ࡱ> q` R bjbjqPqP2$::RRRR|^SL{St*\*\*\*\*\cTjfwyyyyyyyyyyyyy$|h&Nyh*\*\hhy*\*\{qjqjqjh*\*\wyqjhwyqjqjqj*\S PsMmRj(qjwy{0{qjt9jtqjqjtSy$h*hqj8h DhhhhyyUjhhh{hhhh44tX SltvVEXLu  |Q VErjSO| \O: HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq" \t "_blank" [eP:_ | S^e:2010-6-22 6:37:14 | pe: 453 [,gehQeSh(W 0RNlċ 0RNlf[CSSCIn R ,{26wS SN'Yf[QHr>y2010t^5gHr ,{499-532u0W Tlf[[0SN'Yf[lf[bHtQoYec(W ;Nn} -NċNS  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_v 0SltvVEXLu  |Q VErjSO| 0Ne /f[VERlxvzvNymS $\vQ/fՋV^gVErjSO| ُN}TwQ gN[vf[/g`aR 0] SltvVEXLu   |Q VErjSO|  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn1" \o "" *  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn2" \o "" ** N0ee Slt vVEXLu  SlQ^&Tt ['` ]/ff[/gN[R݋ T{Hh_N/f['`v iR NvO/f Sl^S_YUOEQRt [ϑ NSvzz`7h  Mb{ EQR el 0f[LuU"ke݋ m_݋e݋yOvll݋YwQ g9h,g'` vQ[Ype݋܏*gon R㉳Q0SlQ^S_U\:ylQ_0lQs^0f0t'`0ꁻlI{I{OoTf6qwQ gƉ:1Y'` _N/fASRWa0{N[ VERNlbɋefNhQ7h,g[xvz vMR] gpeCSN0peNu Rlf[0VElf[0VERlf[Lu v^1\ VERNl_efNvQ\Oyr_SvQNyO 0 VEl N VESl:gg I{  VE yrr*YǏf N VQl 0yr+R/f -NVl ݍyǏ܏ bU\ُyƉv^ۏLm^xvzzX[(WY'YaINُ/f{~8^mGv _N/f}Y I{_}YvVT{0ُ̑SX[(W0(WNVESl[l gVM| _Nl gl|R_^\TVQSlĉN/yYNSN㉌T(uVEl NN㉌T(uVQlNkl0N[vzz`7hbTT{HhR}YvS0VESl[Y/fVESl:gg ~V c v v^Ng~ NwQ g l|0LǸofT'`+RvGWa'` 0bcKN VESl[ N/fQzzNuv /fV[l| v|Nh0Ydk N/yYN NSSNVElvS Ype`Q N N/yYNHQ/fVQlTklvN[T|0SaVE?elNYN0uSaN,VElv lv b Qlv VESl[ SS N gǏ FOُe] VEll T VERNll  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn4" \o "" [2]veN[R@bmpl0ُyVESl[_N NS(WVESlS NYu N*Ya7hv $RO WN  :NNHNُ7hbTSVASR{USl_ }{QNbv$p;NP͑VQlTklĉ VElfYv/f\O:NNyyr[ l_wƋ X[(W VE?elNYNm{QNVESlꁻlSR N/fk NvsQ01\/f'} _[z0 tEQR vVESlefNyr+R/f(WRN0lFU0NCgI{W dN VEl vvsQĉNlt YeINʑYRR/vv fYvQ[/fU\:y t V gvVQlTklo~RRN,Cg͑(W50%N N gؚvSN0R80%N N 0ckYdk {MbZW[0W:NVESl;N1\/fVESl[vVQlNklRR(WVESlS N@bۏLvl| t yrbvVEzX[mplb _lb 0ُ/fNLuHQۏl|Sl|NvVE bQ'Y[ YUOO` EQRt l|cv^AmCSS ck/fVESl[N(W gP0ؚ0rzNgQv~[QR0[ُy~k|zQ NuvSlUxgۏLw[ wvNVQSlۏSNf[/gb sQ| N'Y T { NN:N6q0c[ SltvVEXLu ASR_ ASR͑0{xvzeT@bPُ_N/fmSxvz@b_{v ,geeR\ VESlefN vhQof_ tXLu NQSb=\0VERNlb/fNLu N/UN8^vRNlb vQVEl;NSO0WMO!kNTT s^ws^PW 01998t^z02002t^uHeNeg ]~ЏLYt^ [t'`N$ROlRcяbq N

f6qwQ g8^ĉ'`T~xQ'`0vMRlbqQ gV*Nrj`Rl;NRg0LNr^0-N^qQTV0ς9N\[\ 08*NHhNh[[ɋbSsR h[[ɋaSfWRT] h[[ɋ~uh[[ɋ<\0eY0KQ~N0eY_wmYZSTfeh[[ɋ!ZSh[[ɋT&OT^_ h[[ɋ] \ h[[ɋ?^R mHhur/JT14N {kN1NKQ~N LNr^?e^QQk 0RHh5NbSsR0aSfWR0]0!ZS0R (W8NO[dY ?e^[XT3NT&O0^_0] \ NNPNς9N\[\`R00RHh5N-N l;NRg`R3NbSsR0aSfWR0] 1N(W -N^qQTV`R1N!ZS ς9N\[\`R1NR 3N(W LNr^`ReN0RHh4N(W 00RHh5N-N 3N|VQ.UclVE.UcbSsR0aSfWR0] 1N|VE.Uc!ZS 1uk)Re?e^.Uc 1N?a0RHhR 00RHh5N-N QNN/fSSfkň /U g!ZS|S_e-N^;`~^TXv WY.^Q FOrjSvQNe/fl;NRg0WeSSfkň0 lb`R NY0HhN NY00RHhur NY FO/fVESl w͑ hbckIN  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn5" \o "" [3]l[QN_N Q ݋ ɋ_8^A~Q efNimYpwm0yr+R/fNeNr0RHh l^zsSweQNlmo ~8^/feq\Owm0Y4Yv^ۏ ɋ/ey4xx0NteT R^_N NeN}T rNl[ uN^[0N,{NHh:NO IQ/f ck__^[$R ,g1\SeJSt^uNt^ 1\ޏ;N[l[]1\elw ~~e ^[{U_vNpeN^N`a0ُ1\/fVESl:NN hblQs^  Hes _{ek0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn6" \o "" [4]bSfߏegvckIN_N/fckIN eegv^ckIN NS[_0Ydk SlefNKNA~YNQ _N1\S` w0 ߏegvckIN_N/fckIN [N [MRb T [-Nb S/f OY  RNll KNejc[vW,g z^SR _N/f VERNll KNejc[vW,g z^SR >f_aINyr+R͑'Y0 [MRb T [-Nb vS_N QRZ (WbV/f SR ^ OY Yg ckINeg_*Yߏ yr+R/f ejʑ>e O&^eg~p'`Tg0Vdk 1\-NVvyrk틃X  ߏegvckIN_N/fckIN 1\^\N kw0^NS YeIN0ُ/f v`'`_s V:N kw0^NSYeIN KN['`v;MRcck/fe^cS{_^㉄gv [MRbT[-Nb KN@b SR 0 X[(WsSTt N/fNHNes?Qa?Q bN[dkY~ؚ^f`b X[(W Ɖ:N NSdRv V` T9ei MRc ۏ ~ga0mS0_SuceHQۏt_N~xQSR _N\ gQCSt^vSS01\dk  ߏegvckIN_N/fckIN ck/f [MRbT[-Nb KN@b SR vf[tKN  llV[vRNɋ:NUOSNePA~tTQ1\/fV:NNrYl gcMR wVW @bNNr I{_w   bNScS ckIN NI{YENbN NcS ^ckIN Neg_Y_0 NSlǏ zvg~~gYUO bN`7hMbe[g~Ώcv/f ckIN N/f ^ckIN bTُ1\/fSl_{ EQRt v9h,gSV0Sl NFO(Wg~Q-N EQRt NbSlǏ zhQ001udkS  Sl Nt b Sl NEQRt mB\SV؏/f gjc[ ~gSV/f Nl t_0 {][ VERNl_efNvQ\Oyr_SvQNN{Nf͑ T{Hh(WvQ-N0HN NN{|Nv _b gmQ~hvQvU_ l^vgTQNy HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn8" \o "" [6]l gReQ vU_ :NGY*`0N,:N wQSOQNy~ /fQvupB _N/fTeS_NNTSNN%`NǏvvk= Vdk(W vU_ -N,g^Nve_RQ0b gNV^{Q~(WefNgT N(uRQ{f~b0R0{ NN:N6q SV/fVERNlbv'YϑQ OY[R^0[$RR^0 NɋR^v -N Nɋ QI{ ;`~v^D8h_a ~8^/fQs(WefN_{ wQSOQNyYg g =(WgT0Vdk Q~v^^(WefNgT v^^N_SN {f~b0R 0Ydk͑vQtSS~vU_ kĉ[vfhQ& & & & & & & & & & & & .11 N l^Ǒ(uvnc$Reel& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .12 10]b2ncvvsQ'`TfR& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..15 20]b2ncvSǑ'`& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..16 30]b2vvcTcnc$Reel& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..17 40vQNncNy& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..19 50[]b2ncvHhRgel& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 21 60l^v1uϑCgSvQP6R& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..22  N e[ceeEQnccQvb___& & & & & & & & & & .22 N0h[[ccvrj& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .25 N qS[N{|j& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .25 10qS[N{|jv틃X }& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..25 1 l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..25 a.X[(W ;eQNUOs^lNS NN& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .26 b.X[(W ^lb g|~v;eQ & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .28 c.\Ov`vL:NN ;eQNUOs^lNS X[(W_T|& & & & & & & & .29 d. fwُy;eQ [eqS[N{|j& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .29 2 l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 30 a. MLC(W2002t^10g26e2003t^3g15eKN[eN [l;NRgs^lNSv;eQ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .30 b.ُy ;eQ /f ^lv & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .40 c. MLC fw ُy;eQ|[l;NRgs^lNSv& & & & & & & .45 20gbqS[N{|jvyr[ }& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 45 a. @gvyr[ },{7ycc & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .45 a l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..46 b l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..49 b.\O:NqS[N{|jv:_xYL:Nvyr[ },{1ycc & & & & & & & .56 a l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..57 b l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..58 c.\O:NqS[N{|jvwRL:Nvyr[ },{3ycc & & & & & & & .67 a l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..67 b l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..69 N bNj& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .75 10bNjv틃X }& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..75 1 l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 75 a.X[(W^VE'`fkňQz& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .75 b.aƋ0RX[(WfkňQz& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .82 2 l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..83 a.X[(W^VE'`fkňQz& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .83 b.\Ov`aƋ0RX[(W^VE'`fkňQz& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .91 20gbbNjvyr[ }& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..92 a.\O:NbNjv @gvyr[ },{6ycc & & & & & & & & & & & .93 a l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..94 b l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..95 b.\O:NbNjv:_xYL:Nvyr[ },{2ycc & & & & & & & & & .96 a l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 96 b l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 97 c.\O:NbNjvwRL:Nvyr[ },{4ycc & & & & & & & & & .98 a l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 99 b l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .100 d.\O:NbNjv_c[*NN \%Nvyr[ },{5ycc & & & & & & ..101 a l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .101 b l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .102 e. \O:NbNjvmRvyr[ },{8ycc & & & & & & & & & & .105 a l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .105 b l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .107 mQ0*NNRN#N& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..114 N 0ĉ~ 0,{25ag,{3>k,{1y& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..115 10l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .116 1 0ĉ~ 0,{30agĉ[v\Ov`vEeaTfwi_& & & & & & & & .118 2 qQ Tckr[[e\O[[brjir(NvqQ TRv fwTcS& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..126 3 ur[YOvQNvQNqQ TckrOSRc6RrjKN[E`Qvfw& .126 20l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .127 1 MLC(W2002t^r^m-N^qQTVKNMR(W2001t^ۏ{-N^qQTV T(W2002t^{Nbl;NRglY]l vegL:N& & & & & & & & & .129 2 (W2002t^r^m-N^qQTVgb gTRMmRf& & & & ..132 3 (W!ZSHQuN2002t^>mcۏ{-N^qQTVeMLC nN hQCgNtv[sX & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 133 4 MLCc%c[2002t^(W荊eYR_Lul ۏeQ-N^qQTVevo& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..134 5 MLCXuQ(W20022003t^r^m-N^qQTVg [[Nv􋞏& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..135 6 !ZSHQuN^TXHQuvvcT8^ĉT~& & & & & & & & & .137 7 (WǏ N T nS]~wSv^brj[ev`Q N N6q~~[eqQ TR& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..138 N 0ĉ~ 0,{28ag& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..139 10l_SvQʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .140 1 ur_{/fQNc%c[b0WMOvS_& & & & & & & & & & & & & .142 2 ur_{ gHec%cTc6RQ^\ b gHe{Tc6R N& 143 3 rjvSu/fV:Nur*gYUc6RQ N & & & & & & & .148 4 urwSbt^wS& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .151 5 ur*gǑSNR_TTtce 2bk06Rbkrj bb;N{S_@\1\dkNۏLgTwɋ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..155 a.2bkINR& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..156 b.6RbkINR& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..156 c.b;N{S_@\1\dkNۏLgTwɋINR& & & & & & & & & & & & ..158 d._TTtce& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..158 20l^vz:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .159 a.!ZSHQu\O:NQNc%c[ gHeLNv^[rjۏL gHe{Tc6R& 160 a !ZSHQu(WMLC~g-Nv[e0WMO& & & & & & & & & & & & .161 b !ZSHQu gCg N_{ gNv}TN& & & & & & & & & & & & & & .164 c !ZSHQu gCgN}T0cGS0MNO0d0.Uc0bYu0ʑ>ec%c[.165 d !ZSHQu gCg2bk06Rbkrjv[e& & & & & & & & & & & & & .166 e !ZSHQu(W20022003t^r^m-N^qQTVg [MLCb g gHe{Tc6RCgR& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..167 b.!ZSHQuwSMLCck(Wb\[erj& & & & & & & & & & & ..172 c.!ZSHQul g(WvQLCgVQǑSNR_Ttce 2bkb6RbkMLC[erj& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..178 sQN vU_ B\~ O@bhTw lf[xvzuf[MOe0*NNNWbvQNf[/gev vU_ N,S N~h0\O:N%N(vSlefN ,gQ vU_ h0RmQ~ NN`0k~vU_hKNT gwQSOuxh:y efNQtSO)R0sQN vU_ Ny Qbur6qrQ0 z^SS0{CgNSSt'`0fhQ+TncR{|0$RehQNel 0ccrj+TN,ltNl^[ 0*NN#N+TN,ltNl^[ I{NQSb=\0N N1\/f ,{NpSa [0~0[te0 N Q\Oĉ{|f6qf_!rx0JS*NN~Neg f[/g_ĉe[U [vl]bO0Sl_bck/ff[/g_ĉc~[UvQ(WBl0l g[_ve NS/f%Nv f[/g \OT l g[_vSlefNee Nt gN 0 KNQQ v_h0SlctǏ z;N/f[lN[nc0$ROI{ Nlĉv_^co }6qyOyf[Wv [r[_ bN[fmBgN [􁨋;`/f݋0 NNNKN0ُ,g1\/fg'Yv N%N(0 Yg[ ['` S_ygbg c Neg1\/f[ [ϑ v01uNbN[MR\e[ VdkYg~~[TۏL[ eN  sQN _le_ lĉl gfnxBl W,gu_Lvf[/gĉ0vMRLv/f l_ ُOMQS >\l_ v8h[p|`0evlx/fUS~v?b/OpeW[0ޏ~S -NevSNQWY NWWv^ c kurzS cR N RTV` 0kĉ[@b geN^O(uA4kO!kĉ[N N{| S(uvl_ N/f,gb8h_lĉ0VElSRTĉR0NLuN,l_SR N/f,gb$ROlSRTĉR N/fVEbvNCgQR0 N{| l_ S gzl!k^ Nv]_ v^e(u6MOv%Ne_ۏLTlv{'Y_N/fQ\ONvCg)R0VERN_^N/fNLuv~'Y^ [f{'Y Tg N*X`0@bN (WVESl-N eN{E^P6RvS_͑0N, l gl^yr+RcCg}TN vsQeNSvQV Y NǏl[P6R0YgN[z4xl[P6R _{NHQTl^3uv^S_S =\{HQeTOYvNOe gSu0&TR NNV:N{E^ 1\NO]=eQɋ4\,\X0W0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn12" \o "" [10] 0lbagO 0zN N*N{E^P6RI{~0 NǏ100uveN g6y,{38ag,{1>k 1 h[[fNb3u[R^cCg(W gsQ~VXQǑSgNce NS~V[[R^vV Ya2 h[[9hnc 0ĉ~ 0,{18ag,{2>kcQcCgg3u8hgVQ@b v^L ɋ 3 SSt'`Tlb[$RCg(u4 ~VT[tOBl[R^ Yh[[ NwɋQ[5 h[[Bl[R^cCgۏLck8^g6 [NBlTPvH0 NǏ50uveN_N g6*N,{38ag,{2>k 1 [N1\h[[3u[R^cCgg\OQH2 h[[Bl[{CgbSSt'`ۏLQ3 h[[3u[R^cCgOhQnc4 h[[ gsQryrg:gOv3u5 SNNT[R^cQǑSwQSOce0S^}TNTcCgfN0[BlV[T\OI{6 .UcNb[jNvTPBl0d N$Ny`QY vQNeN N_Ǐ20u0G gyrk`Q>e[upeP6R _{S_l^ybQ0,{37ag dkY ,{36ag,{1>k؏ĉ[ {upeP6Re h0lT_(u^{(WQ 0vQ-N lT_(u{(WQ O_A~t_leYυ0,{4>kĉ[ s^GWku N_Ǐ300W[ ُ1\O_[Ɩ'`0\W[SLee:gSXN0,{2>k؏>e[N{Bl +T gW[_(u 0ĉ~ 00 0ĉR 0b,gagOvNUODN NS +T gSgqDe0l_Onc0{U_0irTvQNvsQ^NPgevNUODU_0DU_ N_+T gaH N^{(WQ0,{3>k[ "}_ ZPQNyr+Rĉ[SNN^SecNNN"}_ OfN[ybQ "}_^S_SbvsQvNTQcNSDU_vb^0Yg g_ SNNSBlR^1\DU_vQ[\OQQ0fN[ybQ"}_b(WR^[NT^S_zsSHTNDU_0 N0 VERNSl$RefN~xQ7h,gVRg    EQRt v[(pSa N `7hN~Nr   EQRt vt_NN'`W@x Q_{NN(uNNk0 N0RNLe HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn13" \o "" [11]N~N,gHhNr6qrQ mSNrvY T0VM|0QueTQu0W06rNNMvPY T0sLN0l[N {-vW^t.s].!ZSHQu y|TNr l gO(u Nr 0 ur I{/g HQu _N/fev \y vS_NIl-Nv T_ bvQNNHN ;`KN N+T gNUO,a0ُ̑_Nl gNUO MRy b NoTL N~ =\{勺N MRy vnx_Y_͑  TL _N N NOo0Ydky(WlbhQSleN-NNN/KN0l gOY0(WU_[vlbhQ萭^{U_-N bN_NN*gSsvQNS4Yy0VENrN,CN jv`KN$\ NFO dN{|ow v^NbUc Nf f gepe[Nw@w@~vSNb0zHh0g0.Uc0wɋ0[$R0 Nɋ0gbLI{I{/fɋ_~s k*N6k؏ gOYSl;mRNN0Q{USv z^THhN_NOubASNbpeASNN Nl_/SlefN Sl[ gINRSe0hQbubefNv^tetbwS0vQ!k1\/fBlSl[[te0Se0WlQ_0l_/SlefN0HN Nub HN NlQ_ HN N S_NNNSNNYUOwSfT_YgYpeeNv^*gOlubb^\NUSe y[ Sl[SYUOYۏL$R'`_  lQs^ /fVESlv8h_N

k 1uN$NJT@b(W0W0T Te\L0WI{(W TN^:S SJT ~JTɋ ^-NbV:Slb tS N~lbS4Yb~ S}Yɋ:Slb0UOe_^0UOe܀ɋ0UOegbLwɋKNe1\bN`Hh0 {__N}Y 3uV_N}Y /f[lb0l[,gv1YO0Yg(u Nw[_0 EQRt 0b` YO_ 1\ j gl b ꁨRe\L vsQ.aIN vQNQNySvQ t /f&T؏ g[EaINb~~N_T { b V N 1\S_NNv NɋCg b 3uɋCg _N/fNy%N͑vSl bag   N~Sl:gg gCg~~EQRNُ{|ɋ`NOhQb[0 V  Sb[S1\/fSbnc    fhQ _N/fl[vO}T  fhQ evidentiary threshold }6qOe/f z^݋ FO/fۏeQN EQRt v[(6k0 Nzl Nv fhQ YHNR,T NUOl_,g NSb hQ 0N,   ;N/ff[vO}T Yg؏/fl[vO}T \ N/fl[ /}{k  VESl[vVT{/fmg'`v fhQ _N/fl[vO}T0Q(urzv ,{VR 915u057k  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn16" \o "" [14][ fhQ 0 fSR 0 $Reel I{ۏLN{'Y0 EQRt /UP`S_NN Nf}vl[[ncvt'`jR`0 QcQɋ6k N T l[fhQT_0N N 0.UcN 00RnxwɋQ0R~[$RQ ɋMRۏ fhQؚ0,g6knxwɋ vfhQ/f /f&T gEQncf g[(t1uvO勺N[eN@bccvrj 0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn17" \o "" [15]ُ̑QsN EQ sufficient T [( substantial $N*Nb_[͋ R_on l[vp_N1\KN eg0l[ۏ 9hnc 0[r%m͋xQ 0  [( 1\/f ͑ 0 ZWV 0 ir( 0 Sb o}Y 0 wv KNa N/f Zg0`a imaginary (u[N^v݋ 1\/f h[[_{cOwQSOvT gb_vf hfvQyr[;N _vct`npfe 9hncl_ĉ[ l[\OQnxb NnxQl[:Ndk_{ZWc X[ue g)RNJTSR in dubio pro reo, ejc[ vl_ nn 0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn18" \o "" [16](Wdk :NN EQRt 0on fhQ l[Ǒ(uN͋nf[0$ROl0ĉʑTl_{Vyel ُN_~vf[/gelQNNl gNUO]_0  fhQ nZiN ؏DKNN fSR evidentiary principles l[ۏ cQ9hnc 0Wlĉ~ 0Tag0,gb$ROTVElQvNCghQ ,g^\9hnc NR fSR e]b2nc0,{N vsQ'`relevance NfRfN

NQNeg]wT?S TNbNHXdvvQ͋eye-witness testimoniesvcnc 0vcnccO,{NKbOo` q_Tl^O(u~Ǐw[g YgvcncOYvQNvfNbH evsQSS` NegUOeS_NN NOl^KNvQؚfRl^SOOlO`ُyUSNvvcncZPQQe0[6kSNO(u?S T͋T͋Xd FO/ffRNO V:N[eR:YNe(:gO0cncvfRvcnc:NNO ُ/fNyW,gSR0l^}6q Nb~cnc$ROlR FO/fR_(NaO(ul^ N;NOnccncZPQQ0l^:SRvcNcnc N g_[$Recncvel0l^Ǒ~ $Nekpl two-step approach ,{Nek/fċ0OcncvvsQ'`0fRTSǑ'` V:N[SNvcnc gsQ,{Nek/f$RevQ/f&TX[(W |T^'`nc corroborating evidence NQvQb__begn0l^Vdk1\nx~TvQNnc gsQnc/f&TOteSO N_ؚfR0l^Џ(uُyel1\SNnxOcnc-NvOo`SN_0RvQNfRbؚbNOvncPO0=\{,gb 0ĉR 0 NAQn |T^'` vl[Bl'`fRrj$\vQYdk FO/f,g^:N`bNy;N _ NNO`NyfRNOvcncv^ NSL0Vdk =\{[NyccvhQnc:ONvc'`0N gcnc/ed vQfR_NNn fhQ 0l[ZPQQ0,{V vQNnc0ncv NN'`inconsistencies NO[l[[ncvꁨRb~ _N NOYxl[[[vO(ul[:NNLu[vQfR Oċ0Oُy NN'`/f&TO[ncvte*NSO^TS`'`Nuu0l^O[gkNncvQ(WOS'`intrinsic coherence kNncSOfY*N NN'`SSNyr[ gsQ Nfdk tSSNf|_ Vdk NOYxl^O(u0l^ NOꁨRb~;N/fWN?elbvQNR:g egvN\O /f[vQ1\[_k*N_[vS`'`v^~Tte*NncZPQċ0O0,{N  HhRgl case-by-case approach 0l^:NkNnc^\'`k_ N Tcc0gb }0HhNN[SvQ N TsQ|yr'`T_ VdkMb VHh6R[ 0,{mQ l^v1uϑCgSvQP6R0l^cQl^N g^lv1uϑCg1uċ0Onc FOv^^SNfkebeP6RLN l[vvsQ'`0fRNSǑ'`Bl1\/f NS>v`l0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn19" \o "" [17] l^gT؏[evsQ_ZPNV^e#*`ceO(u SbFO NPN (u틂ibcc0OreCg)R l^:N Nbz V:N,g6kSBlcecO EQ N/f hQ nc0e؏c#ceLu[rje:S荦^Ǐ'Y0|u mqN l^:NcewQSOcc g|nxe0I{I{0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn20" \o "" [18] ‰Q Ne N fhQ 0 fSR 0 $Reel I{gwb:N*NHhwQSOcc Rgvc[SR0(WbN weg ُy t f_YHN͑06q ~‰ NeMbwُNN/fQq\N҉0 N YUOۏL[SO'` t    rjSO| vVESck tete24u070kǏS  Rɋlf[ ǏN>v Q~NۏeQ[SO t 6k0 Rlf[ v'Yb_^U^& & V0 VErjSO| e    rjSO| vVESck N  VErjSO| ݋NeƉ  VErjSO|   N*NASRNvee0,geR6RُN/g v^^_`)Y_ f NO)YlLzz0bU\ rjSO| eƉ R6R VErjSO| /f{c~[ SltvVEXLu -Nv͑'YSs0nxrjKN@bN SO|'``~ HN/fQN ; Q HN/fQN ~Nm Q vQ[g͑v 1\/fQN Ne_RrR0wƋ̀ofNf[yR]Q[ VElf[ NSmeQc VErjSO|  u[hQ Nav+TIN06q 1uN rjSO| f~Nv^S[)RvQRrR0yr+R/fYUO RTV`  -NVRlf[_N*g1\ VErjSO| U\_  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn21" \o "" [19]u:NWa0vQ N VERlCN~Tl z^0[SO0~~0NN0gbL  [SO S N/fg'}도v {N gNu󁤋:N j TLuR ^\aIN gP0ُ/fVERlTVERlf[v`T {~ N T0 1\ NsrN xvz VErjSO| y N_VQlNklbgTsrv gRc[bcKN VElf[TVERlf[,gN[bُyx06q ,geaQ!kwSeQ rjSO| vVQlNklll /fNNPtvQ-Nv Ƌ  Nl| rjSO| v'Yyr_ @wRx 0Wlĉ~ 0lĉSvQ$ROlRv^Ss ĉR b0ُ/f,gvyrkO}TT!.s0 b gNb_xvz7h,g/f&TǏNrz N ~ YUO  nf'` `7hvQ[ُ/fYQ0HQ 0Wlĉ~ 0/fďN:Nbk1\VERl[SOĉ[_g[0gZfя0g8^ĉvlĉ _NgwQ g~b'`TRe'`0~v 0rjN 0fwQ g~xQ'`0vQ!k YMRe,{N @b  VESl;N1\/fVESl[vVQlNklRR(WVESlS N@bۏLvl| t yrbvVEzX[mplb _lb  0VERNlbvl[t f:N%Nk,{1y HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn22" \o "" [20]T,{28ag,{2>k HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn23" \o "" [21]ĉ[cwvqS[N{|jNbNjccnx9hnc,{28ag,{1>k HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn24" \o "" [22]ĉ[cwvqS[N{|j @g0:_xY NbNj @g0:_xY0mR cc b~nx9hnc,{28ag,{1>kĉ[cwvqS[N{|jwR NbNjwR0_c[*NN \%N cc\!ZSOgqnxvccN[$RI{I{0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn25" \o "" [23],gHhNdk~_g [ 0ۏeQ [$R 0VERNɋǏNSsQ.i l^Nl[sS 'Ybc@ 0,gHhQ NX[(Wl[ rza separate opinion N,/f ^ T~0hQbRS[ctǏ z f NX[(W\pel[ S[a dissents ;N/fS[~0_NS[ctǏ z YgX[(W$N Nv^NYpeaޏSOlQ_0,gHhl[NvctǏ zN~wQ gN'`0VErj }X[(WV gv YBg'`N YT'` Ygl g SO|'``~ _ۏL }teTNnx0HN [l^vl[Nvzz/f`7h |~0W cRɋMRۏvbTl^[rjgb }vRgSO|vzz/f`7hvbT 10 sQN {|j T v SO|'``~ sQN {|j T Neeu gNN _N1\/f 0Wlĉ~ 0vV'Yj T _NSNy:NƖT'`j T vS_NbVv {|j T _N1\/flvv Tbяf6qR+RۏLrzRg wQSORg`Y Nj TNqS[N{|j010틃X }contextual elements 1 X[(W [NUOs^lv;eQ 2 X[(W ^lb|~'`;eQ 3 \Ov`vL:NN [NUOs^lv;eQ KNvsQ|nexus 20yr[ }specific elements 1 @g2 :_xY3 wR0j TNbNj10틃X }contextual elements 1 X[(W^VE'`fkňQz2 [X[(WfkňQzvfwawareness 20yr[ }specific elements 1 @g2 :_xY3 wR4 _c[*NN \%N0l[[ *NNRN#N vRgrzۏL '} h[[ccvrj KNT#NN,{25ag,{3>k,{1yqQ Tckr#N 01 ,{30agĉ[vEeaTfwi_2 qQ Tckr[[eqQ TR\[[brjvir(NvfwTcS3 ur[OvQNvQN TOc6Rrj[E`Qvfw0#NN,{28agc%c[b N~#N 0ur1 _{/fQNc%c[b0WMOvS_2 _{ gHec%cTc6RQ^\ b gHe{Tc6R N3 rjvSu/fV:Nur*gYUc6RQ N 4 urwSbt^wS5 ur*gǑSNR_TTtce 2bk06Rbkrjbb;N{S_@\1\dkNۏLgTwɋ0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn26" \o "" [24] bNN-N NSsl[Rg`v SO| yr_vQN  j T HQL0 #N kT0 j T /frj'`(  #Nb__  /f rjb_` 0 rjb_` (WVERl-N~y SN!j_ participating model 0Vdkُ̑@b *NNRN#N -Nv #N N/f'YFl| rjSO| -Nv g#'` 0qQ T ckrNqQr (W 0Wlĉ~ 0-N^\N TN{| rjb_` b SN!j_ l_N[R؏\ONf:NwQSOvR{|0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn27" \o "" [25] c%c[b N~#N R^\NSN{|rzv rjb_` b SN!j_ R_#SRNgb }NMR:S+R_'Y0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn28" \o "" [26](W[l[ weg  #Nb__ d _N^\N ['` f\Pɋ0Owɋ0͑e,T0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn29" \o "" [27],gQg~&T[N #NN nxN #NN Stck(WNdk0 j T N #Nb__ ^\N N TB\!k ُ̑tS gRg^MOHQTKNR0+TvSt'Yi/fYg j T ,g Nbz c #Nb__ v^eaIN0ُyct`>f6qf+TNy;ۏsQ|06q  {|j T N #Nb__ ,gS+T;N[‰ } VdkdkY؏ N_Q HQ[‰0T;N‰ v~0vQN  틃X } HQL0 yr[ } kT0gb$NjOlyr[vT N Tv rj틃X 0 rj틃X vS_N [‰YZagN  T7h/f @g :1Y Nl[ rj틃X SSgbvQNrjmpy0OeuunfRNrj wQY N N Tvl[ rj틃X TNL:NOY @g s^l Sbz N TvrjqS[N{|jbbNj 0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn30" \o "" [28] yr[ } [E/fc wQSOj T [R-N1\/fc wQSOcc 0l gN[e wQSOrj  {|j T 1\ NSbzbz {|j T  wQSOrj =\{؏ rj틃X /ed rj틃X N yr[ }  wQSOj T qQ T/ed {|j T 0 틃X } v^\'`YUO/f;N‰v؏/f[‰vl_l gĉ[ SǏ[R‰[ ~/f [‰v 0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn31" \o "" [29] yr[ } v^\'`SYUO1\ {|j T >f6q^\N wQSOv[‰L:N 1\vQ,gv wQSOgb [‰0;N‰ }_{wQY0 틃X } /f[‰v  yr[ } RS+T[‰0;N‰ }0Vdk dkY N T7h_Q HQ[‰0T;N‰ v~ S/f HQ[‰ vz:WR2z*P06q N$Njv 틃X } U\sNVErjgb }vzQyr_(Wl[jr-N  틃X } B_{HQL0Ydk  HQ[‰ vZPle^/fV^NVErjNzlyr_ v^e*YYv SO| ckNf_QŖ0_ SOrjL:N }/fir(material b[‰objective } rjaV }/f|^y/_tmental b;N‰subjective } /fbzrjfor a crime to be committed @b_v$N*NsQ.essential T*b6q N T/rz/npfdistinct v }0ǏRg l^v[g~/f['`v0sQN rjL:N l^:N 0ĉ~ 0l gLu[ @g[IN 0rjN 0cON gPc[ @g1\/fL:NN\Ov` perpetrator @g[killed l[ʑ:NN {k N͋(u NNbYN09hnc,gb$ROl bz @gBl[N_{{kN0{kN_{eg @gL:N0 @gL:NSN/f\O:Nb N\O:N0[Nv{kNYN[E`b_-Nc[Qeg h[[_{f @gL:NN[N{kNKNvVgsQ|the causal link  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn34" \o "" [32]0:NNfL:NN@g[yr[*NN h[[ gINRcOcc~particulars FO/f N_~b0RSbf8\SO S=\S|nx0Wnx[ @g0Wp0S`egTL:Ne_ NSNNv`b_TL:NNNrjvT|link 09hnc[6kvfhQ [(t1u hQ  substantial grounds threshold NS'Yĉ!jrjmass crime HhNv[E ZWc ؚnx['`hQ high degree of specificity NR[E0:Ndk h[[ N_[ky@g[f[NTvcL:NNvN0_N N_wS[NvnxRpeϑ0ckYdk l^MbOQ Y many b pe~vN/!k l gfyr[peϑ v@g[nc0sQN rj_` l^:N 0ĉ~ 0,{30agvĉ[S+T$Ny ra dolus _N1\/f ,{Ny z^vvcra dolus directus in the first degree T ,{Ny z^vvcra dolus directus in the second degree 0ُyBl(uNqS[N{|jTbNjvNRyr[L:N0 d^S gĉ[ ُ/fNyNRl[rjvR_TSRa default rule 0_N1\/f d^ 0ĉ~ 0b 0rjN 0Bl(u N TvjǏhQa different standard of fault _{nxz gsQrjvir( }/f(W EeaTfw with  intent and knowledge vra/eM N[ev0ُ_N/f 0rjNN,c[SR 0,{2>kvĉ[ ,{3>k؏ĉ[ EeaTfwSNN gsQN[T`ce 0:Ndk l^_{nxOL:NNaVN{kNmeant to cause death baƋ0Rwas aware N`vN,SU\O[~g01\,gHhqS[N{|j-Nv @g SNN[^fkňNXTO(ufkRc[QEea0sQN sQ| l^:Nh[[_{f(W @gN;eQL:NKNX[(WsQ|nexus _N1\/ffMLC[ev @gL:N/f^lb|~0W;eQRgs^lv~bR0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn35" \o "" [33]l^T~~Rg qS[N{|j v :_xY cc `~SO|l g9eS0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn36" \o "" [34]HN [ bNj  N Trj -Nv @g vRgSO|O gNHN N TT~/f&T[v dkY NX0 30 sQN *NNRN#N v SO|'``~ sQN *NNRN#N l^vRg`Y Nl^(W 0\PbkɋQ 0-NcQh[[v['`k,{1y bgbc%c[b N~#N,{28ag 0Vdk /U gMR Nbze l^Mb{~~[gT0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn37" \o "" [35]   sQN qQ Tckr#N 0ُ,g/fh[[,{N!kccv #Nb__ Tl^:NS ['` g v^ f\P,T 0h[[vQ!kccOYuNُycc TeXRN c%c[T N~#N cc y NBl SOi 0l[dk!kvg~[g~/fXRveccbz OYuvcc؏/f Nbz0Ogq8^t 1uNh[[R N,TR; f\P,T Q20u St]~__nZi 0$N!kr l[SN[hQ NQtOcc bgY/f{SYtTvc sV 6qTvTYbzvecc0FO/fl[>f6ql gُ7hZP0sVS_NNh[[e/f Sl'Y 0f/fS_NN ͑ɋBl VEl[ NS N EQRt Ndk Te l[nxzN qQ Tckr ;N‰R_#vN,`~SO| v^[,gHh9'YۏLN_8^~0{_vRg0:NN NpbqN SO| N N NbbRċ0 l^cQh[[PR rjc6RRSt control over the crime SvQqQ TckrtcQ:NNOkS^TX $NNb[qQ TR g~[rjur(WMLC-Nv0WMONS[[eqQ TRv8h_aINQ[ Nc6RN9hnc勡R@b[evrj0ur_N&{Tl[v rj_` BlN EeaSNLR 0 aƋ0R N TOqQ T[eN,O[rjvqQ TR cS[eqQ TRvΘi0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn38" \o "" [36]FO/fl^ NN:N6q2009t^4g24e ec#eEQccv N|nx'`SvQ:w vQ-N1\SburvSNb__form of participation _N1\/f\O:NqQ Tckrco-perpetrator vzz/fcckrindirect perpetrator ؏/fvcckrdirect perpetrator068     βββΆgMg1gM6h#h#5>*B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph3h#h#5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph<jh#h#5B*CJKHOJQJU\^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph)h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^Jph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h#h#5B* CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph30 h z& ()h***/0<5556Z66$dP1$a$gd# $dP1$a$gd# $1$a$gd# $dP1$a$gd#  T V \ ` ^ ` b d h DFDFLN.!0!."0"6"8"ββββ}β}eββ}ββ}ββ}/h#h#5B*CJKHOJQJ\^Jph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6h#h#5>*B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h#h#5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph'8"##$$$$--....&0(0&1(1.101334444UVWWW W[[\ \&\(\vbbbb\p^p^q`qhqjq,wRwTwnw̳̳̳̳̳̳̳/h#h#5B*CJKHOJQJ\^Jph3h#h#6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph26667778\88869~99:\::::;;;<^<<<>===>f>> $dP1$a$gd#>>D??? @h@@@FAAA$BnBBCLCCC&DnDDENEEE.FxFF $dP1$a$gd#FGXGGG(HrHHIRIII(J^JJJ0KzKKKDLLL"MlMMM6NN $dP1$a$gd#NNOfOOOFPPP$Q\QQQ*RvR.TPT4U\8]_Ze|l,wTwpww $dP1$a$gd# $dP1$a$gd#nwwwxxxx||}}}}BDDFNP^~npprz|z||~̳̳̳̳̳̳̳̳3h#h#6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3w8{p||N~Ȁ„.&̌ڍƏ2~b0PzXԭ $dP1$a$gd# $dP1$a$gd#.0N\^^`hjrttv~ֻػؼڼ prrt|~ дддддддддддддддддддд0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph/h#h#5B*CJKHOJQJ\^Jph=ԭ.зĸV >V$DHvvvvy{ $dP1$a$gd#\^^`hj.002:<&((*242x VXXZbd "VXXZbd˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴3h#h#6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph< 01uNh[[]~9hncrjc6RRStcQqQ Tckrv|nx;N _ evc#B N͑ l^S[gُySN!j_mode of participation v9hnc0sQNqQ Tckrvi_ bSsRHhNf gQ O TNN[e  _{N c6Rrj vi_~Tt0,g^l gt1uOPy[R^vctelN`0qQ TckrbO T[ejoint commission vi__{NTTc6Rrjjoint control over the crime :N9hnc _{n[‰Tas well as ;N‰ }Bl0$N*N[‰ }/fur_{/fNNNbYNbvqQ TRbOSvNRurN TO_{OSR[rjir(Nv[bv^wsQ.\O(u0l^:N1uN NR rj_` } Nn Be_~[g[‰ }0n[‰ }v^ NY 0ĉ~ 0v^ NAQOnc%Nk hQeu gOPy0yr[rj؏yr[vvbaVspecific purpose or intent ُ1\ NNnN, ;N‰ }Bl ؏nYBl  _N1\/fyr[aVspecific intent/dolus specialis 0l^:N 0ĉ~ 0,{30ag,{203>k/fN }Rgl an element analysis approach :N9hncv ُN rjRgl a crime analysis approach R}YvS  N T z^v_` }Mn~k*Nyr[rjvir( }NO[0(W NR`Q N rjvN,;N‰ }_n1 ur gameans to SNyr[L:N ^g/aVwith the will//intent _wrj~gvSub\/faƋ0R,g N ^gSuvundesired ~g Ock8^Su 2 uraƋ0R Ny`b_b~g\Ock8^Su 0 Eea T fw S fv/f ra / jǏ dolus BlX[(Wa_volitional Tas well as Ƌcognitive V }0N, 9hnca_V }[vis-a-vis ƋV }vq_Tstrength ra/jǏS g Nyb_`forms 1  ,{Ny z^vvcra dolus directus in the first degree b vcEea direct intent 2  ,{Ny z^vvcra dolus directus in the second degree _N1\/f cEea oblique intention 3  c:kȋL:N /Sradolus eventualis 8^/fc;N‰b/ gau_/ǏNOsubjective or advertent recklessness 0,g^:N 0ĉ~ 0,{30ag,{203>kS+T$Ny z^vra/jǏ ,{Ny z^vvcra b vcEea BlurwSknow vQ\O:Nb N\O:NOwill Nubring about rjvir( }v^and &^@wNubring about 勯rjvYir( }ve[?ag/aVpurposeful will/intent [eُN\O:Nb N\O:N0(Wُyra-N 8^X[(Wprevalent a_ } V:Nuryr+R ^gb?aa_purposefully wills or desires to attain l_ybkv~g0 ,{Ny z^vvcra v^ NBlur[Eb gNurjir( }vaVb?ag S/fBluraƋ0Raware ُNir( }QNN/falmost vQ\O:Nb N\O:Nv_6qinevitable ~g OY ur aƋ0RN,OSu~g 0(Wُy`Q N a_ }'Y'YMNOv^Ƌ }overridden OY SaƋ0RvQ\O:Nb N\O:N O will [cause  N`Suv undesired ybk~g0N,{ Nyrab_`bNUONyf:N{_vjǏb_`form of culpability l^:N,{30ag-Nv^ NX[(W V:N 9hncN`vN,SU\Su will occur in the ordinary course of events v(u1\I{NcdNvQNrab_`09hnceINe,g ʑ  ~g OSu will occur 1\/f(uNhNy NSMQ0W/_6q0W inevitably g_expected vNir0 OSu N 9hncN`vN,SU\ v~TnZi0Wf@bBlvSuhQcяS_6q/nx[certainty 01\dk l^?aabُyhQLu[:N [Enx[ virtual/practical certainty hQ _N1\/f~gOSu  cd;bkrj[( }Suv*g`0*gg_vr^pb0keu ُyhQؚN c:kȋL:N vhQ  N?aSuv~gNN/fNyS likelihood/possibility vzSu0Vdk YgzlՋVmv c:kȋL:N 1\OO(u SSu may occur b 9hncN`vN,SU\SSu might occur in the ordinary course of events ُ7h1\SNS+T US~v NSKm'`bS'` mere eventuality or possibility N/fNPN cяS_6qb[Enx[ near inevitability or virtual certainty 0[ 0Wlĉ~ 0zlSS  dolus eventualis nfl(u T advertent recklessness HQQs(WIHh-N0TS Rd N؏3ufMRN 9hncN`vN,SU\OSu hQ N T _NnZi0Whfzlea(WdkmvُyjǏ z^degrees of culpability 0Vdkl^:Nd^fur\/faƋ0R9hncN`vN,SU\0Sudk{|rj^\N[eqQ TRv[Eyr[~gvirtually certain consequence &TR1\ Nur gahave intended to [eNUOccrj0,g^ea(u de lege ferenda SN [(Wl de lege lata :NNib'Yʑ,{30ag ib _ɋlQ0,{N qQ Tckr[[eqQ TR\[[brjvir(NvfwTcS09hncqQ Tckrttheory of co-perpetration nv,{N*N;N‰ }/f1 qQ TckrvNaƋmutual awareness 0R [eqQ TRO[rjir(Nv[bNS2 NN;Rawith the purposeful will/intent to ǑSLR0_Srjir( } baƋ0R9hncNirvck8^SU\ [bir(N1\O/fvQLRv[Eyr[virtually certain ~g0,{ N [OvQNvQN TOc6Rrj[E`Qvfw09hncc6RrjvqQ Tckrt gTN*Nnv;N‰N/fur[OvQNvQN TOc6Rrj[E`Qvfw0ُNhQBl1 uraƋ0R](W[erjǏ z-Nv8h_\O(u2 9hncُy8h_\O(u urY;bkfrustrate rjv[eimplementation Vdk_N1\Y;bkrjv[bcommission 09hnc NhQ l^v[~/fur:ON[erjv_aVthe requisite intent Vdk_N1\l g_~~Q/f&T&{TqQ Tckri_-NvvQYO$N*N;N‰ }0h[[c0R9*N }PNfurvrj_`0l^:NsSOX[(W qQ TR qQ Tckrv,{N[‰ } urvrjaV_N*gnxz0,{N h[[y(W,gHh^\e{:SKNMR200102002 urf~>mc eP unpaid vMLC [Su[s^lv:_xY0mRrj N@brjLN*gm0R`Z vQ-N g*NQNl^ϑR{_0TSfMQjr0,g^:NurvrjaV NNvQǏSvL:N\OQN,'`co0(WegNN-NSuNyr[rj v^ N_6qasT@wOS_6q0WQ!kSu T{|rj0dkY (W{|mc eP vMLCvl N:NO0_N_ N0RHhNwS[/ec0l^ w NQ>mcePN @gT:_xY gUOT|sSOSN mR gsQ _N_ N0R,gHhnc/ec0=\{l gsё FO/fu;m9(u؏/f1uLRc%c[bُ1\elc[uraƋ0R9hncNirvN,SU\ mRO/fNy>mcv[Eyr[~g0h[[_Nl gʑdN eP NY ؏X[(WNHN {|f:ON|nx'`0,{ N >mc hQCgNt carte blanche 0h[[yur[hQN(W2001t^vrj 2002t^Q!k>mc 1\I{NbُynN hQCgNt vAQsX N AQ[e:_xY0wRTmR gj NZ0ce(WdkNNO`N*NN,{15S N_Nc0R hQCgNt N͋ FO/fNv݋틃X N/eccecNS/fh[Lv'`(T z^vbċ0O NS fur,gNvNUOnZib NnZivcCgNvċ0ONN/f s` suppositions ُ/fN]v(u   >mctVYbQeqS;`~;NO}T 1\I{N_NaLRvcCg  SSSvQowgPTLuvc6R 0l^:Nv;NO}T/ftYVbQeqS;`~ v^ NasT@w1\ꁨR_rjcCg>mcQec_N N1\/f[rjvfw0R[Eyr[ z^0,{V ǏLulec%c[vo0h[[yǏLule MLCc%c[fnxc:y@g.b-N^s^l v^N,{47SNXdsummary statements :N (W-N^vsR_ `ONl g6rk0YP[Ti[P[0`ON/fSSbN0`ON@g.bv^gdkNR& & s].!ZS>m`ONS@g.b N/fSsv 0l^:NXdvfR]~_NO ؏NvQNncelOSNdkY ͋_Nl gR_TNs] v^l g>f:ys](W:WbYdkc:y0f͑v/f N͋_NNce,{40SN͋wvv;NNR/f1  thQLeN 02  OkSl ;`~ ,{6SN_Nf ;eQs^lݏ̀ OkS;`~CgR v[EO}T0Vdk ce NfuraV(W-N^ gdkNR 0`\@gs^l0,{N MLCXuQ[[NvH0ceOnc,{22023SNHcy (Ws^lmGk[e MLCXuQ[[Ne6q`ON/f1uMRSSfkňc6Rvs^l `ON1\^\NSSfkň VdkMbOm0R;eQ 0vQ[ NS/f^TXHQuS-N^;`~ }TN`\@g2-10\KNv?Qz Vdk /fs]Ydk}TN 1\/fc[ e_NcQbMLCXuQXfNs]KNl gsQ|0ce؏c_,{47SN͋Xd[NJTw  a"s] bN gx^N-N^YsY'`N 0ec_Y͋NNSQ0l^:N,{47SN͋Xd,gfR gP Yg NNvQNncvNpS N:NOMLCXuQXf,gv^ NnZib+T|0Whfs] gǏ:_xYcCg Nfs] gdkra0,{mQ s]N^TXvvcT~8^'`T~0ce:Ns]N^TX~8^T~ wSv^aVrjSu0FO/fce>f6qnc N0hQvsQnc>f:y1 Ǐ[0Wċ0OOVS^TX NvbJT ^TXwSuNmRT:_xYrj2 (Ws]T^TXKN\SuǏ$N!k5u݋N3 NN NwS5u݋NvwQSOQ[ S g,{37SN^TX|TTs]>mcXc0Vdk l^ NnxO^TXJTwNs] gsQrjN[ ce;N _l gOnc0,{N =\{NTy nS`rjN[v^NNb0tSN6q~~[eqQ TrjR01uNMRmQy;N _GW Nbz @bNvQYO3*N;N _ N;e4x0cePRgcv&qp݋0 0Wlĉ~ 0e g~b0f gRe ĉv[ z^SeMRO06q =\{gNl[b #Nb__ Ɖ:N rj['`  FO/f weg 0rjN 0v6R[ NN:N6q  0rjN 0-Nl gĉ[ N T #Nb__ vgbN0ckYdk YUOnxRtNʑ gPvĉ 1\b:Nf[TSl[vNR0,gQv EQRt euwQ g~xQaIN0:NN NpbqN SO| N N NbbRċ0 l^cQqQ Tckr#NNc%c[b N~#N N T0:NNf}Y0WtT gNagSR1\/f` g(WX[(Wl[\O:NINRe MbSNc[Q N\O:NvRN#N0,{28agS:SRQ$N{| N~SvQsQ| _N1\/fQNb{|NgbLQNc%c\O(uv FO/fǏc%cagN[ N gHec6R@wVSO0VEyrl^MRWSl^0bSel^ 1u$RO(WHQSN[ Nbl_ Nb:N gc%c#Nv N~ l g ck_l_cCg formal legal authority Nb:NcdRN#Nvt1u0Vdk ُy{|f2bS fN gHe{ 0-Nv c%c /fc {authority/CgR yr+R/fc6RfkňvCgR   { 1\/fc N}TNT:_6RgbLvCgRpower bCg)R 06q e6qe,gO(u b \$N_ :NN㉳Qe,ghbQX l^S:N$NX[(WNyяmcTedVvCgR0l^cQfur gHec6R _{f/f(Wyr[vektime frame &TR1\ NEQR0ُ1\/f gHec6R NrjL:NKNv4Ne]Ttemporary coincidence 0yrl^vbO/f_{(WrjL:NSueX[(W gHec6R0,g^:N\(WrjsS\Sue urX[(W gHec6R0@b *gۏLS_c6R hf(WrjSuKNMR N~]~c6R0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn44" \o "" [42],{ N rjvSu/fV:Nur*gYUc6RQ N 0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn45" \o "" [43]l^cQ,{28ag,{1>knx[NNy sQ| link  \O:N& v~g as a result of 1\/fcُysQ|relationship 0@bN ُ1\/f(W N~vu_#Nthe superior s dereliction of duty N gsQrjKNS+TNyVgsQ|causality 0ُN%Nk,{2yĉ[N NyINR2bk06RbkTcNrj T$NyINRX[(WNrjKN-NbrjKNT0TNN;v~O/f N=\T$NyINR 1\Ob:NSurjvVn'`SVretroactively cause 0Vdkl^:NVgsQ| }the element of causality SNc%c[2bk*gegrjSuvINR gsQ06q N~(WrjKN-NbrjKNTb Ne\L6Rbk0cNINRNSu*gegrjKNX[(WVgq_Tcausal impact 0V:NRZwQ g2bk*gegrjvV g:g @bNc%c[b N`ZǏSvrj1\Slikely XRSu*gegrjvqSirisk 0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn47" \o "" [45]tN,{28ag,{1>kl g~ĉ[Vg^the level of causality 1\S(u but for test  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn48" \o "" [46]hQۏL$ReYgl g N~b Ne\LǑSNR_TTtce2bkrjSuvN[ Qvrj1\ NOSu0FO/f Nyg\O:Npositive act vSvTir(Heg N T N\O:Nomission vHeg N_0Rnx['`[0bcKN bNel|nxKmYgc%c[e\LN2bkrjINRSOSuNHN0enxz$NKNvvcVgsQ|direct causal link 0h[[Sfc%c[v N\O:NXRN[eccrjvqSi0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn49" \o "" [47],{V urwSbt^wS0,g^͑3u 0ĉ~ 0l gĉ[%Nkĉ[N$N*NhQvjǏ },{Ny|1u wS knew h BlX[(W[Efwactual knowledge ,{Ny|1u t^wS h [E N/fNyǏ1Yb_`form of negligence 0,{Ny wS NS c[ presumed vS _{ gvcvbccKmvcircumstantial, ^vccKmv nc0VEyrl^v~y 2010t^5gQHr0   HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref1" \o "" * ,gevQ\O_0R\Orz;Nc_N/f/UNSRN v-NNSNlqQTVYe萺Ne>yOyf[xvzyvDёDRS08JA820008 ,ge؏/f\Orz;Nc_N/f/UNSRN vSlyvybQS07SFB5015 0-NVlf[OSD08052 NSў_lwYeSyvS11534046 0\O;NcvT\n]N'Yf[lf[b2009t^J\Ye^ReWё hQwl_efNvQ\OĉRSvQNy2008t^Hr ,{90-101u HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ VERNSlefNvQ\Oyr_  NVERNlb`RTHhNeN:NO } 0-NVlf[Ol_efNxvzO2007t^f[/gt^OeƖ 0 ,{82-92uI{I{0{؏(W,gO2008t^t^ONSvQNTyV0QY͑f[/gO NY!kcRُyVEl_efN[xvzv^_S TN^ltQ0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref4" \o "" [2] {R6R cVERNWvllr` |SHtQoYec RNll t_/TS ZPvVEU\_ _N/f{[VESlefNvt_W@x0SS HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ TNLuv VERNll   [VERlvNy2006t^Hr ,{516-549u HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ VERNllTNLuv^~O }uy_[;N] 0TNLuvRNll 0-NVRlf[O2006t^t^OeƖ  NwS -NVNllQ['Yf[QHr>y2006t^Hr ,{116-124u HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ 0VERNSl6R^ 0 T\n]N'Yf[QHr2006t^Hr ,{313uSvQN NI{I{0 VERNll _N/f VERlTf[ v8h_}T0 VERlTf[ ,g_N/f,ge\OvR 0S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ VERlTf[b_`0}TNz:W }HtQo[;N] 0RNlċ 0,{20wS SN'Yf[QHr>y2007t^Hr ,{566-609uI{I{0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref5" \o "" [3]  Appearance of justice _NSыy hbckIN 0S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ VERNlbh[[:N hbckIN b  |Q hbckIN i_Tt_v_ۏNc!P }HtQo[;N] 0RNlċ 0,{22wS SN'Yf[QHr>y2008t^7gHr ,{578-618uI{I{0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref6" \o "" [4] VERNlb NɋR^l[:N Hes_N/flQs^v~bR 0FO/fNɋ`[  lQs^CNVESlv8h_NyOv Sl;mR _{N Q ݋ g ;mR _ g Q l g Q v;mR NƉ:Nck_v Sl;mR 0VESl[Yegll>yO `N` NS9e 0Wlĉ~ 0lĉ_N/fُ7hBlv0vQ!k VERNSlSS N0 MRy SvQN_Y  ll RRwek (Na^g0Ydk llR~6k  N/f ll/T6k  lQs^ v W\e OagR_HQL 'Y Hes v le~ 6k\*g0Reg0N_e܏0 N 'YÍۏ ?el0~NmYdk ll_NYdkVQllYdk VEllfeOY0gT  VESl N,/fSlvgؚS  lQs^ vXLuvzzYUO N,/fll>yONNl>yOvqQ TsQlN8h_sQl0ckYgVEl[o@b [NVERNSl lQs^1\/fNR vQNSNbaba xd"} 0  VESl Ydk  VERNSl f^Ydk V:NRNSl^ TN,0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref7" \o "" [5] ICC-01/04-01/06-803-tEN, 14-05-2007l;NRg`R h[[ɋbSsRQ157u ; ICC-01/04-01/07-717, 01-10-2008l;NRg`R h[[ɋaSfWRT]Q226u ; ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009-N^qQTV`R h[[ɋ!ZSQ186u .  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref8" \o "" [6] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 184-186. wQSOQNyNqQ8y0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref9" \o "" [7] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 3-4.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref10" \o "" [8] S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ 0VERNSl6R^ 0 T\n]N'Yf[QHr>y2006t^Hr ,{85-190u0ُ/fVQf[Lu[,gHh!kU\_v|~TSY'`xvz0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref11" \o "" [9] S HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" [eP:_ RlwƋb_`vteT[ }HtQo[;N] 0RlwƋb_` 0 nNS'Yf[QHr>y2009t^3gHr ,{Nz ,{29-57u0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref12" \o "" [10] NtEQRvBl҉^[ bNvBly2007t^Hr0fNvnxl g tet Q{|kl gĉ[ lN b USMO rj 20ckr SbUSrckr0qQ Tckr0cckr,{3>k,{1y 30qQr SbYeUr,{3>k,{203y N^\ NckreBb*gB:NbzagN 0.^Rr//eRr,{3>k,{304y N^\ NckreBb*gB:NbzagN 40r/}qRr,{3>k,{5yvclQ6q}qRNNmpy 50*gB-Nbk,{3>k,{6y N c*gBYZ 0Ydk  lNrj 0 rjY 0 Y-Nbk 0 *gB-Nbk NS YYeU 0 Y.^R I{ N/frj0ُkbVl[ rjb_`W z_Y0N Nl[ rjb_` -Nv jǏb_` /f Eea Sb vvr  L:Nb__ ;N/f \O:N 0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref28" \o "" [26] 0Wlĉ~ 0,{28ag/f c%c[TvQN N~v#N Nag =\{(W[R-NvЏ(uSf:NA~0SOsVEɋyrr FON,{25agĉ[v *NNRN#N ~xQ!j_6q N T0ckYdk l[[T #NN vRg[NfYv;NSO0{0Cg0r`I{ [‰ } ُ_N/fĉaIN Nvl[Bl0dkY (Wُyyrkv rjb_` -N  jǏb_` e g Eea N,/f wS 0yr+R/f t^wS T Eea NtO _N gǏ1YsS N2bk0 N6Rbk0 NcN _N1\/fs_L[ba `L#  L:Nb__ _N;N/f N\O:N yr[vNTr` }Nyr[v Eea T N\O:N ~T(WNw 1\b_bdk{| rjb_` b SN!j_ vzQyr_0ُ/fzlrNag0:S+RNv9h,gSV _N/fl[[ #Nb__ N T0rj_N N T vl[t1u0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref29" \o "" [27] 9hnc 0Wlĉ~ 0,{61ag[$RMRnxcc ,{7>kvĉ[ [l^g~SNOlZPQ nx b b~nx ccT f\P,T Ny N TQ0 f\P,T vt1uTBlS g$Ny#NeEQ>Nbg O9eNycc V:N@bcQvnc>f6qgbSNy,glb{Qvrj 01\T f[t N{dkMRN6q N,O:Nzl/fc j TdN v`Q OYb qS[N{|j \O:N mpyj cc  ُ_Nck/f[tONy^XeT,glb[ς9Nrj`Rv['`Rgk S NǏN(WɋMR1\㉳QN0FO/f,gHhɋ`f_NSb #N!j_dN v`Q0V:Nl^dkMR@b Vh[[cc['` f\P,gHhnxwɋ,T 1\/fWN #N!j_dN 0l^:N9hnc>k,{1-2yT,{3yBl@bZPQvQ[ (W'`( N[hQ N T,gĉ[v;Nvv(WN\Pbk,T NO㉳QncbN[vl_['`:w ۏ MQl^(W,g6k1\[( Ng~Ql^(Wdk6k N_f N Trj vBl~[_n l^SۏLNy hb prima facie $RecceN[ gsQN[vl_['`X[(Wu0sQN N Trj vi_ [ NFOmSl[j T ؏mS#N!j_SNrjv!j_ N T rjv[([‰ N1\O[hQ N T  rj v~g N T \O:N;Nr0Nrb N~v*NN#N_NO N T\O:NɋvSlONjudicial guarantor of the proceedings l^_{nxOcceNNsQ,gHhɋ;N G g͑'YSf_{JTwSeS_NN 9hnc 0ĉ~ 0,{67ag,{1>k,{1yJTNvCg)R vĉ[ Ygl^ NQ#N!j_ 1\ONulQs^ V:NJTOeR:Y NJTNSfTO(uv틇e ŏ~JTwccv'`(0SVTQ[ vl[Cg)R NS_cNa:gOvCg)RsQN QOcc agvv(uwQ g[~g'` h[[Q[/f&TOvsQcc l^eaOrh[[vL b[YS_vccb^h[[YUOg}Y0WwIcceN N/f,g^r^v;m?Q YUOOncl[L#Sb Nnx[build and shape wɋHhN/fh[[vL# l^vL#/f(W[ɋ-NLOSlvcwLv^Ol NQ9hnc >f6q hQ \O:N z^'`Q l^ N[ncۏLmeQRg ُ̑ScSyr[ncbTez:W _N NOQ[( /U gYdk l^MbSNMQ1\ gsQۏLQbel^:N,{28ag[v#N!j_ N TvrjSN!j_ v^*g_0REQR㉳Q s gnc>f:y Nrgb N Tvrj#N!j_ _N1\/f,{28agĉ[v#N!j_l^gTQf\P,TBlh[[PgQOcceNSv#N!j_ v^meQRg]cNnce0[ePgV^ecc60evnxwɋQ~{SgPgTa6e0RKNew͑e{0See ICC-01/05-01/08-388, 04-03-2009.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref30" \o "" [28] 0rjN 0 N,'`[ ,{9>kĉ[ NyL:NSgbNjbpej 0ُ/f jpe vl[SR vzzYUOt VERlvf[t\*g~U\_09hnc %Ny1996t^Hr ,{152-153u0ُ̑v NyL:N ^S_/fc NywQSOrj b Nyyr[ } NS/f N{|L:N b Y*Nj(v TvL:N f NS/f Y*Nj( N TvL:N  cgqbNvl 1\/f NL:N 0 NL:N  SgbNj bN[ft b  Sgb  pej ~[QbNvt\ z0gqdkt Yg NyL:N OY @g s^l Te/f(W qS[N{|j T bNj v 틃X } N[ev 1\S Tebz$Nj  -NVJ\ VERNlb!jbl^'Y[ vYpe ɋr /fُ7hZPv {S_sSsQlv^(ُN vQNċ[l[S_eHN*gla0HN q N0HNNTRgk%N͑ vnxfWyr_ VdkNRgvQ^\'`0 rj틃X ,geg/f [‰v FO/fl[0S_NNcSe TSNN[N0l^KNS0V[l_NtNI{ /f N 0SS/fNQv  rj틃X ieOY0Q/fNQvN NSMQ;N‰'`0HN  rj틃X Rgvzz^\N[‰ }؏/f;N‰ }Yg^\N ;N‰ }Rg ,gev8h_~KNNHQ[‰0T;N‰ 1\&T0Vdk _{㉳QُN0bNHQۏL ĉ V~0 0rjN 0 N,'`[ ,{7>k(Wu_ HQ[‰0T;N‰ vSR N b vsQv̀of`QR(WgT  ,{NagqS[N{|j  [ ,{2>k,{NSĉ[  kyqS[N{|jvgTNyNcL:NSuev_̀of`Q  ,{kQagbNj  [ ,{3>kĉ[{|f06q VERNlbvɋefNNɋ z^RR}YPN ĉ !k^ rj틃XRg HQL0{:NُyRg`/fTtv V:N[f&{T}Y0WfVErjNzlvyrkBl v^NُNl|`~yr_W,gesQ NNvN,t'` gsQ0dkY {؏:N [‰ } N [[‰ }vH /f$N*N N TNir0Vdk iR NvNN/f rj틃X ,gvzz/f[‰v؏/f;N‰vN (WH SvQ `7hH N,geem0{:N rj틃X ,g/f[‰v N/f;N‰v [rj틃XvH _N^S_=\ϑ[‰0MQ;N‰0N[ N (WVERNlb N/fh[[؏/fl[_N/fُ7h:Nv2008t^6g20e ce[ aSfWRvNtN1\h[[vb2INRSh wl TecQ\PbkɋvvsQ3u NNV^ (W0Rh[[:NNgte*Nrj`R Oo`n^lcODee h[[ @bSvOo`SNOceg`Y[(W[‰W@x Non an objective basis [hQ&{TceOlnxzN[vL# 0ICC-01/04-01/07-619, 20-06-2008, pp. 4-5, para. 5, lines 7-9. 2008t^12g2e [$RN^ N sQNƉ,TRvisual aids vQ vQ-Nc0Rcef~;N _ :NNONl^t@bccrjv틃X[‰ }the contextual, objective elements of the crimes alleged ^S_AQO(u Ɖ,TR ICC-01/04-01/06-1371, para. 11 ُyl_0Rl^S0See ICC-01/04-01/06-1528, 02-12-2008, p. 5, para. 9.bNSN N^ TNN Hrj틃X ve_el FO/fbN~[ NVdk&T[ rj틃X,g/f_N^S_/f [‰v 0iR NvNN/f[‰v rj틃X /f [‰ } T9hncVERNlbl_efNwQSOcQ[[ bvT{Hh/fYpe/f =\{ NN[hQ/f0@b Ype/f 1\/fc;N/fHl[vT[‰v vsQ/_̀of`Q @b NhQ/f 1\/fc:NNޏ/0YU0WHl[v vsQ/_̀of`Q *N+Rv NxQW~_N Nweu vv؏/f:NNMR0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref32" \o "" [30] lȃُv sQ| nexus N^\N rjL:N ,gSO } /fcwQSOv @gL:NN {|j T @bBlv 틃X } ^lb|~0W;eQs^l KNvsQ| VdkN VgsQ| causal link N/f TIN0 NX[(Wُy 틃X sQ| Sbznf@gNjbvQNrj FO NObz qS[N{|j v @g 0kĉ[ rjNN, cgq NRSR~~1 rjN:_NkyrjvsQvL:N0TgT`Q VdkN, cdkz^_R2 _v_tN >e(WSvQq_TvL:N0Tgb`QKNT3 vsQv̀of`Q>e(WgT0 ُ1\/f N,'`l[Bl 0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref34" \o "" [32] lȃُv sQ| ^\N rjL:N ,gSO } /fNy~xQvVgsQ| eN 틃XsQ| N^\N TNNir _N N/fnxz c%c[b N~#N @bBlvyrk VgsQ|  rjqSiXR 0/f&TSN(WY`Q N VErjvVgsQ|wQ g YT'`  Vg_ SvQfhQv^ NN0ُy YBg'`/f1uL:NNv N T SN!j_ participating mode Q[v0Vdk NbVERl-NvVgsQ|{USS(W TNHhN-N [VgsQ|vfbfwQ g]_'`0S_6q؏{la  sQ| _N N/f VgsQ| NN 틃XsQ| m T0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref35" \o "" [33] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 45-56.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref36" \o "" [34] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 56-67. ُ1\f[v Tj T Nv N TwQSOrjvRgSO|Oc%Nfvu B(Wck_Q-N~_[‰ }0vTY;N‰ }0ُv^fl[(W Hh`Omȉ0[g Ǐ z-N_N T7h/f ~_[‰ }0vTY;N‰ }   ُ[E N_N NS V:Nh[[vccfNv^ N/fُ7hc^v l[_N NS ~_ 0YUOOmȉ0[g/fNVN YUOQ/fSNVN0QvfNb; NI{NOmȉ0[gv[E; =\{$N~8^N0Q/f`~gvfNbh yrp/f vTY[ Omȉ0[gǏ z1\ NSُ7h yr+R/fOmȉ0[g YBgvVErjHhN0,gev VErjSO| ;Nvv/f_n ^S_YUO` Omȉ0[g 0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref40" \o "" [38] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 114-139.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref41" \o "" [39] VQf[Y HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/ldq/" \t "_blank" R'Y0>QQ0bS gf[I{ VYfY U` N~_0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref42" \o "" [40] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, p. 142, para. 408. f[f(Wg͑VE[W NcQT VEwɋT[$R/f&TNN[ 'YNir /f&TOb_bNyVE`O v ,gQ]~~QfnxT{Hh0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref43" \o "" [41] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 142-143, paras 409-410.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref44" \o "" [42] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 143-148, paras 411-419.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref45" \o "" [43] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 148-151, paras 420-426.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref46" \o "" [44] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, p. 149, para. 423. FO/fُN,gHh l^KNS 'YfVETh[[vz:Wv^ NN0'YfVE:NVgsQ| N/fc%c[#N }09hnc`N`VEl N~#NBl1 X[(W N N~sQ|2 N~fw N[erj3 N~*g6Rbk02bkb`Zrj0(W N NN $RehQ-N l gBl N~v N\O:Nvc[ Nrj0vS N~ N\O:NN gsQrjKNvsQ|S/fS gHec6RBlv6R~  N~wQ gq_T NL:Nv[ER  N/fNyrzvVgsQ| }0ICC-01/05-01/08-406, 20-04-2009, pp. 19-20, para. 30. 'YfVE؏cQ N\f[ 0ĉ~ 0 :Nl_[NNyevVgsQ|0[E N l_l gBl N~ N\O:N[ Nrj 0ĉ~ 0l gOPy`N`VEl0sSOۏLVgnx cknxvʑ/f N~v N\O:NXRN NrjvΘi0ICC-01/05-01/08-406, 20-04-2009, p. 20, para. 31. 2009t^4g27e h[[V Y'YfVE l^KNS av^h:y^ T,{28agl gĉ[YvVgsQ| }0 N~KN@bNRN#N 1\/fV:Nl gۏLc6R0_N1\/f N~wSb^S_wSrjck(WSub]~[e tSb NǑSceNN;bkb`Z0ُ1\/f@b \O:Nb NۏLYUc6Rv~g v;N+TIN0ICC-01/05-01/08-412, 27-04-2009, p. 3, para. 4. h[[؏:NYg^fVgsQ| h[[Sf N~vb N\O:NL:NXRN N[eyr[rjvΘiYg(ufؚvhQ 1\Ol[VgsQ|Bl0ICC-01/05-01/08-412, 27-04-2009, p. 4, para. 5.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref47" \o "" [45] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, p. 150, para. 424.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref48" \o "" [46] VVgsQ|t SB\!kSV -Nv N[SV hlQ_ Ygl gAB0C& 1\l gZ RAB0C& 1\/fZSuvN[SV 0ُ*NlQ_/fVgsQ|tv[‰W@x v^ N/fRlVgsQ|v[IN0lQ_ N㉳Q YBgVgsQ| OY qQ TSV b SVvbǏ'Y vS_N agN 0SPi i 0VRl 0 SN'Yf[QHr>y1996t^Hr ,{64-65u0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref49" \o "" [47] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 150-151, para. 425. ُN'YfVETh[[vz:WN0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref50" \o "" [48] ُN'YfVEz:WN T:N 0ĉ~ 0:_SNc%c[#N N`N`VEl0Yg N/f [EwS actual knowledge /U g(WJTwon notice Nrje `N`VElMbbc%c[#N0FO/f 0ĉ~ 0XRN ^S_/t^wS should have known ُ7h1\b`N`VEl-Nv mgJThQ the passive notice standard SbǑSceN Nrjvf:NygvINRa more active duty 0ICC-01/05-01/08-406, 20-04-2009, p. 3, para. 3.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref51" \o "" [49] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 151-155, paras 427-434.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref52" \o "" [50] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 155-159, paras 435-443.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref53" \o "" [51] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 159-184, paras 444-501. egn: 0RNlċ 0,{26wS dDFFHPR *!!""""#`###++++<-\-F/d/v//n99CCDDDDFFGG G"GKKLL"L$LFNHNHOJOROTOW谗谗谗谗谗0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph3h#h#6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJphU-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph;WWXXXY4Y6Y6Z8Z@ZBZ[[\\\\__``````aaaac>d@dHdJdgg2i@i>k@k@lBlJlLlDnFnFoHoPoRo:tuFuHuuuv͚͚3h#h#6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph(    lnց؁ށlnւ؂ނ$&,.ĆƆ|~DFJLRT8:>@FH8:>@FH0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJphGD886ƢVDfx8Prr $dP1$a$gd#H "(*•ĕ,.46ėƗ "*,"$ &(0268>@̳̳̳̳̳̳̳̳̳̳̳0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphF@HJƢȢΣУأڣVX^`hj&(DFLNVXfhnpxzxz8:@BJL  j˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴˴-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph?jPRXZbdrtz| `lrtz|prxz"ββββββββΙβββββ3h#h#5B*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h#h#6B*CJKHOJQJ]^JaJph2rp$TX|8."V     $1$a$gd# $dP1$a$gd#"$,.$&,.68 &(02$&TV\^fhXZ`bjl|~ "8:-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJphG:@BJL.068@B"$*,46    V X ^ ` h j    ̳̳̳̳̳̳̳蜘h&y-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h#h#>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh#h#B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h#h#B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph+0182P. A!"#$%S EDd,  c :ANormalFax01C"jP src="/webcount/count.asp?newsid=39260"b!X󆡑NBD>nX󆡑NBPNG  IHDRfsRGB@}0PLTE{bIDATE!0Eq^uM&VUp\ &C|)"3.8̴(6 jPtsʄ&)NU- \^w& ^eyƾ_c|_^9IENDB`Dd V  3 C"J ((N@N cke $1$a$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ ؞k=W[SOBi@B nfh*S*Y(ph"W`" #p5\$' "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& "& !"& ""& #"& $"& %"& &"& '"&H 4 9 $K*.3>9>BIEO]S4X^fklrpxXT{cLwͳlE  ^ > .` . ) !%"#$%&{ZdH u `4HV  -Rv .Sw .Sx /Vz3X}4Y~7\7\<a 9 ^ !/!T!s!!!!!""G"l"""""#A#g######$H$m$$$$$%;%&(&&K**+.>2777798:U:';d<D>a>@@AFBfBBCF?NEO1PQPPPPPQRRUUWbXXq\\j]`ghhikBnauwuvwHBDFNhh!%عTۼg/nKY3[S]*r s;r ?)r s;r s;r s;r s;r $r I@;r ]r /Cr Tr r 6 r s;r s;r {?r s;r .r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r dr s;r Y r .Lr Y r $r Tr ƒer Щr s;r s;r s;r &r ?)r s;r vr &r 7r s;r !r r $r ?)r s;r r Y r .r 3sr r $r s;r vr s;r s;r s;r $r Y r dr c2r ?)r {?r r s;r 7r s;r dr /Cr 2r dr s;r &r ?)r .Lr Щr s;r r }R*r '7r &r &r s;r vr s;r dr r ?)r c2r r 7r r s;r s;r vr vr vr s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r Y r s;r s;r s;r s;r s;r &r &r w~r r Mr $r r $r s;r vr s;r vr &r s;r s;r Y r s;r s;r s;r .Lr s;r ?)r vr dr s;r s;r s;r r {ZdH u `4HV  -Rv .Sw .Sx /Vz3X}4Y~7\7\<a 9 ^ !/!T!s!!!!!""G"l"""""#A#g######$H$m$$$$$%;%&(&&K**+.>2777798:U:';d<D>a>@@AFBfBBCF?NEO1PQPPPPPQRRUUWbXXq\\j]`ghhikBnauwuvwHBDFNhh!%عTۼg/nKY3[S]*I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I00I00I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0@I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0@I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0{ZdH u `4HV  -Rv .Sw .Sx /Vz3X}4Y~7\7\<a 9 ^ !/!T!s!!!!!""G"l"""""#A#g######$H$m$$$$$%;%&(&&K**+.>2777798:U:';d<D>a>@@AFBfBBCF?NEO1PQPPPPPQRRUUWbXXq\\j]`ghhikBnauwuvwHBDFNhh!%عTۼg/nKY3[S]*I0@I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I00I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0@hI00 8"nwdWvH@j": ~    6>FNwԭr   OS q*./"&SW   TXgksw&'')**.4447f8k8r:::Q???!CCCHDDDENFSFM8N=NN>OCO.TTTX:Y?YHYYYYlZqZZT[Y[_z``Laaabbbb9c>cde ee/f4fyjjjkkkppptttt,u1u vvvx,y1y{o|t|AF֐W\WؓݓpuřFKfNϝԝjkotjoFɩ˩')#'+`dƬʬNѭխMQ7;˯ϯ)^b*.Uquh(,hܷ!%ع\aTػݻۼ_d#(g/{Z_nKlqLQx} !&Y3bg[z|EJSlq,1gl<A]*{XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXj_ftnref1_ftnref2_ftnref3_ftnref4_ftnref5_ftnref6_ftnref7_ftnref8_ftnref9 _ftnref10 _ftnref11 _ftnref12 _ftnref13 _ftnref14 _ftnref15 _ftnref16 _ftnref17 _ftnref18 _ftnref19 _ftnref20 _ftnref21 _ftnref22 _ftnref23 _ftnref24 _ftnref25 _ftnref26 _ftnref27 _ftnref28 _ftnref29 _ftnref30 _ftnref31 _ftnref32 _ftnref33 _ftnref34 _ftnref35 _ftnref36 _ftnref37 _ftnref38 _ftnref39 _ftnref40 _ftnref41 _ftnref42 _ftnref43 _ftnref44 _ftnref45 _ftnref46 _ftnref47 _ftnref48 _ftnref49 _ftnref50 _ftnref51 _ftnref52 _ftnref53_ftn1_ftn2_ftn3_ftn4_ftn5_ftn6_ftn7_ftn8_ftn9_ftn10_ftn11_ftn12_ftn13_ftn14_ftn15_ftn16_ftn17_ftn18_ftn19_ftn20_ftn21_ftn22_ftn23_ftn24_ftn25_ftn26_ftn27_ftn28_ftn29_ftn30_ftn31_ftn32_ftn33_ftn34_ftn35_ftn36_ftn37_ftn38_ftn39_ftn40_ftn41_ftn42_ftn43_ftn44_ftn45_ftn46_ftn47_ftn48_ftn49_ftn50_ftn51_ftn52_ftn53q/ &).47r:Q?!CHDEMN.TXHYYZ_Labbdeyjkptt vx{֐WřfNjkFNhh!%عTۼg/nKY3[S]*  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghi'X Ylx'*4l8:?CDTF>NDOT@YYrZZ[`ab?c e5fkkpt2uv2yu|G]ޓvL՝up̩*(֭/v-b޻e)`rR~'hKr2mB3S, ;*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagschsdate \` 1520096DayFalse IsLunarDate IsROCDateMonthYear PSW[ps| h:- i gpZHgpZH_UgpZH@}gpZHPgpZHEX;gpZHLbgpZH(>I!)gpZH4|6gpZH*'P\ d4\8)cBvLrM`gpZHHhvtgpZHQgRAMgpZHKgpZH #gpZHWkZcBo+,m|>gpZH cB- tb1I gpZH gpZH/ gpZHqA ^$is cBev D %5n gpZH gpZHx=f jN{)gpZHD\s[JhcBlRgpZHRzexMDFgpZHdgpZH> gpZHupcB\wgpZHMgpZH=\n.cBwucB,gpZHeEGv66T$7gpZHVSz2ZgpZHbgpZH R <=N~gpZH^gpZHVgpZH^b$gpZH!gpZHhgpZHwl3R+CIxgpZHHIbGggpZH<cBo@gpZHkWgpZH`gpZH}cBO gpZH gpZHO;igpZHwY!gpZHN!i[u5"<"gpZH15$cBqQh$cBy$gpZH^$cB{#%jfJ)%gpZHzg%cB'gpZH(+gpZHR?+gpZHI",ig@Y1.gpZH1)/gpZH1g/gpZHa_0gpZHV1gpZH{D1cBan2=| <2gpZHl^3gpZHVk 4gpZH+4 D %5cB ]w5gpZHG,5gpZHR@5cB{r6gpZH<6gpZHB6up*B7\8)gq\7gpZHLa7gpZH7{D107is UU7gpZHV%h8\mF8Y:~Kuo8gpZHh8gpZHM~9gpZHU:gpZHW:gpZHPT:gpZH2=;gpZH$ogpZHc?gpZHn@gpZH=AgpZH [A.XAWkZ;AgpZHRAcBcBgpZHX5BgpZHR+CcB{CgpZH Cj@[CgpZHuDgpZHMEP0ng8+EgpZH 7EH2m^AFgpZHF15$!6FgpZHE)GgpZH?GgpZH~VGgpZH{GgpZHgpZHY:~,NtHgpZH>IcB}IgpZHZ)IgpZH .IgpZH CKgpZHkaLgpZH+L`q~'XLgpZH2MgpZHexMcBrMcB <=NcBjNcB_UlNcB5NgpZH;NcBO[JhOgpZH\PgpZHgkPwu7mPcB QgpZH*RY:~,@RcB~ RgpZHsSgpZH%p:T-y'U TMTgpZHTcBKUgpZH-y'UcB,7DVgpZHWgpZH)XgpZHxMYgpZHSz2ZcBZgpZH*'P\cB]gpZHp]gpZHT^gpZH b_@R dagpZH7agpZH$bgpZHJbgpZH tbcBRdcBve6=6egpZH]egpZHjfcB2]ggpZHigcBbGgcBjhgpZH =igpZHWOigpZHsOjgpZHjcBHjRdH2mcBJ$mgpZH\mcBUndo\ncBP0ncB$^ oR@5b$ogpZHdocB[ozg%LnogpZHp}9p;NW%:pgpZHMXzpgpZHahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref41-;ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref40-x8ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref39-x5ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref38-x2ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref37-x/ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref36-x,ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref35-x)ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref34-x&ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref33-x#ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref32-x ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref31-xahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref30-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref29-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref28-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref27-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref26-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref25-y ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref24-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref23-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref22-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref21-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref20-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref19-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref18-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref17-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref16-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref15-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref14-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref13-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref12'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref11'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref10-rahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref9-sahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref8-|ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref7-}ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref6'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-~ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref5'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref4'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-xahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref3-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref2-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref1 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn53 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn52 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn51 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn50 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn49 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn48 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn47 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn46 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn45 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn44 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn43 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn42 ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn41 ~ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn40 {ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn39 xahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn38 uahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn37 rahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn36 oahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn35 lahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn34 iahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn33 fahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn32 cahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn31 `ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn30 ]ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn29 Zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn28 Wahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn27 Tahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn26 Qahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn25 Nahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn24 Kahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn23 Hahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn22 Eahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn21 Bahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn20?ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn19<ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn189ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn176ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn163ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn150ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn14-ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn13*ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn12'ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn11$ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn109.!ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn99.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn89.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn79.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn69.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn59.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn49.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn39. ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn2'5 http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/9.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn1'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/Vhttp://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~      !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ\]^_`abdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry F02qNmData 1TabletWordDocument2$SummaryInformation([DocumentSummaryInformation8cxsCompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q