX[(WvNN>yO kYSlP%0gbl NlQI{I{ [NNb_bNy`~[R[XTT[N gyrCg`` ;`OQPCgRTё_gy sQgq 0(W+[]ݍb'YvN)Y [$Rv:ONlQ_OlQO[[NNTSl]~1YSON lQO NvOSlO["R[k`kvSeNƉ TN0 N{N[wvYUO lQO;`/f:ǸُT[υ@w NSJTNvN0ُ[( N/f>yO`~0>yO _RvNyb\0`OlQO[Sl͑hON 1\_{SlǏ z[hQlQckTlQ_0[lHhTRmHh/fV:NSl(WYt/f NYlQ_ fR_SlQOv(u YV3@b:y0 NN [t ZSObS Q~ f[c CgR V3SlЏ\O|~~gVRmI{Hh Fig.3 Structure of the justice operate systemcase of Liu Yong NV3eg w (WmB\SOs@w+[6B\Qzvl_NN ۏeQNSl[t z^T 1uZSObSQeg S1uNHhNS_NNSe"[[Rv`k]ݍTSl[tvv[:ONlQ_ _w:_'YvQ~(uTf[vc0:_'YvlO?e^NeQvQ-N CgR[Sl[$RǏ zeQOS g~Q[t~g0[tv~gTf[vc\O:Nte*Nl_NNЏ\O|~vQOS vcS0ReQOSNz0CgR Te[ZSObSTQ~eRSRTq_T _[Tc6R0 (Wُ$N*NHhN-N [[N6B\TSl:gsQv NON R NSl[tvv[:ONlQ_TTg;NAmZSOv1YXOlQOzzMRN0RmHh-NQsv N[afN /fN*Nyr+RV } ,geb[\O:Nf[-NvNRegxvz0ُNN[afNTlQOv^ NN u*b6q[z v^[N[[t~gNuNQ['`\O(u0FO[ NFOl g_0RlOvSTbb S b􁂚XNGr0V:NُQMON[(WQwQafNv Te _N_0RNvS_v~Nm)Rv ONNNf]vNf'`\O(u0kYT\n^?e^eRlQ[lQ_h`y\[Hh_U\g0 Yg =\_~O0eZSON*N#NvT{ Y0(Wў_lwYfN;Nc N wY8^YO[dkHhۏLNxvz nx[1u?el:gsQOlۏLg0 Yg0 dk{|HhN-Nv>yOQsTSU\vR`Ǐ z_N gN[vyrp01uNNN,gv?elOea'` ZSObSǏHhNT S0RCgR蕋SR1\O\Pbk~~bS0Q~Tf[velSV O~ZSO (Wُ̑ O~ZSO[Q~Tf[cvOo` O/fUSTv Q~Tf[vKNv\O(uN6q/fNNv0 CgR_N(Wg'YP^Q[Q~ۏL{6R0 O~ZSO0Q~0f[N Nz (WmSOeav?el'`e (WCgR蕄vSR NHTsQev`R0 40 CgR6B\Ns^lvQzY[_RI{Hh _ёgHh0Y[_RHh0ĞYHh0Ng`!`HhSOsNCgR6B\Ts^lvQz0 _ёgHhSu(W1997t^ S_eQ~؏l gnfS HhNl gmSY\Q~ gvS/f O~ZSOvbSTvQ_Svl0vQNv N*NHhO-N Q~RS%c@wvS_:_'Yv\O(u01uN _ёgHhYV4-1@b:y TY[_RHhYV4-2@b:y kxQW S gTyrp @bN,ge\USrRg$NHhvSlЏ\O~g0ĞYHh0Ng`!`Hh1uN gN[vvyOwv O?e^vb_aTZOS0R(u @bNCgRSN0RHh-N v^w0RN>f'`vq_T\O(u0lWSwYfNI{w^ gsQ[Bl[dkNb'}e%NgY lQ_b Q NYo`0,gHh-N>yO[Sl[$Rvq_TwQ gN[v['` u _ёg,gN ]/f{k(WNvKb-N ZSOvǏ!n2ngNOdkHhQs N@g Ns^l$a v@\b0ُf[>yO_N gN*N[‰vƋ >yOv^ N;`/fNhckIN gePZSO[T_NO g0,gHhCgRv^l gՋVc6RZSOvbS /fV:NُwNNHh-N vw4YNcT _ёgُ*NCgRgbL,gN NNLeƉv/fN*N UxvRvlQ[@\$*,        βββ΄hQh5hQhQh6h~YGh~YG5>*B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph)h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^Jph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h~YGh~YG5B* CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph3$ \ v ,>6N^R $1$a$gd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YGR Z \ t v *2<6JN\2z $ !!##$%'˴紂i0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph3h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph/h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^Jph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph) !#$J&'b)b+--./z1j3334^4d4f46kdE$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$ed#"Zgd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG''v)x)--..00112222p333333^4d4f4h4r4εΜΜ΀΀εi\Ci0h~YGh~YG<B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJphf4h4r4t4v4|4~44Y6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$ed# Dgd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edZJ>gd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YGr4t4v4|4~4444444455(:@;B;D;F;d;========zaGG3h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG<B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ4444444YB$hdPdd1$[$\$`ha$gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$ed*o$hgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd>$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edAyagd~YG44N5J7>9(:B;f;======$d$1$Ifa$ed@Rgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edlPjgd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG =======mY$d$1$Ifa$ed(gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$ed"x?gd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd7$$Ifr 634a===============lBnBpBB"E(E*E,E2E4E6E@EBEDENEPERE\E^E`EjElEnELLyyy3h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG<B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ'=======mY$d$1$Ifa$ed Kgd~YG6kd0$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edZqgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a======>>@lBB"Emaaaaaaa $dP1$a$gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$ed/,&gd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a "E(E*E,E2E4E6E@EYE$d$1$Ifa$edCgd~YG6kd|$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edBgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd)$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edE`gd~YG@EBEDENEPERE\EmY$d$1$Ifa$ed >bYgd~YG6kd"$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edxG gd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a\E^E`EjElEpEEFGmVJJJ $dP1$a$gd~YG$hdPdd1$[$\$`ha$gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edNKgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kdu$$Ifr 634aGI"KLLNNNNN$d$1$Ifa$ed7Ybgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edgd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG LLNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNSST~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Ͷw][ͶU3h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(0h~YGh~YG<B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6h~YGh~YG5>*B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph#NNNNNNNmY$d$1$Ifa$edAh4gd~YG6kd$$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$ed&B,gd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kdn$$Ifr 634aNNNNNNOO*QmVJJJ $dP1$a$gd~YG$hdPdd1$[$\$`ha$gd~YG6kdg $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edygd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd $$Ifr 634a KNŏs_NO _ёg(WN[-N1\$RY{kR0te*NHhNN[{US [tǏ zlQ_ NNl gSlP%v(u [t~gyOv Ng!jWHTsQTRm0[lHhv Tv`R0sS1u O~ZSOTQ~TwƋLuvOo` O/fUSTv eSS ُ/f1uNNNv?elOea'`O_CgR[ O~ZSOTQ~ZSOeRSR N bN O~ZSOv1YX0 Q~TwƋLuvKNv\O(u/fNNv NvNvNAmTMT]Yb_b alP _[@wte*N>yOvpT0 ,gHh-NvSlЏ\O|~-N yyV }vNN\O(ug~ObNl_6R^vO9eT[U OvQb:N|~vN*N͑QOS0ُ]~ gvf[Ɖ:NbVelCgЏRvN*N=Nv_Y0 NN Q~ CgR [t O~ZSOV4-3SlЏ\O|~~gVĞYI{Hh Fig.4-3 Structure of the justice operate systemcase of Huang Jing YV4-3 ĞYHhNNg`!`Hh:NvyONSl[$RvNRǏ z-N >yO\O(uNSl[$Rvg'YaINTgO~g0 N >yONSl[$RvNN\O(u 10>yO[Sl[$Rvq_T ǏN NRg >yO[Sl[$Rvq_T]~>f f }6q,gxvzel[>yOSR~Sl[$Rvzz bY'Yq_T\OϑSRg FO]~SNSsُyq_TvW,g{|Wyr_0>yO[Sl[$Rvq_TeSbvcq_TSSbcq_T e g[HhN[t~gvq_T_N g[[tǏ zvq_T0 YMRbmQ*NSlЏ\OǏ z~gV@b:y QNNk*NHhN-N>yO[[Sl:gsQ[tHhN bN[vvcq_T ؏ gQ*NHhN-N >yOǏؚB\CgR[Sl[$ReRSR cq_TSl HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn3" \o "" [b$]0*N+RHhN-N vQvcq_TTcq_T TeS%c\O(u0 >yOe[[t~gNuq_T _N[HhNv[tǏ zNuq_T0[[t~gvq_T_N g}YOWKNR0[‰eg w _ёgHhT _f[~bHh-N[[t1\NuN NovSRTq_T0>yO[[tǏ zvq_T N*Nf>fvOP[sSY['YHSHhv^[ /fxQWvZPy0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn4" \o "" [c$]ck/fV:Nُ/fN*NS0RlO0ZSOTؚB\sQlvHhN0 20Sl[$R[>yOvur_ >yONSl[$RvvNsQ|/fNNv Sl[$R[>yOwQ gur_\O(u0 Sl[$R[>yOvur_ HQ/fNyƉ~ Nvur_0\O:N;NSOvlQO /f(Wv[NY>yO gN[vqQ Twɉ b[wQSOv>yOsaT gvя wlvN0v[SO/fs[>yO NSTy>yOsa00[SO N T z^0WwQ gN'` [Nvc _0W_SlQOSN b_bYy>f'`0l_NN $\vQ/fNk'YvƖ-NS f>yOwvvl_NN _[fur_\O:N;NSOvlQOvƉ~TlaR0V:Nl_NǸTSOs@wN*NV[vef z^NS[lOvTyCgvvOb z^Sl[$RvǏ zYS fQlQCgR/f&TckS_LO lQs^ckIN/f&TY[s0ُNlQO-Nvk*N*NSOv)Rvo`o`vsQ0@bN 'Yĉ!jvsN>yOYvƖ-N(Wl_NNSvQSl[$RKN-N0 vQ!k Sl[$R[>yOvur_ ؏hs:NSl[$Rv zN [>yOvoS0Sl[$Rv zN geSOs:N~gvzN_NSb^zN'`vN geSOs:NǏ zvzN ُNOۏN>yORSvhv[s OvQb_bN*Nv[3z[v!j_ N oSNlQOǏ>yO[s݋CgTSNlQqQNir~blCgvp`0 Q!k Sl[$Rv~g gePY9eSlQOvgNNsN'`v̀yv O~‰_ [>yOvQ[w0R\oy؞Svur_\O(u0 gePY9eS>yOvsQl͑_0 gT Sl[$R[>yOvur_ gePǏCgR[v_[bvc T>yOl[݋cv[s0  N SlЏ\O|~vN,!jW  ёW[TX!jW }6ql_NNCS]N+R N T{|WvHhNvSlЏ\O|~ gvQryrv~g FONSN;`~QN*NN,!jW0ǏMRe[l_NN-N>yO Ng!j_vRg T[8*NHhO-NvSlЏ\O|~R{|+RۏLvR`~gRg SN_QbVSlЏ\O|~vN,|~!jW sSёW[TX!jW YV5@b:y0 A Sl[$R B O~ZSO C f[c D Q~ E CgR V5SlЏ\O|~vN,!jW Fig. 5 Model of the justice operate system te*NёW[TX1\/fSlЏ\O|~ vpANhSl[$R vpBNh O~ZSO vpCNhf[c vpDNhQ~ 8h_pENhCgR v^N__/fV[ؚB\CgR0A0B0C0D0E:N|~v8h_N }0S_6qN*NSlЏ\O|~-N N[OX[(W@wvQN } FO`\SlЏ\O|~Rg{_ 1\_{ NSbOOvQ8h_ }egRg [NvQN }fN_eu N0 ǏMRevRg Y wQ ёW[TX!jW-NvB0C0D1\/fSlNN-N>yO Ng!j_~g-Nv N*Ngp0 NvN\O(u b_b>yO [AsSSl[t OOo` eRq_T0ASǏeg_NTB0C0DSOo` v^[ Ngbv>yOw@wur_\O(u0 (Wُ*NёW[TXQ萄v8h_Y υ@wSlЏ\O|~-NvN*N;N }E sSCgR0ECgR TB0C0DSu@wvNv\O(u _N1\/f T>yO(W|~Q萐'`vlT[݋0ُylv~g gvhs:NECgROTASl[teRq_T gvhs:Nl_6R^vO9eT[U0(W NmS0R?elT6R^v3z[v`Q N CgR:ggyr+R/fV[ؚB\CgR N,O[SlS%c'`\O(ub NRr^m NOǏZSOp0RMRSS_HhNmSCgRP%blQO(uX[(WCgRP%e CgRyr+R/fV[ؚB\CgR 1\OsNMRS hCgR蕄v`^ v^[Sl蕽eRq_T0 ECgRyr+R/fV[ؚB\CgR _NO[ZSOۏL{6R RVc6R[T0RmHh0[lHh-NZSOvz6q1YX1\/fxQWvOP[0[NDQ~ CgR T7h/f(W[L@wg'YP^vv{0 OZlQqQWv\Ջ Y~%NyOlW6kSlЏ\O|~@bX[(Wvg'Yv0ckYbV'YYpef[@b;N _vSlrz t`v!jW-N[/f N^X[(Wv S_6q_NSb>yOvQs0FO/f N&Tv/f [N(WS_MRvu;m-Nnx[/fX[(Wv0>yO[NSl[$Rvq_T(WbVYYN>yO'YO[NSlv NON lQOvُy NONvNQ gV [ N T>yOegڋOv[hf >yOڋOv^T4xOWv;N[Rϑ/flQCg)R0>yOX[(WNs gvSlЏ\O|~-Nvg'YvaIN(WN [NSlCgRTvQNvCg)R g@wvcwT6Rav\O(u sSO/f gePur6RؚB\CgReg_[Sl FO/fُ(WS_MR_N/f gaINv0V:N S gS_SlP%vsa g'YE^^v9eUTmd SlL:NW,gOSlڋO:NKN Sl(W^zwSlCgZveP SlrzMbwckvwQ gs[aIN0 ُNRSNǏ>yOTSl[$Rvo'`NRegekv[s0 V0>yONSlvo'`NR Tle:NsN>yOv8h_yr(/f [݋ l 0sN>yO-N llV[vSlǏ z/fl_[݋vN*NxQ0 O~aIN Nv[(ckINb z^ckIN gN[vΘi'` ُ(WbVvMRlWgv̀of NfRf>f0bVlWg^[BlNyfRwQ gTt'`vckIN sS OSFUWckIN by:N e z^ckIN 0sSSl[$R-N Sl:gsQT)R[vsQNSlQOǏvNv[݋Tt'`OSFU [l_NNvYtbN ۏ b_bl_vĉR, Mb(WqQ Tavb_bǏ z-NNvOcckIN MbcR[SOl_6R^(WhQSNvOSFU-Ne[U0(W OSFUWckIN b  e z^ckIN -N /UNnx[v/fĉRb_bvl z^Tُ*N z^vckIN'` sSOSFUǏ zvckIN'` sSُy z^ckINp`p`SOsN [݋ ,g0 Ǐ>yOTSl[$R(WSO6RQvo'`NR OSFUWSlckINv|^yRleQ0Rl_vgbLǏ z-N0o'`NRSNƉ:NlQqQ>yOsX-N>yONSlckINNKN(WvNq_T-N@bbv|_dkT\ObTvt`>yOr`0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn5" \o "" [d$] N NSl(WSO6RQvckTZS_ (Wl_6R^FhgRek^z S\ N[Uv̀of N evbqvNTQZSO (WN O~ZSO $\vQ/fb RKNvzN0n0NRvǏ z-N :N*NN~bckS_Cg)R0:NwƋRP[SlQOha0LO݋CgR-d^wNNYlQqQzz [5]0ُ*NlQqQzzSN g]v}SO OYb R0Q~ Necy Q~]~b:NvS_1uhlQOXv;N}SO0 gvePlQlOrv /f]sLl_fecNlQlvTlCg)R gveP/f*gl_@bObvckS_Cgv gePvQckS_Cgvp`p`TsLl_v̀y0(WS_NNT  vqQ TRR N ُN'YYۏeQNSlЏ\O|~ ǏSO6RQvZS_ sSǏT\ONϑ$Ny 8nbĉR NvNRe_ _NN[ z^v㉳Q0>yOǏNSl[$RvckTZS_ p`p`ǏvQvcw\O(uO6RNSlP%savQs0ZS_xvzv͑p/fT*Nt'`*NSO(WvQL:NSuvcvN\O(uevQV{NTg0ُytNQzNT\O0eNNYOSv[V{ bSvQNRĉ_:Nxvz[a0Џ(uZS_egRg>yONSl[$RvsQ| Q NNN/fN*Nxvzelv V:N>yONSl[$RKNvsQ|1\/fN*N YBgvZS_Ǐ z0(WُNǏ z-N >yO\O:N SO6RQ vsN'`V } S%c@wvQ[SlckIN[svo'`cR\O(u0NhlONL?e0zl0SlI{V[CgR:ggۏLl0[݋TOSFU N [slONV[KNvo'`NR0ckTZS_v,g(yr_1\/fT\ONqQb0>yOvcwvv(WNvcwSl0OۏSllQck Slrzvvv T7h(WN[sSllQck $N g@wqQ Tv>yONyO;NINT>yOvۏ z-N >yO[NSlrzv[sS%c@w]'Yv\O(u @bN>yOvcw NFO N/fSlrzvx S /fvMRbVSlrz[sv͑O0>yOvvcwp`p`/fOSRSl[bNSllQckv~gvh (WT\O-N[bNqQb @bN >yONSlKNvNR/fNyckTZS_ ُyckTZS_/f gRNR^T>yOُNqQ TvSU\vhv0 v^^YgNf[b_v7h :_NSlvNROr^Slrz0Slvrz(WN[ z^ NNSlv~Q\g~SlP% :NMRc >yOǏNSl[$RvckTZS_ p`p`ǏvQvcw\O(uO6RNSlP%savQs0SlǏ z-Nv>yO NN~>yOTLuv gsQvOo` _N T7h~l[v'Yϑ gvvOo` vSRSOONfR[NL[ ُy[݋TlSOXRNvzfga ONfm;RtlaTla0>yOvcwvv(WNvcwSl0OۏSllQck Slrzvvv T7h(WN[sSllQck $N g@wqQ Tv>yONyO;NINT>yOvۏ z-N >yO[NSlrzv[sS%c@w]'Yv\O(u @bN>yOvcw NFO N/fSlrzvx S /fvMRbVSlrz[sv͑O0T>yOvN*N,g(vyr_1\/fYCQS :_vNOS R`s^a0 >yOvcwNSllQck/f>yO;NINT>yOvQ(WBl0 N OSFUWSlckINv`6q[s (W>yOlWg S_gNl_6R^ NN N^>yO S ;x>yOSU\veP 1\OrSNNwQ gnfM'`vl_NN _SlQOvsQlT ۏ _S[l_6R^X[^vc Q1uf[Ɩ-N|TTCgR:gsQ^bkel |TT^^eNBlvel0S_ُNNR[bveP OSFUWSlckIN_N_0RN[s ُNNN_N1\wQ gNN[v&{SaIN0OYY[_RHh-N NMOlf[ZSX NfNhQVN'Y8^YO ^[ 06e[cRl 0ۏLݏ[[g g~ObN 06e[cRl 0v^bkT 0QeR{tRl 0vck_[e0Y['YHSHhT f[N]~cNNsQNc[g 0^lё:ggT^lёNR;mRSRl 0v^fN0 gf[Shċ ǏS6RvNNN^:W~NmSR Nv^vl_lĉN_Ocku^bk ݏSNُ7hvl *g_/fNNOWN0 ĞYHhRcRNhQVN'Y8^YOǏ 0sQNSlt[{tvQ[ 0I{I{0yΘ(W 0fNQ-NVNvCg)R 0-N0R lQO _N N N0WSNNzlTSl v^ǏNSl0?el蕄vOSFUNNR Ol_v[eT@wQeNmS[0f[U0WObNlvCg)RveTbaoۏ0 kN*NS'`*NHhv ^aVTg b nQHe^ _N(WcR@wl_ĉR,gSuSi sSPRN?el蕄vr^ l_SO|nۏ0W9eoN 0 (Wl_‰_B\b N Ǐ>yOTSl[$R(WSO6RQvZS_ ǏlQqQwƋRP[vRRSN Ǐ*NHh-N*NSOCg)RS0ROb ۏ OCg)RaƋfmeQl_ OSFUWSlckINv|^yRnleQ0RSlǏ z-N0ck/f(W>yOTSl[$Rvُyo'`vNR-N $\vQ/f(WNNwQ g&{S'`aINvxQWl_NN-N (WlQqQwƋRP[v&^R N lQOegYNYvp`SN0R[wQSONNv-N $\vQsQlvQ̀Tv gsQ>yOlQO)Rvv~b0 kN!kObS[0ObNl)Rv0cۏzl[Uvo'`NR~g OlOS0RoRT0S0RvlQO\O~~Nf'Yvp`beQ0R[lQqQNNvsQl-NS l_ON\oy؞S(WlQOQ_b_b0  N SlckIN[>yOvo'`_[ (W>yOOۏOSFUWSlckINv[sv Te OSFUWSlckIN[>yO_NS%c@wN[vo'`_[\O(u0 HQ OSFUWSlckIN[>yOvu[\O(u0S_l_NNSOsN>yO;Nwve l'YYhs:N(` (WdkW@x N1ut'`v | cQ0l@bSOsQv Nn`~ (WlQqQwƋRP[@bNhv|v&^ N __Y(WُyOSFUNRvǏ z-NS_TNt'`0 ُylT[݋SSN(WN[ z^ NOt'`vl_0Rn kYHhNvYt~gObN1_RvS[vCg)R bNN&{T>yOSU\Rvl_lĉ_N[e0OSFUWSlckIN NN(WُyNR-N[s SǏeg_NYlOv Nn`~Se0WǏck8^ nSSlQeg __SN㉲Qz mdgN\o(Wv` (WN[ z^ Nw@w >yO[hQ v\O(u0 vQ!k OSFUWSlckINSNcؚ>yOv(ϑ0v(ϑ/fc@bhvNyO6B\0 N TvSuV0 N Tv[SOI{I{RRX[(Wzzv N Tzzv;NSOveS4ls^TOo`cSRASR`k [6]0'YOP*NNN7h geO gv$ReTt _N8^8^&^ g_Y^t'`V } vNKN_NO gN[vRgk0FO(W>yOTSlvNR-N (WOSFUWSlckIN[vǏ z-N >yO-NRgkv㉒Nv~ck GdFdv‰pNvbmNT OnNV[0@bN (WOSFUWSlckIN[svǏ z-N Yb(WNvQzKN N_s^a ُyޏ~ vNveEQnOgTvafcяN[0 ,{ N OSFUWSlckINOۏvZN0WMOvcGS0(W[sOSFUWSlckINvǏ z-N >yOُNl'`(vCgRvcwDn[E NQNN/flQl>yO/UNYN:_'YvlQCgRlT[݋0[\TbavRϑnl0SN l(WُNǏ z-N S%c@weg͑v\O(u >yO҉r0WMOncGS0 Se.s [1]  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/" \t "_blank" RNgf  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/fyx/" \t "_blank" QN.SlǏ z-Nvb__SvQsN'`yr([J]. QS>yOyf[, 20063 . [2] O[h. |~[M]. SNnNS'Yf[QHr>y, 1995: 201 [3] m.ꁨRc6Rb/g(WsN{t-Nv^(u[J].[] zb/g'Yf[f[b. 2003,(6): 32 [4] UOQ. laNl`  l6Rv6h[M]. SNV~QHr>y, 2003: 136~140 [5] yΘ. elCgЏRfNQ -NVNvCg)R [J]. 0FURhT R 0 2004-1:5 [6] [A]C. H. Cooley. Social Organization[M]. Schocken Books, 1963:185   HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref1" \o "" [`$]Wёyv2006t^ў_lw>yyWёNyyv 0T>yO-N>yONSl[$RvNRxvz 0(yvS06D028)6k'`xvzbg0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref2" \o "" [a$]ُ̑cvl_TgSb[$R~gTvQNTg OYl_6R^v^dT^z0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref3" \o "" [b$] ُv^ NNSlrz/fv`0ُ~TbVvSlsrwQSORg vMRbVNYNlWeg SlvP%TSl z^v NlQ_0CgR[NSlvr^mI{saOlON^zw[SlvON ُy NONMb/flO__ ^gPRN>yOeg0RSllQckvwckSV0>yO/fNyovcw vMRvQfY/f(W.^RSl:gsQ[sSlrz0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref4" \o "" [c$]nc 0"~eb 02003t^11g5ebS  _4lS[ُ!k[$RۏLN^8^w~vQY ubN>k͑eňONl^0 021N~~NmbS 02003t^11g04e[dkHhvbSRc0R  gmo` :NNd}Yُw[$R lbfZPN{|yOyf[ 20063 35 egn:u?elf[bf[b2007t^,{6g *Q~~~~~~~M6kd $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edqD!Igd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edgd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG~~~~~~~~YE$d$1$Ifa$edsngd~YG6kd $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd` $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edw`sgd~YG~~~~~~~mY$d$1$Ifa$edh'5gd~YG6kdY $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edI,7gd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd $$Ifr 634a~~~~~~~~~*024>@BLNPVXZdfZ BDz`3h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG<B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ~~~&D*02Z6kd $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edb'gd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG$hdPdd1$[$\$`ha$gd~YG6kd $$Ifr 634a 24>@BLNPY6kd $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edB))gd~YG6kdR $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$ed3Xgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YGPVXZdfYMMM $dP1$a$gd~YG6kdK $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edk0hgd~YG$hdP1$`ha$gd~YG6kd $$Ifr 634a$d$1$Ifa$edYo,gd~YG DbdHnԍDldRœ2&x $dP1$a$gd~YGDF`  2424:<npdʳ~~ʳʳe~L0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph6h~YGh~YG5>*B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJphxlְZJR^V6¿(PR $1$a$gd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YGְfhзҷطڷܷ޷FHNP68ϚϚeϚK3h~YGh~YG5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph6j h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph8<>DF¿Ŀ\^dh(PR̳̳̳̳̳̳蜕 h~YGh&y-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph#0182P. A!"#$%S EDd,  c :ANormalFax01C"jP src="/webcount/count.asp?newsid=38027"b!X󆡑NBD6nX󆡑NBPNG  IHDRfsRGB@}0PLTE{bIDATE!0Eq^uM&VUp\ &C|)"3.8̴(6 jPtsʄ&)NU- \^w& ^eyƾ_c|_^9IENDB`Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Q$$If!vh5r #vr :V 6,534 Dd V  3 C"J ((N@N cke $1$a$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ ؞k=W[SOBi@B nfh*S*Y(phb^`b ~YGnf(Qz)'$hdPdd1$[$\$`ha$CJKHOJQJ^J"W`" ~YGp5\)J "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& nMLHr!$'J+n0O4.9=BG)JwPX5Ip : H   wIf'/) d h r f z% /249;>@EGLMOb M\6H !"d#x#N$S$U$X$Z$_$a$f$h$m$n$p$$$%Q'T'V'Y'['`'b'g'i'n'p'u'w'|'}''''(E))))))))))))) **+,",1,,-..."00021H11111)22E3O4R6a6788;6=F=M?k@}@@A%CCCQDxDDD EOEQESEFFGHJ(J+Jr s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r dr s;r s;r }R*r s;r s;r s;r $r !r s;r s;r $r ?)r !r Y r $r s;r Y r r r $r r ?)r ?)r dr $r !r s;r vr ?)r $r Y r s;r s;r vr s;r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r r s;r s;r $r $r r r s;r dr vr <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r vr s;r s;r !r dr s;r &r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r r s;r s;r dr $r ?)r dr s;r dr <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r r s;r s;r dr c2r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r r s;r s;r dr ?)r Y r <<r <<r <<r <<r <<r s;r s;r dr ?)r r s;r s;r r Y r r s;r s;r &r r vr vr s;r r vr s;r s;r s;r ?)r Y r $r I@;r s;r &r Y r s;r ]r }R*r s;r I@;r !r s;r vr !r &r r s;r vr s;r vr s;r s;r s;r vr s;r vr s;r r Y r vr r wIf'/) d h r f z% /2349:;>?@EFGLMOb M\6H !"d#x#N$S$T$U$X$Y$Z$_$`$a$f$g$h$m$n$p$$$%Q'T'U'V'Y'Z'['`'a'b'g'h'i'n'o'p'u'v'w'|'}''''(E))))))))))))))))) **+,",1,,-..."00021H11111)22E3O4R6a6788;6=F=M?k@}@@A%CCCQDxDDD EOEQESEFFGHJ(J+JI0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0#"Z@0 I0I0ZJ>@0 I0I0# D@0 I0I0Aya@0 I0I0*o$h@0 I00I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0lPj@0 I0I0@R@0 I0I0"x?@0 I0I0(@0 I0I0Zq@0 I0I0 K@0 I0I0/,&@0 I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0E`@0 I0I0B@0 I0I0C@0 I0I0xG @0 I0I0 >bY@0 I0I0NK@0 I00I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0@0 I0I07Yb@0 I0I0&B,@0 I0I0Ah4@0 I0I0y@0 I00I0I0I0I0I0@0 I0I0qD!I@0 I0I0w`s@0 I0I0@0 I0I0sn@0 I0I0I,7@0 I0I0h'5@0 I00I0I0I0I0I0I0b'@0 I0I03X@0 I0I0B))@0 I0I0Yo,@0 I0I0k0h@0 I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0wIf'/) d h r f z% /2349:;>?@EFGLMOb M\6H !"d#x#N$S$T$U$X$Y$Z$_$`$a$f$g$h$m$n$p$$$%Q'T'U'V'Y'Z'['`'a'b'g'h'i'n'o'p'u'v'w'|'}''''(E))))))))))))))))) **+,",1,,-..."00021H11111)22E3O4R6a6788;6=F=M?k@}@@A%CCCQDxDDD EOEQESEFFGHJ(J+JI0)\S`dhlI0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0#"Z)I0- \S`dhlI0ZJ>)I00 \S`dhlI0# D)I03 \S`dhlI0Aya)I06 \S`dhlI0*o$h)I09 \S`3dhlI0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0lPj)I0E \S`dhlI0@R)I0H \S`dhlI0"x?)I0K \S`dhlI0()I0N \S`dhlI0Zq)I0Q \S`dhlI0 K)I0T \S`dhlI0/,&)I0W \S`dhlI0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0E`)I0` \S`dhlI0B)I0c \S`dhlI0C)I0f \S`dhlI0xG )I0i \S`dhlI0 >bY)I0l \S`dhlI0NK)I0o \S`3dhlI0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0z \S`dhlI07Yb)I0} \S`dhlI0&B,)I0 \S`dhlI0Ah4)I0 \S`dhlI0y)I0 \S`3dhlI0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0 \S`dhlI0qD!I)I0 \S`dhlI0w`s)I0 \S`dhlI0)I0 \S`dhlI0sn)I0 \S`dhlI0I,7)I0 \S`dhlI0h'5)I0 \S`3dhlI0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0b')I0 \S`dhlI03X)I0 \S`dhlI0B)))I0 \S`dhlI0Yo,)I0 \S`dhlI0k0h)I0 \S`dhlI0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0)I0\S`dhlhI00(J 'r4=L~D8R*-/15<fkmn f444==="E@E\EGNN*Q~~~2PxR+.02346789:;=>cdeghijlR,IM CGcg---...7{88CCCC#D'DSEEEFFFFHGLGGdHhHHbIfIyIIIIII)JXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX _Toc76553167_ftnref1 _Toc76553163 _Toc76602533 _Toc76602540_ftnref2 _Toc76602541 _Toc76602542 _Toc76602543 _Toc76602544 _Toc76602545 _Toc76602546 _Toc76602547_ftnref3_ftnref4 _Toc76602548 _Toc76602549_ftnref5 _Toc76553188 _Toc76553189_ftn1_ftn2_ftn3_ftn4_ftn5w  5g#*",-..1176=k@SEFFGH+J  = h5w#-+#,-..1186=|@EFMGiHgI+J4=t=$\A_ApHH+JzHH+J8*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace;*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagschsdate $## 041120035DayFalse IsLunarDate IsROCDateMonthYear  JMQUknwDGJQRYZ]@C JJJJJJJ#J%J&J'J+Ji l FlIoIJJ+J:::::z:::zf F+JMF+J;56wHPlwH~wHxG fh"<':""wH}vdwHvwHt3wHwH7i=AtwHawHh'5lbE;wHLUwHowHwH5)wH wH wH Je wH  wHv wH wH} wHLf wH_ 6HOwHUnwHpthUwHwHyWwHFwHDXwH1wHLwH_X{wHh,?"O/FwH wH(w%^"D#E'wH}CwH!wHCa( UVwH$wH5DwH`wHpwHjwH"O6Hn wHwH- wH/j7!wHO,n!wH*i!wH d"wH"wH"D#wH4=&wH/,&Lb'J H:6'Z`>'wHWY'wHa(wHB))4jdYo,E}1*,wH&B,k7pR0wHqt1pt XsaF2wHy2wH@3wHAh4JT!4wHe5wH>5wH:6wHI,7Ate7wHk7wHL7wH<9wH<':6HJ H:wHPv:wH4:wH7i=wH Z=wHw=wHZJ>wHZ`>6H"x?Cs+?wH`?qt1,>Zp@wHB2wAZBwHACwHJDwHEDwHwlDwH# DwH14EwHK/fEwH7FwH6HwHwHqt1,< IwHqD!IK/fE%fI6H,VIwH KsaF2NKqiLwH:(QwH^QwHo RwHKRwH@R+?VRwH_kTwHJTwHpTwHTwH3X/j7!j(BXqt1K_XwH >bYv ^cYwHiYwH#"ZwH-L[wHO\wHw%^wHE;^wH~ l^wH}_wHE`E;^oawHAyawH7YbocihlbwH4jdwH dwH.newHdCewHewHgTfwH*o$hwHocihwHMlhwHfhwHk0hPlhqiwHXi_ AjwHlPj_kTO jwHjwH{kwHMlwH2;lwHmwHsn1*,1"owH'7pwH wqwHK=rwH@vrwHCswHw`s2;l#{tswH twHqDvwHY4w%fI2wwHUxwH0ywHyw=xq{wHfW|wHE}wH}K}wH_}wH9}wHF~wH~wHU ~wH'lwHZq-L[}wH$:~YG&y/2349:;>?@EFGLMN$S$T$U$X$Y$Z$_$`$a$f$g$h$m$n$Q'T'U'V'Y'Z'['`'a'b'g'h'i'n'o'p'u'v'w'|'}')))))))))))))))+J@(J(JĂ(J(Jp ')JPP P@PPP(P2PFP~UnknownG:Ax Times New Roman5Symbol3& :Cx Arial;([SOSimSun 1hA&B& ?% ?%!-!),.:;?]}    & 6"0000 0 0 00000 =@\]^([{  0 0 00000;[JJ3HX?~YG2 AdministratoradminOh+'0`   ( 4@HPXAdministrator Normal.dotadmin2Microsoft Office Word@F#@n.ڐ@;ڐ ?՜.+,D՜.+, X`lt| %J  8@ _PID_HLINKSA `;&-http://law.hit.edu.cn/fyx/$3*http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/-~'ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref5-$ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref4-x!ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref3-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref2-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref1;&http://law.hit.edu.cn/fyx/$3http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/9.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn59.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn49. ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn39. ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn2$3http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/9.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn1Ihttp://law.hit.edu.cn/llm  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnoqrstuvwyz{|}~Root Entry F;>ڐData p1TablexjWordDocument2SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q