ࡱ> rtqq` R"~bjbjqPqP2::7$$["B$!!!!!!!$M#h%N!9!"PPP!P!PPP 0n# lP!+"0["P&4&PPB&!$P!!P["d Hd H VESl z^vSU\SvQ[VElvq_T \O: HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf" \t "_blank" uwm\ | S^e:2011-5-4 15:47:39 | pe: 356 VESl z^vSU\SvQ[VElvq_T  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/" \t "_blank" uwm\[`$] Xd яNASt^eg VElb0'kvlbTVERNlbI{VESl:gg z^vSU\ HTsQN|RevRNRT0VESl z^e/f(WlQck'`THes'`eb ؏/f(Wꁫ[UTNCgObeb gN>fWvR:_0ُNSSXRNVElvR'`00N[NVElvQ[ v^[VElv;NtT nnf[I{ NuNN|Rvygq_T0 sQ.͋ VESl z^ VEl Title: The Developments of the Procedures of International Judicial Organs and its Influences to International Law Abstract In recent twenty years, a series of new tendencies and trends have occurred on development of the procedures at International Judicial Organs like the ICJ, CJEU and ICC. The international judicial procedures, no matter on impartiality and efficiency or on improvement of itself and the protection of human rights, have been clearly strengthened. These developments have reinforced the hardness of international law, and enriched its content, and led to many positive influences on theories of the subjects and sources of international law. Key words: international adjudicature, procedures, international law [\O{N] HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/" \t "_blank" uwm\ 1963- _lςciN 7u T\n]N'Yf[lf[bYec0 _ VESl z^ (W,ge-N;N/fcVESl:gg [1](W[tHhN-N@b(uv z^0VESl:ggvi_ 8^ g^INTrINKNR0^INvSl:ggbQ:gg ;N/fcsLVESO|-NNVE~~0VE6R^I{b__0Nl_vel㉳QVENzv z^N~~ sSSbSlelTNel0rINvVESl:ggNNcNSlve_㉳QVE~~v z^N:gg0,ge(WrINvVQSl:ggv z^0FO/f ,ge@bcvVESl:gg N TN8^(W㉳QVENzvFhg N@bcvVElbI{NPNNV[:NS_NevVESl:gg /flc[t\1uV[bVE~~:NNevHhNvVESl:gg cgqChristian TomuschatTCesare P. R. RomanoI{Nvxvz ُySl:gg^&{T7*NwQSOhQ8^'`01uVEag~I{^z0OgqVEl[Hh0NNHQX[(Wv z^'`ĉ[:NW@x[Hh0[t~gwQ gl_b_gR; l[^(WHhNcNMR]~lQckv:g6R N ^1uS_Ne [HhN\NeS_Ne:N;NCgV[bVE~~0[2] P713 NǏ ,gevxvz_NSbWTONz㉳Q:g6Rُ7hvQSl z^SO|TMRWSNbSeVERNl^Nr^VESvRNSl:ggُ7hyrvVESl:ggv z^0 BrownZSX:N VEl^8^(W z^TQeNmebǑSqQ Tvel0ُyTqQ TelvSU\OVESl:ggv[T$ROl(Wnx[T[e z^TQeNmCgRebwQ g NeXYvqQ T'` N:NُNpO VE[$RvqQ Tl bVE`N` z^l_NNu0[3] (PIX)ُ/fbNY(WOYvVESl z^-N~bQqQ TĉRvW@x0VESl z^8^/fcNzeTVESl:ggcwɋNSl^cSHhv^ۏL[tTZPQQvN, z^ 8^Sbwɋ0fNb z^0Rek[0D&^ z^0S4Y z^0$R0(Wyr[`Q Nv NɋSvQQvgbLI{Q[01uN N\VESl:ggewQ gɋ{Cg_NwQ gT⋡{Cg @bN,gevQ[_NmvVESl:gg(WLOُ$Ny{CgYtHhN-N@bO_v z^0 N0VESl z^vSU\RT VESl:gg(W~NmhQtSTNCgnfMSI{V }vq_T N gяNASt^egS_NNNwvveSU\HQ/fevSl:gg Ne^z OVESl:ggXR0R20YO*NvQ!k/fNN O~vVESl:ggۏLNm^9eiQ!k/felbStHhNvpeϑ'Y'YXR0 [NVESl z^vSU\ ,ge;NN N*NebۏL‰[0N/f[e^zvVESl:gg@bĉ[vSl z^0ꁷQbNT gяNASt^ege^NvS_peϑvVESl:gg YVEwm mll^0WTONz㉳Q:g6R Nɋ^ 0$N*NVEyrRNl^0VERNlb0r^VESRN[$R:gg0^2mNCglbI{I{0N/fRg O~VESl:gg@bۏLv z^9ei0@wVESl:gg0WMOv NGS r^ O~vVESl:gg@bStvHhNevXY QsNRHhHes Nؚ yHhXRI{0:Ndk N\VESl:gg(WяegۏLNm^9ei0ĉ!j'Yv9eiY'k2mNCglbv$N'Y9ei0'kvlbSO|e^v$N~ N~lbTl^ I{I{0VElb_N(WR_RHh z^ebZPQNRR0 N/fNTSl:ggvwQSOSl[T$RO-NRN‰[ Sl z^vNNĉR/fǏ$RO@bR^v l[(W[$RǏ z-N_NOn gsQv z^ĉR Ǐ[Sl[ SN_TSl:gg]\Ov[E`Q0 яt^eg VESl z^vSU\HTsQN NN'YRbRT N VESlɋ z^vN,'`R 10 z^NncĉRe[U VESlv z^NncĉR@wVESl:ggv Ne^z ȏTNe[Uvۏ z0YgVElck(WN O~vN[SOl:N;NT[SOlN z^lv^͑v[teSO|SU\ [4] (P88)VESl z^(WvQ-N@bS%cv\O(u/fg:N͑v0(WNe[[N(uUOyncĉRvP6R0VEl^(W[-Nĉ[NSN1uǑ(uncv^KNl[_'Yv1uϑCg v^(uLCg;NINv[_!j_0S_NN;NINvc!j_S[l_ z^vb^Tؚb,gv/eQ0VERNl^[ncvǑ(uǑS1uve_ (Wnx[ncv gHe'`0SǑ'`0ncv0WMOTg~v͑'`e l[N[ NnboNwQ g_'YϑCgvrz$Rv҉r0(W[-N _\O gnccd(WVERNɋv z^KNY0VERNɋǑ(uejc[vW,gSR ĉ[>N#N1uwɋeegbb0@wlbSl[vXR Ne[UN8^VElb_Y VElbv z^ĉR_N~SNr^!k͑O9e N ev[Y0 20:_6R{Cg_R:_ VESl:gg(WQbNTvSU\f0WHTsNVE>yOY0W^zwQ g:_6R{CgvSl:ggvR0 O~VESlv{Cg }NV[ Ta:NSR :ON^ gv:_6R{Cg/f;xVESlS%c\O(uvN'Y%N͑x :_6R{Cgv^z eu/f[ N O~VESlĉRv O_VESlvЏLǏ zfwQ gR'`0ُ/f[ O~vVEltvNySS'`vz4xTSU\0 N ُyz4x؏QsNnR:_vR4Y0OY MRWSl^0bSel^TWTONz㉳Q:g6RI{ ĉ[N:_6R{Cg0wm ml^wm^NzR^[ 0TTVVEwm mllQ~ 0ĉ[VQvyr[Nz_NwQ g:_6R{Cg0 NN O~vSl:gg Ǐ9ei_NnxzN:_6R{CgvSR Y'k2mNCglbǏ1998t^v9ei [N*NN3uɋv{ ebXTV Ta1\wQ g:_6R'`v{Cg0'kvlb[NvQbXTVKNvNz _N8^wQ g:_6R{Cg0:_6R{Cgvnxz [NVESl:ggRR[[0WS%cvQ㉳QNz0ʑl_v\O(u wQ gsQ͑vaIN0 30 ɋ;NSOeY7hS cgq O~vVEl VESl/fN*NS g;NCgV[MbwQ gɋCg)RvW0ُNyrpgYxNvQ\O(uvEQRS%c OKNN^eeNv?el0~NmTVEsQ|vBl _N/f[evVESl:gg'Yϑ^zvSVKNN0яeg^zvVESl:ggegY0WAQ*NN0VSONSVE~~vSN0~N^V[L:NSONv^0WMOvVESl:gg]~'Y'YYNNN[~;NCgV[vVE'`lb0OY wm ml^vS_NedN~VKNY ؏Sb?e^VE~~0vQwm^NzR^vS_Ne dN~VT?e^VE~~KNY ؏ gVEwm^{t@\bON0V%ON06qNblN0'k2mNCglbvS_NedNbXTVKNY NUO6qN0^?e^~~T*NNVSO(Wyr[`Q NGW gCgNV[:NJTvcTlbcwɋ0[N'kvlbSO|eg Q/f6qNTlN SbONTONOSO9hnc'kvag~cQvl_QeNmɋGW1u'kvN,lbb'kvlQRXTl^[t0?e^ VE~~0^?e^~~0*NNTQVlbI{(W N Tv z^ NSNNVESl z^0;`KN vMR^V[L:NSO]~SNSN~'YYpeVESlɋ v^N(WAQvQQsvlb NvQ gsQvHhN]`SbHhNv~'YYpe0 N 0nxO z^lQck'`veR 10 VESl:gg-Nl[vnfMNh'`X:_ VESl z^gR&^ gYveNyO;NINV[vg'Y NON0FO/f ~ǏgvSSSU\TVEsQ|esQ|[R0VENCgSl:gg0VEL?el^TVERNSl:gg[l^KNShsNygv"kΏ`^ gsQl^KNSXdvO(u gя(WWTONz㉳Q:g6RFhg N_wNgRpvb0vMRdSR Ncb*NNvSl:ggYVElbI{[l^KNSRhsQ%NPT0;`SO N l^KNS[NVESl z^vSN g)RNR:_Sl z^vl;N'` Oo` N[yI{ gRNl[ZPQf:NlQck0s^aNcknxvQ @bN[vQvO(uev^l0 40 nfMR:_Nl_cR]\O 1uNVESl9(uf5 NNNVESl:ggBl_{1u_^NtQ^ O_~NmVvV[T~~N+Vv*NN[VESlg tSek0:NNRT/ecSU\-NV[TvQN~~T~NmVv*NNEQR)R(uVESl㉳QNzT8O _Cg)R egYvVESl:ggR:_N[V[b*NNSNVEɋvl_cR]\O0Y[VElbTVEwm mll^R+R^zN OSRV[ǏVElbVEwm mll^ ㉳QNzvTTVyfNOXbWёOXbWё  0'k2mNCglbSN(WɋvNUO6k~N~NmV gdkv3uɋNl_cR [7] (P544)I{I{0l_cR[NRT/ec gsQvV[0VSOT*NNfR^l0WЏ(uVESlTs^㉳QNzNSOcSlb[$RvCg)RwQ g͑aIN _N/fVESl:gg^S_RSU\vN*N͑W0  N 0RBlcؚ z^Hes'`veR 10 BlɋHes0͑Ɖ{f z^ PVQSlN7h VESl_Ne͑ƉlQck_N͑ƉHes0яeg TVESl:ggStHhNnfMXY [ gvlbyHhl͑ RHhHes_NO0VESl:ggb[ُN ǑSNX[$R:gg0O9e z^ĉR0XRNRDnI{9eice NcؚɋHes0YVElb1997t^wǑS z^'`0b/g'`TNRDnI{ebvTyce R_RHhHes S_NN[Heg0WTONz㉳Q:g6RtNVE8fNz㉳Q[Nev'}'`Bl ǑS(WN[~T Nɋ:ggvT*Nɋ6kĉ[fnx0~vRHhgPve_ teSOcۏ z^v_SU\ Hesgؚ0wm ml^[Nk%`도vBlʑ>e9ST9XTvBl (W z^ĉR-N NFOBlOHQ[t Nĉ[Nwv[tgP (W[-N)wNɋ z^0MRWSl^TbSel^돎NHhNvSRTsQ蕄veP f/fǑSNOYvR_ z^ۏ^vce0NNVESl:ggb[yHhl͑ ENb NQv R:_N[N{f z^vO(u0VElbTwm ml^GW g{f z^R^I{ gsQR^0:NNR_'k2mNCglbvRHhHes 2004t^(W z^ NۏL{S Yĉ[1urNl[T1u3N~bvT^[tN[nZiT͑ Y'`HhN [N{_HhN NNStI{ NVR_RHhv^0 NǏ [NHesvBlv^^@b glbvRvh YVERNlb(W^zN8t^JSKNT \*g[~NwHhN0ُ*N]~_wN gsQebvsQl0 20 Ǒ(uBl[HevmTɋ!j_ VESl:ggvy{|A~Y e glNTL?e'`(v _N gRNT[l'`(v0VESl z^vSU\-Nk>PTN~ǑO0FO/fMRWSl^0bSel^T^Xb)Rfyr+Rlb NS(WN[ z^ N VERNlb vQ z^;`SO N/f[b6R bS_NN;NINv0FO$N*NyrVERNl^Teg:NNR_RHh^v (WY!kO9evQ z^ĉRǏ z-N GW8T6eNNNLCg;NINvĉR OɋSO6RTmTSO6RǏ!n lb(W$RQ-NfcQ  VERNl^vɋ z^@bOncvTf[ e(WnflSO|vc_!j_TTllSO|v~_ z^KN~cgys^a TeOckINv[s0 [a$] gN\vQ}T T:N {t[$R!j_ Managerial Judging Model 0 NYUO (Wɋ!j_ N ckINv[s S_NSeKNfkňs^I{ lQckɋCg)RSRTHesI{ __/f6R[ z^ĉROHQQvV }0 V 0OckS_l_ z^vNCgCg)Rv=[ @wNbNTNCgnfM'`vR:_ SOs(WVEN:SWNCgĉNhQ-NvVENCg[NVESl z^vq_T_Nevf>f0VESl z^e(WĉRnTwQSOHhNvYt-N _0RNONlQck[$RCg)RvVEhQvNv=[ _NegYvO0OY [NVEl^Nl[vrz'`NlQck'`vBlXRN ;`SO NBlOlQck[$RvCg)R z^[b'`vO g@bR:_cs^I{0SlvcwI{I{ gNegYvĉ[0 VEckS_ z^ NNMRWSl^0bSel^TVERNlb@bSv^ĉ[N[Nvĉ~KN-N N_N(WvQTꁄv$RO-NRNЏ(u0 gsQvO/zNte*N z^vY~0VERNlbĉ~T z^ĉRNVENCgeN-NǑ~N'Yϑv z^OvQ[Nj NN[0cs^I{0[MRŏJTwcɋNSnclQ:yvCg)R0_eNыvCg)R0rjZuNTJTNvbCgI{ gsQCg)RvO0Q-^l^[$RNSNSvQOb'`ce0ejc[0 N:_vQjNSOcl؞vCg)R0[@bSO[_TPvCg)R I{I{0[8] (P500) VElb(WvQ[tHhN-N _NRVOS_Nev[hQs^I{ lQckeOP (WhQ萆NSe`QKNTQZPQQ0 ddkKNY egYvVESl:ggygcRɋvf^TlQ_'`0SbXRgHhwSPgevS'`Tĉ[_^SR NlQ_ۏLI{I{0VElbekX:_NvQRHhvf^0VEwm mll^ĉRǑ(uNVElbvge[~ :_fT^:g['`/fW,gSR0[9] (P140)MRWSVERNl^v_^`QSNǏQ NƉ[e6e w 'k2mNCglb_N_YNQ NƉ[eldv]\O0SlvlQ_'` R:_NSlvSO^ O Sl NFOlQck N w@wlQck v TwQ gNۏNekvSOs0 N 0l_(uebveR 10 VESl$RO(WSl-Nv\O(u>fWX:_ VESl$RO}6q cgq 0VElbĉ~ 0,{38agvĉ[ N/fck_vl_ nn FOvQ(WSl[-Nv\O(u/f>N{͑v0 0eY,gwmVEl 0cQ  Sl$RQ]~b:NVElvSU\-NN*Ng͑V } NSl$RQvCgZT gR geO[NwQ g[N(Wb__ N@bN gvfYvaIN 0 [10](P24)NTVESl:gg,geg w VElb0'k2mNCglb0WTO Nɋ:ggI{VESl:gg(W T{|HhN-NSR Nu[v^ Nec_vQHQMRv$ROMRWSTbSel^\~&O!XTNNQNl^v$RONSvQꁫvSl`O$RO vteSO\O:N `N`l RN(u0 [11] (P500) nc N\f[v‰p (WWTONz㉳Q:g6R-N 1uN Nɋ:ggv'YRcLT NeRR vQ$RO  WTO:g6R-NvN[~T Nɋ:ggbJT Nɋ:gg@b\Ov'YRQ $\vQ/fvQ-Nvl_ctNSlʑ }6ql gl_ Nde jure vu_HQOvĉ[ FO/f(W[-Nb_bNN[ Nde fact*02   βββ΅nRnR9R9n0h hh h>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh hh hB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h hh hB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph/h hh h5B*CJKHOJQJ\^Jph)h hh hB*CJKHOJQJ^Jph6jh hh hB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h hh hB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h hh h5B* CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph3* x Z`bB^D\!!l%%% $1$a$gd h $dP1$a$gd h"~ &Z^@B\DZ!!l%%%%''*,*,,R/t/v//346667<<<<@JKKN>NLTjTjjββΙΗU0h hh h>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh hh hB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h hh hB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h hh h5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph;%''*.*,,R/v//r33467:<<<>KKN@NPLTlTVV $dP1$a$gd ho vwQ g]yr_v u_HQO vHeg0$RO]~b:NN!kNTmvOS[vck_l_ nn0 [12] (P75) 0Wlĉ~ 0,{21ag,{2>kffnxĉ[VERNlbSN(uvQNMRv$R@bʑvl_SRTĉR ُh_@w(Wag~-Nfeĉ[$ROHeRvN'Yz4x0N*jTvsQ|eg w TVESl:ggvN_(uvQ$RO $\vQ/f_(uVElb$ROv`QgvQ8^0'kvlbxvz'k2mNCglbvsQ$RO]b:NvQ gsQNCgHhN[$R]\Ov_~ z^ [$ROv_(uf/fASRA~0 20 VQlvV }(WmT'`RNl^-Nv\O(uzQ VES mT RNl^vQs/fVEl[e:g6RяgvN'YSU\0z(WQzTV[vmT'`l^vNR/f[VErjZPQQ0ُasT@wVQlNVEl[e:g6RvevT0l^N mT }T T/fQ0RvQ TewQ gVQTVEV } Te1u,g0Wl[TYVl[~bNS Te(uVElNVQl0l^vz8^/fWNVQ?e^NTTVvOS[0l^N[eVERl:Nvv Te_NAQVQ?e^[SlNXT0Sl z^T(ul_LON[vϑCg0[13](P160)ُymTl^NhNVQ0VElSO||_dkNAm0|_dkq_TvNye!j_0VQlV }(Wُ{|l^-Nv0WMO>f6qkvQ(WvQNVESl:gg-Nf:Nf>fTzQ0 30 VESlNVQSlKNv[݋emeQ0 VQl[__ NN[eVQl _N[eVEl0@bN g\OcQ vMR1uNVQlbTVElbsQ|v4я SN\@b gvSl:ggy:NhQt lbqQ TSOcommunity of courts  [14] (P192)bN~R[1\OSs Ǐ N Tvb__T_ VElbTVQlbl[N~8^ObNAm R:_N[݋T0NNǏ NQNvNvl_a v^vNRNc_0SN NNAmvl[ NQ\]NNƉ:NgNyr+RSl:ggvNh N_N\]TvQNl[Ɖ:NNyqQ TvVNNv TN0b[qQ Tv[SOT z^ NNvNf[`N|_dkv~Nct vcvNT\ON㉳QN蕉Nz0ُymeQTA~vNAmNT\O e/f[VQSl؏/f[VESl eu/f gvv0 ObVESl z^Nu NSSvSV/fYebv Sb~NmvhQtSTNCgvnfMSNSVEl,gvV }I{I{0HQ/fNbNTNCgnfMSvq_T[N[NckS_ z^vBl O_VESl z^SuNN|RvSS Y z^-NckS_ɋCg)RvOf:N[Y l_cRI{KbkeR:_I{I{vQ!k/f~NmvhQtS[[NǏSl㉳QNzv_cۏQ!k/fSU\-NV[(WNbTv~~rzT(WVEsQ|-Nv\O(uf:N͑OVESlvNh'`TlQck'`_NR:_,{V/fVQSl6R^TVESl6R^KNv^lNR0VESl:ggꁫvSU\ĉ_[vQSU\bq 1\TVQlbf[`N ُ1\[NN[~[6R0l^KNS0:_6R{CgI{6R^v^zTSU\0,{N VESl:gg,gvyrp_NQ[Nr^VESl z^veRTvQs VESl:gg/fkleU\q_Tvg}Y:W@b 1ueg N Tl|T N TV[vzlTSl@b6R[v z^ĉR_6q[(Wɋ!j_ NZSǑOvmTɋ!j_vQs0gT VEl,gvyr__N[NVESl z^vNNSU\ YVElzlvVNSSl,gvĉ_I{[$ROl\O(uvR:_I{I{0 N0VESl z^[VElvq_T VESl:gg(WNbNeg $\vQ/fяNASt^egv'YϑXRT O~Sl:ggv9ei@b_vVESl z^vSU\ [N O~vVEl&^egNN|R͑q_T0VESl:gg(W㉳QNz0SU\VEl0ObNCgI{ebS%c@wev͑v\O(u >f:yNl_(W㉳QVENzǏ z-N\O(uvR:_ N gbNevbvVEllv͑Ns0[15] (P5)OYVESl:ggv^zTЏ\O eEQTibU\NVElbI{ O~VESl:ggvL :NVElň NNYr N N9evQg'`l_vb_a0ُNevSU\ y:N20N~VElSU\-Nvg:N>fWvyrpKNN _N g\O:N/fQbTVElv/UNvg͑vSU\0[2] (P709) wQSOeg VESl z^vSU\[VElvq_TSOs(WY Neb N X:_NVElvR'` cRNVEllv^0VESl z^SvQЏ\O:Ng'`vVElĉRň NN )Rv Yr X:_NVElvR'`T~_gR OvQN O~vVQl gNegYvvevle:NVEl;NSO VESl z^@b&^egvN|RevV } Y^V[[SO $\vQ/f*NNN^?e^~~(WVEɋ-N0WMOvcؚ ~ NVEl;NSO‰_&^egNevQQ0tN^V[[SO(WVESl z^-N0WMOv NGS N\\O:N *NNT^?e^~~I{^V[[SO]~b:NVElv;NSO b\/fRaIN NvVEl;NSO0 V ͑eV[;NCgt0 O~VEl[NV[;NCgASR͑Ɖ hs(WSl$Rv{Cg N ;N _ $R^S__V[v Ta 0@bN O~vVESl(WLO{Cge NV[ Ta:NMRc N:y[V[;NCgv \͑0FOяegr^VESl:gg:_6R{Cgvĉ[ [NُNt gNev0VESl:gg{CgvR:_/f[V[;NCgvNyP6R FO:_6R{CgvLO_N__/fNV[v Ta:NMRcv S NǏV[[NSl:gg{vb TvQ[Nte*NlQ~:g6Rvb/fNv0SReQgNlQ~ 1\_{blQ~@b^zSl:ggv:_6R{Cg ;NCgV[l g[N{CgvN!kNb:gO0YNVReQWTO 1\_{bWTONz㉳Q:g6Rv:_6R{CgReQ 0'k2mNCglQ~ 0_N_{ Teb'k2mNCglb[N*NN3uɋv{Cg0S_6q[N:_6R{CgvbvXR _N/f;NCgV[v?a b!nvQ;NCgv~g0ُhf(WS_N ;NCgV[egPNNcSSlQ\O:NNz㉳Qve_0 N b[NVEl nnvttu0VESl z^vЏ\O NuNimpLqv$ROlSO| ُNSO|_N~VEl nnb[NƉΑ XRNQ[ :NVEl nntvSU\ Ne&^egevRR0VESl z^-N[NVESl$RO@bnfMǑSvN[ N(de facto)vu_HQOvZPl NSWTOlNVERNlb[N$ROvevR:_v͑Ɖ fN$RO(WVEl nn-Nv0WMOev NGS \O(uev͑0 mQ S&^egVElvxGrS0VESl z^SU\HQ/f&^egNVElvY7h'` FO/f VESlvN*N͑yrp/fvQ|_dkKNvrz'` QAS*NVESl:ggKNs^L e^\sQ| dNPVElbُ{|wQ gN,{CgvlbKNY T*NbT{|Sl:ggbSO|0W(WVElv N TbNSW]\O gSNu[N TNHhNr^Sl:ggGW g{Cgv`Q _S1uNl[[NVElSRTĉRv N Tʑ [[ TNl_Qs|_dkwvTQzvʑ OVElv~N'`b4NΘi Qs@bxGrS0OY MRWSl^ Nɋ^(WvQ[TadicHhN1999t^7g12eZPQv$RQ-NNVElb(W<\RbtHh$RQ-N@bcvz:W1\ Nv T0ُ1\OVElvN'`b4NZ0FO/f Charney(W[ N\;NVESl:ggv$ROۏLN~xvzNTSs [E N(W N TSl:ggKNQs͑wvv`Qv^ N%N͑ }6q|_dkKNv N T/fX[(Wv [16](P699) NǏ 1uNُNSl:ggqQ T(uN,VEl 1\cON㉳QwvTQzvqQ T̀of0 N\lf[[ $\vQ/fVElbvl[ tN1udkSNuvVElĉR N TuwvQzvQs cQNyy㉳Qel0{:N SN\R:N*jTT~T0(W*jT N _N1\/f(WT*Nlb|_dkvsQ| N TVElb^S_T'kvlbf[`NvQ(WYtN'k2mNCglbsQ| NvZPl ;NRN㉌TxvzvQNVESl:ggv gsQ$RO vN \͑ RBlZP0R|_dkN0(W~TsQ|vg^ N gN^KNVElbNNyVEgؚlbv0WMO SNcSvQNVESl:ggv Nɋ NSNdvQNSl:ggv$RQ N OcVElv~N MQxGrSvQs FOُ(W[( NeTVv?ela?a (Wb__ NSO9e 0VElbĉ~ 0 SL'`g\0 [17] (P474)SNy^/fzNy6R^ TVlbSN1\ gsQVElvN,(u TVElbcQ{|f0VESl z^9hncvQ@b^\VESl:gg N Tv{|+R NVQlv N T z^ĉR-N8T6eN0N[v%{Q SU\N]vSO|0VESl z^[VQlv8T6e8^ N/f[gN*NV[ __/f^l8T6eTV g)RV } RN~TSU\0 Te VESlǏ[NVQlvvcwT[g[NVQlvq_T_NevX:_0 ~ VESl z^veSS /fl_hQtSۏU\vN*N͑SOs0VESl z^@bwQ gvyrp Yl_[T0:ggV[0QwQ gl_HeR0ǏSes^I{v z^ۏL[tI{ /fvQwQ gf'YvTl'`vnl0OYVESlvQsTSU\ }6q g~VEl&^egxGrSvΘi FOfY0W0N[NVElvQ[ OۏNVElveL cRNVElvY7hS0ُ_NNN*N͑vebSOsNVEllv NeSU\Tۏek0VESl z^vSU\_N[VEltT[&^egNN|Rvq_T OVElfRwQ gfveNyr_0 -NVNVESlvsQ| Nu[R S g(WQbNT @wetQVESl:ggv'Yϑms -NVNVESl:ggvsQ|MbSuN(vSS0ُ;NSOs(W(WVESl:gg-Neg-NVvl[evXY0-NV[VESl:gg{Cgv`^TygNSVESl:gg[tvmS-NVvHhN_XRI{eb0 gsQ-NVHhNvX zQ0Whs(WWTONz㉳Q:g6R-N0-NV2001t^eQNNegɋvHhN_XR $\vQ(WWTONz㉳Q:g6RteSObɋяg NMv`Q N [-NVvbɋtSevXR0Ndk Te bVck(WNSJTev0WMO;NR0W)R(uWTONz㉳Q:g6R㉳QNV'kvI{v8f~~0vQ[VESl:gg sSO/f:SW'`VESl~~ _NOmS-NVOlv)Rv 'kvlbSO|[NbVONS>PHhNv[tf/f:Npe N\0(WVElb2010t^7g22e[~v gsQy"}l[^rzvTHhNv[t-N bV?e^QwQav^Q^S >f:yNbV[NVESlveygv`^0[NVESl z^vxvz NFOwQ g͑vtN

y 2007. [5] {^:_. VElbv YtQ NbVv^[[J] lf[ 1996, (4). [6]  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/" \t "_blank" uwm\,  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/glz/" \t "_blank" ؚz_. VESl z^-Nvl^KNS6R^[J] klxvz. 2007, (3). [7] []KQ\&#8226;eY~, W[&#8226;`yr. Jacobs and White 'k2mNCgl SRN$RO,{ NHr [M] UO_O0Y[tы SNSN'Yf[QHr>y 2006. [8] []")R+Y&#8226;]eY<\W uy_0seNSI{ы. VERl[[M], SNl_QHr>y 2006. [9] 4Tga. VEwm mll^xvz [M] SNwm mQHr>y 2002. [10] []y[e, t(O. eY,gwmVEl,{]NHr ,{NwS,{NRQ[M]. s]I{ы SN-NV'Y~vyhQfNQHr>y 1995. [11] Vladmir-Djuro Degan, On the Sources if International Criminal Law[J], Chinese Journal of International Law, June,2005. [12] u~0uI{. WTOvSl:g6R[M]. Nwm NwmNlQHr>y 2004. [13] O|^ , z~f. VEl_SO|vYCQSNOSSU\ [J]. lf[Bg_. [14] Anne-Marie Slaughter, A Global Community of Courts[J]. Harvard International Law Journal, winter, 2003. [15] UO_O. VEllhQtSeNvy^g^ [J]. TglQ[ؚI{Nyf[!hf[b. 2007,(1). [16]Jonathan I. Charney, The Impact on the International Legal System of the Growth of International Court and Tribunals [J]. New York University Journal of International Law and Politics, Summer 1999. [17] Pierre-Marie Depuy, L unite de l ordre juridique international, Receuil des Cours, 2002, Tome 297 [M], Maritinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden/Boston. ,ge RN 0S_Nlf[ 02011t^,{1g ,{132-138u0  [`$] ,gev;NSOQ[ f~(W2007t^-NVVElt^O N[ _0RN['Yf[hg~gYecI{vpċ ~N\O N\/TS yrdk"0 [a$] MRWSl^R[^1998t^2g16eDelalicHh$RQ ,{20k0l_s|wmO\&#8226;4b\se l.kl[VERNl^]\Ovq_T ss,  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/zhf/" \t "_blank" uwm\ы. klxvz. 2004, (6) ,{133u0 egn: 0S_Nlf[ 02011t^,{1g VWXZ\$_`gjjk:oFoptqDrrr2ttnuu@v8wwwx(yz $dP1$a$gd hjNoPooooorr`sbshsjsnspsssssFtJt`tdtu u*|,|.|0|2|8|||} }P}R}}}}̳̳̳d̳6jEh hh hB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h hh hB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(3h hh h6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0h hh h>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh hh hB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h hh hB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph'z{*|.|2||} ~"~ $1$a$gd h $dP1$a$gd h}}} ~"~Ͷh&y-h hh hB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h hh hB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh hh hB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0182P. A!"#$%S EDd,  c :ANormalFax01C"jP src="/webcount/count.asp?newsid=40565"b!X󆡑NBD nX󆡑NBPNG  IHDRfsRGB@}0PLTE{bIDATE!0Eq^uM&VUp\ &C|)"3.8̴(6 jPtsʄ&)NU- \^w& ^eyƾ_c|_^9IENDB`Dd V  3 C"J ((N@N cke $1$a$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ ؞k=W[SOBi@B nfh*S*Y(ph"W`" hp5\7xaq On  ! / " . N] wmO^sy  Y &"6"O#m##a$H%&'H(+ ---// 00"1L1w12z222 3333]44^55666W6677I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0xaq On  ! / " . N] wmO^sy  Y &"6"O#m##a$H%&'H(+ ---// 00"1L1w12z222 3333]44^55666W6677I0%@I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0%I0@hI007 j}"~ #AC%Vz"~!$@B"~"LPU///{1111116667XXXXXXX_ftnref1_ftnref2_ftn1_ftn2 6W676Z676677]4|477]4577]f#Z2[ X?FQf#` f#(:E f#!P_pCCf#Qf#Mf#Lf#k4f#,f#Yxf#f#9Nf# f#'9f#?f#df#sf#,)f#im2f#!f#7 f#U#f#f#Z,)f#N%/f#~+1f#kS!2f#m5f#S6f#v 6f#7f#C7f#rl8f#pV8f#;f#6;f#Fpf#[>!Y>e?ZK~t?f#$?Z,SAf#P_pCf# ~Cf#Df#(Df#A$Ef#Ff#1>Gf#*%8If#|9Kf#7Lf#yNf#^Qf#yTf#.~kWf#l*Yf#WZXu~Zf#7[f#2[9Nla^f#~X`f#`f#D`f#T*&af#x8cf#Ldf#1Qef#iff#[|0jf#Q,kf#omkf#rDnf#?@ABCDFGHIJKLNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`bcdefghjklmnopsRoot Entry F@y luData E1TableM&WordDocument2SummaryInformation(aDocumentSummaryInformation8iCompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q